Based on 411 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
201 E Main St, Milford, MA 01757
Phone: (508) 478-7377
Website: https://www.hotpizzacoldbeer.com/
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michael Edgar
I tried this place for the first time. The pizza was very good and had a nice crust. The menu has a lot of items I want to try next. I’m glad I tried the beef and broccoli pizza, it was delicious. I would get extra sauce next time. The Idaho potato pizza is wonderful.
… more
John Simons
Got various items that were shared. Everything lacked flavor but the chicken wings, which I guess you can’t really mess up. Bread was amazing. Staff very unprofessional sitting with friends while working, on cell phones. No management in sight.
… more
ADM
I ordered over the phone and paid with a card so my kids could pick up dinner. I’m a vegetarian and ordered a vegetable wrap off of the online menu. Sat down to eat and I was given some sort of steak wrap! I called and the person who answered the phone apologized and told me the vegetable pesto wrap is no longer on the menu. So you gave me steak instead? Then I had to ask him what could be done about it because he didn’t offer a solution. He put someone else on the phone. The kids both had upset stomachs after eating their pizza. Not sure what was going on there tonight, but it wasn’t good!
… more
S “S” B
Old school friendly service that was once the standard. First time trying this restaurant and I’m hooked. They make you feel welcome and wanted. Got the breadsticks which are addictive. Idaho potato pizza., without the bacon on Good Friday but it still did not disappoint. Delicious food reasonably priced and great friendly attentive service. I was a little disappointed that the Irish Craic wasn’t available but the sincere good natured attitude of our server made me forget about it immediately. This could be the go to restaurant we’ve been searching for. The acoustic live music was outstanding! When your only wish is that the bar was bigger and closer to your home, you found a gem.
… more
Ryan DiVittorio
If I could give this place less than 1 star I would. I ordered take out last night and when I picked it up I zeroed out the tip because i don’t believe it’s necessary to tip for take out. When I looked at my bank statement there was very clearly a $5.00 tip added that I did not approve. It doesn’t matter how much money it is, the employees basically stole from me and that’s just wrong. When I called and informed the manager, because who knows how many people they do this too, she basically shrugged it off as a “misunderstanding” and didn’t offer to write the wrong in any way. This is upsetting because I enjoy their food, won’t be going back.
… more
spencer guerschuny
I grabbed lunch here today. I got the Mac and cheese pizza with Buffalo chicken on top. The crust was nice and crunch and the dough was fluffy and chewy but also crisp so no toppings fell off my slices. I really enjoy this type of crust and dough so I was really pleased. My boss got a BBQ chicken calzone and I had some serious lunch envy. Even though my meal was perfect. We also ordered fries which they forgot to add to the order but threw them in for free once I got to the restaurant. Overall very satisfied.
… more
Whitney McKay
Pizza and bar food are always good. Take out from here is always the best. Dining in is always an interesting experience. No matter what time of day / what day of the week we seem to go, the service is always a little behind or you can’t find your server. Sometimes there are children just running around? which isn’t a reflection of Pepperoncinis, but it does add to the overall experience. Even with that being said, the food is consistently great.
… more
Ronan Gorman
Staff was everything but welcoming, food was not made to order, bathroom had obvious insect activity, and I could swear I smelled alcohol on my servers breath. Needless to say I will not be coming back which is a shame because I love to support local businesses.
… more
Ellen c
hmmm… was very disappointed last night. Server delivered our drinks and then we waited for about 15 minutes for her to return to take our orders, before we left. It would have been better had she at least asked if we needed more time or if we were ready to order before departing our table. This has happened before (where we were abandoned) and I do know there’s a shortage of good help, but we won’t be back. We left and went to Prezo’s – where we had excellent service and they were busier than Pepperoncinis.
… more
Sean Simz
Ordered take out. Had Taranaki wings and Steve’s sauce wings. They were good!
… more
… View more