Rustic eatery with a fireplace & patio for American bistro fare & over 50 international whiskeys. Based on 685 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
10 S Hanover St, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone: (717) 960-1000
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Alex Rogers
This was my jam. A massive whiskey list, I chose a flight and was pleasantly surprised by the inclusion of Japanese and French whiskey. The food was also fantastic. My wife’s Bolognese was super flavorful and the bison burger I had was cooked perfectly with tender onion rings on top. I would recommend for whiskey lovers.
… more
Dan Snyder
This place was fabulous. More whiskey cocktail choices than you can imagine. And the onion rings… we’ve had them all over the US, and these here hands done THE BEST!! Corrin was a very attentive server, thank you so much!
… more
Heather Shuler
You walked in nervous because we were arriving late. But we’re greeted with it extremely friendly staff. They informed us we were 10 minutes before closing for the kitchen but took us anyway we both felt bad because we didn’t want to intrude. Staff went above and beyond super helpful and amazing choice recommendations. We ordered the bourbon chicken and the wagyu ravioli. Absolutely phenomenal I recommend their prosecco it’s $10 a glass tasted great with the meal and we finished with a cookie skillet however they are a little small but they are delicious. Ask for Corrine she’s a gem. 9/10
… more
Laura Schreiber
ENORMOUS portions. We got the onion rings appetizer, Reuben, burger, bourbon flight and a cocktail for my husband and I. Including tip it was $100. More expensive than some other dates we’ve gone on, but worth every penny! The cocktail was that night’s special and had lemon and basil and tasted *amazing.* Ended up bringing home half the Reuben and half the rings, *and* we were both stuffed! Very impressive whiskey menu. Located INSIDE the Comfort Inn, which was not immediately obvious. Parking directly in front is 30-min limit, but the side street was close and free for the evening.
… more
Janet Shirey
The food and service were excellent! Our daughter and her boyfriend recommended it. We shared the Chesapeake crab dip with hand cut fries. I had the Shaved prime rib French dip sandwich and my husband enjoyed his Sheppard’s pie. Everything was delicious! We would highly recommend 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion. The cost was just over $60 including one cocktail.
… more
Chad Fiedler
You almost feel like you’re in an old colonial town when you sit on the patio. You can almost feel the history in the middle of downtown Carlisle. The mixologist behind the bar made really good cocktails. The bone in ribeye was on point. Seasoning spot on. Prepared exactly how I like. If your in town I highly recommend this establishment.
… more
Stavy
Reservations required…atleast during spring carisle events. Well priced. Huge whiskey, bourbon and scotch selection. Service was not on point.
… more
Scott Shipley
We were worried this would be an overpriced stuffy place when we looked at pictures. WE COULD NOT HAVE BEEN MORE WRONG!!
… more
Zakary Babin
Food was fantastic, onion rings were probably the best I’ve ever had. Shepard’s pie was very good. Awesome bourbon selection, although a little steep on some of the prices. Rarer bottles were priced decently fair. 9.5/10 overall.
… more
Jason Oates
Truly great experience! Not only was the food and selection of whiskey (obviously) and other beverages great, the waiter Rich was phenomenal. We will be back and specifically requesting Rich. His personality, genuine approach and attentiveness actually made the trip. Thank you all and keep up the awesome food, drinks and service!
… more
… View more