The Shed Restaurant – West Sayville NY Menu – West Sayville, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : West Sayville, NY

The Shed Restaurant Features a bright take on American Comfort Food featuring a robust list of specialty brunch menu items alongside unforgettable lunch & dinner items.
Eat Well. Drink. Everything from scratch #InTheShed

Edible Long Island: You Need to Head to New Neighborhood Restaurant Right Now – “The Shed, is the type of restaurant I could live in. The menu is drool-worthy. The vibe is comfortable…

The Tri-State Restaurant Club Reviews: “Set away from the hustle of Huntington’s main drag, The Shed seems like a tucked away little treasure. Yet this is no hidden gem, both locals and traveling Long Islanders have all been taking refuge in the restaurant. Though quaint, The Shed does not lack a distinct ambiance.”

Based on 900 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup

The Shed Restaurant - West Sayville NY 11796

Address:
21 Main St, West Sayville, NY 11796

Phone: (631) 750-9191

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday 9 AM–11 PM
Sunday 9 AM–9 PM
Monday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

Cocktails, Beers, Wines & Beverages
Pink Panther
Breckenridge Distillery Vodka, fresh grapefruit, peach, lemon, St. Germain		 $14.00
Bloody Mary
Breckenridge Distillery Vodka, Cucumber Shrub		 $15.00
The Shed Lemonade
Rye, Domaine De Canton, homemade lemonade		 $14.00
Figgin’ Fresh
Fig vodka, dark rum, fernet, apricot		 $14.00
Smoke & Herbs
Ilegal Mezcal, lemon, pineapple, agave, sage		 $14.00
The Rabbit Hole
Reposado, Lillet Rouge, black currant, plum		 $14.00
Farmers Gin
Hendricks, cucumber, basil, fresh lime, elderflower, prosecco		 $14.00
The Watermelon
Watermelon juice, watermelon, Patrón Reposado		 $14.00
Bud $7.00
Corona $7.00
Heineken $7.00
WHB Brewing Tropical Storm IPA Cans $8.00
Athletic Brewing N/A IPA – Can $6.00
Draft Beer
Your server can tell you about the select draft beers available.
Downeast Pineapple Cider
Unfiltered craft cider infused with fresh pineapple. 5.1% ABV. GF.		 $8.00
Montauk Hard Seltzer
Lemon Lime, Mixed Berry, Black Cherry, Raspberry Lime. 4.5% ABV. GF.		 $8.00
Original Sin Black Widow, Blackberry Cider
The black widow is fruit-forward, yet tart, with a tantalizing complexity, made with blackberries and freshly pressed New York apples. 6% ABV. GF.		 $8.00
Austin Dry Rose Cider
A well-rounded cider using hibiscus and real rose for a uniquely light, dry take on rosé. 5% ABV. GF.		 $8.00
Ommegang Chai Cider
Sweet and spicy aromas of chai tea, cardamom, cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove accompany a lively, pleasant tartness. A touch of lactose imparts a sublimely smooth texture and reveals the richness of the spices. Medium-bodied yet notably dry, the cider finishes long and slow, reminiscent of a chai latte. 5% ABV.		 $8.00
Air Quotes Sangria
Our non-alcoholic version of the classic, white grape, cranberry, peach, citrus, agave, fresh fruit		 $8.00
Revenge Of The Pink Panther
The Shed’s most popular cocktail, but virgin, grapefruit, lemon, peach, elderflower		 $8.00
Sea Pearl Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough
Light-Bodied, zesty lime, gooseberry, appetizing mineral finish.		 $14.00
Sunny With A Chance Of Flowers Sauv Blanc, Monterey
Guava, pineapple and ruby grapefruit. Zero Sugar. 85 calories. 9% ABV. Sustainable. [VEGAN] (GF)		 $14.00
Phantom Chardonnay, Central Valley
Medium-bodied. Stone fruit, vanilla, oaky and buttery [VEGAN] (GF)		 $14.00
Riff Pino Grigio, Italy
Light-bodied, fruity, tart, acidic. [VEGAN]		 $13.00
Shine, Riesling, Germany
Dry, green apple and peach. Acidic with a citrus finish. [VEGAN]		 $13.00
Cakebread Chardonnay, Napa
Stone fruit, mineral, citrus, oak		 $90.00
Hubart Brochard, Sancerre
Dry, fruit forward, clean, crisp		 $63.00
Dough Cabernet, North Coast
Full-bodied. Dark fruit, brown sugar, cedar. First wine collaboration with the James Beard Foundation. Created with chefs to be food friendly. Supports the MAPP program.		 $14.00
Tortoise Creek Pinot Noir, California
Violet and ripe cherry aroma, raspberry, earthy, vanilla. [VEGAN]		 $13.00
High Note Malbec, Argentina
Medium-bodied. Ripe red fruits, Vanilla, Spices.		 $13.00
Fat Bastard Merlot, France
Medium- Full-bodied. Deep plum, black cherry, black pepper, fresh, full and juicy		 $44.00
Flowers Pinot Noir, Sonoma Coast
Mature fruit, complex flavors, bright acidity, minerality		 $96.00
