Family-owned seafood house inside a historic button factory with views across the Ohio River. Based on 991 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
117 Ferry St, Madison, IN 47250
Phone: (812) 265-2831
Website: http://www.keywestshrimphouse.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Adrien Kooyman
Key West Shrimp House doesn’t look like much from the outside, but the inside is a whole different story. The food is amazing. Purely comfort food, fresh, clean ingredients make up the delicious menu. The atmosphere reminds me of the old fun King Fish restaurants that use to plague the city of Louisville, but are mostly gone now. There’s a certain “hole in the wall” feel to the place, but not in a bad way. Food is amazing, drinks are excellent, the history of the building is so cool (it use to be a button factory using the shells from the Ohio river freshwater invertebrates for the buttons). Such a great time here!
… more
Megan Wilson
Stuffed Cod was way to salty and in edible. The seafood platter is just blah everything fried in the same gross tasting batter no flavor difference at all. The onion soup is not normal its a tomato based soup like yoy make a vegetable soup. Prices are outrageous for sub par food. On a positive note salad bar was good and our waitress was very good. Would i go back unfortunately no!
… more
Ron Calhoun
The food and staff was great as always. Wife had the King crab legs, I had Lobster and Grilled Shrimp. We ordered Crab Cakes and fried onions. Got the sea food chowder and double baked potatoes with the meals, and salad bar.
… more
Debra Haden
I walked onto the porch of the Key West Shrimp House at 8:15 pm and was welcomed by a cheerful hostess that immediately thanked me for coming. I asked if I was too late, considering the restaurant closed in 45 minutes and she assured me, “Even if you’d walked in at 8:55, you’d still receive the same great service.”
… more
Steve M
We had the shrimp in a net and fried shrimp. Both we very good. Service was very good. Ask for the really spicy shrimp sauce. Not sure what was going on, but wouldn’t serve alcohol.
… more
Dave P
Saturday date night. our waitress was busy with a 7 top so it took us 39 minutes to get Luke warm soup. My wife ordered the chief special, the bacon wrapped shrimp was marinated in a ketsup sauce. not sure what all the fuss us about.
… more
AL
Very relaxing atmosphere and location. The menu has plenty of selections to satisfy your taste and reasonably priced. Plenty of parking is available on a hardtop lot with handicap. We came out for lunch and enjoyed the food and waitress was excellent.
… more
Donald Reynolds
The Greeter was in a great mood. Every waiter and waitress in there was mad about something. I ate there alone and they set me at the bar and then had me scoot over by the dirty dishes and the bar tender was about to have a nervous breakdown. Best I could tell she needs a full time bar back. I got the Captain Platter best thing Not on the Menu. I got treated like a deck hand not a Captain
… more
Darin Bowman
Nothing to write home about but was ok. First thing to note is that the place could use a thorough cleaning. Everything is grimy.
… more
carolyn bryner
Food is amazing and lots of it, you wont go away hungry! Wish we had a better waitress with better attitude and manners…
… more
… View more