La Valentina
Montepulciano D’Abruzzo – a hearty red wine made from 100% Montepulciano grapes		 $14.00
One Stone, Rosé Of Pino Noir, California
Watermelon, pink grapefruit, guava. A portion of each bottle sold is donated to Dream Big Darling, a nonprofit that provides mentorship programs for the next generation of leaders in the wine and spirits industry.		 $13.00
Summer In A Bottle, Wolffer, Provence
New Release. Tangerine, citrus, peach, floral. Blends the Provence grapes including, Grenache, Cinsault, Syrah, and Vermentino, with the vibrant style of Summer in a Bottle Long Island.		 $58.00
Notorious Pink Grenache, Rosé, France
Light-bodied. Berry, Citrus, Stone fruit		 $14.00
Bridge Lane, Rosé, North Fork Long Island
Long Island. Medium-bodied. Strawberry, peach, citrus		 $13.00
Tiamo Prosecco, Italy
Organic, Vegan		 $14.00
Adami Prosecco $49.00
Veuve Cliquot Champagne $75.00
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea $3.75
Handcrafted Lemonade $4.00
Fresh Squeezed Juices
Orange, grapefruit, watermelon		 $5.00
Sail Away Cold Brew Coffee
Regular on tap, Decaf exclusively canned for The Shed		 $7.25
Coffee
La Colombe, Arabica, medium roast. Regular or Decaf		 $3.75
Herbal Tea
La Colombe Teas: Breakfast, Earl Grey, Turmeric, Chamomile, Peppermint		 $3.75
Espresso $4.00
Cappuccino $5.00
Beach Ball Cold Brew
Organic tea, strawberry hibiscus, white peach, grapefruit basil mint		 $7.25
Brunch & Lunch Menu – UNTIL 4PM
Fried Pickles
Buttermilk Dressing		 $10.50
Skillet Mac & Cheese
corn, jalapeno, bacon, green onion		 $16.25
Hummus Crudite
basil hummus, buttermilk dressing, garden veggies		 $16.75
Shed Wings
chipotle buffalo, bleu buttermilk		 $15.60
Calamari
fried, herbs, cherry peppers, tomato vinaigrette		 $15.10
Deviled Eggs
avocado, roasted jalepeno, pickled onions, tajin		 $12.10
Breakfast Bowl
2 poached eggs, avocado, homefries, spinach, onion, corn, jalapeño, chipotle hollandaise (GF)		 $14.50
Buttermilk Pancakes
butter, maple syrup		 $12.95
Two Eggs Any Style
homefries, toast		 $10.25
Farmer’s Breakfast
flat iron steak, 2 eggs any style, homefries, hollandaise, dressed greens (GF)		 $22.95
Belgian Waffle
blueberries, butter, maple syrup		 $12.25
Brioche French Toast
banana, brown sugar, maple syrup		 $15.25
Avocado Toast & Sunny Eggs
watermelon radish, tomato, sunflower seeds, arugula		 $14.95
Biscuit Benedict
2 eggs poached*, bacon or sausage, homefries, hollandaise		 $15.95
Arugula, Roasted Tomato Benedict
avocado, 2 eggs poached*, homefries, hollandaise (GF)		 $15.25
Shegg Sandwich
2 eggs fried, cheddar, bacon, arugula, tomato, onion jam, rustic bread, homefries		 $14.95
Omelettes & Frittatas
onion, mushroom, sweet potato, spinach, jalapeño, bell peppers, corn, tomato, bacon, turkey bacon, sausage, american, swiss, cheddar, goat cheese, parmesan, cheddar jack		 $15.89
Shed Bowl
roasted chicken, arugula, radish, sweet potatoes, wild rice, sunflower seeds, mushrooms, goat cheese, spiced honey vinaigrette (GF)		 $18.75
Summer Bowl
Strawberries, goat cheese, pickled red onion, arugula, smoked almonds, white balsamic vinaigrette, pink peppercorn honey		 $17.25
Veggie Protein Bowl
tomato herb rice, garbanzo, sprouts,brussels, sweet potato, mushrooms, sunflower seeds, pickled veggies (GF)		 $16.25
Cobb Salad
greens, grilled chicken, avocado, corn, tomato, bacon, egg, buttermilk dressing (GF)		 $18.75
Caesar
romaine, brioche crouton, parmesan crisp		 $14.75
Shed Burger
american, swiss, lettuce, tomato, onion jam, shed sauce		 $15.95
Steak House Burger
blue cheese, potato chips, house steak sauce		 $15.95
Smoke Burger
applewood smoked bacon, cheddar, smokey tomato jam		 $15.95
Vege Burger House-Made
green pea & potato patty, pickled carrot relish, hot pepper ketchup		 $14.95
Reuben
corned beef, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, shed sauce		 $16.50
Fish Sandwich
blackened market fish, cucumber slaw, chipotle mayo		 $15.10
Chicken Sandwich
hot honey fried, pickle, buttermilk dressing		 $16.10
BLT
bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, rustic bread		 $14.95
Short Rib Melt
bbq braised beef short rib, cherry pepper aioli, cheddar, pickled red onion, grilled hoagie		 $16.50
The Shed Lobster Roll
Butter poached main lobster, brioche split top bun, north fork potato chips, coleslaw , pickle, grilled lemon		 $38.50
Chicken & Waffles
habanero honey		 $18.75
Glazed Salmon
brussels , sweet potato, shallot, sweet mustard glaze (GF)		 $28.40
Blackened Sea Bass
beurre blanc, basil oil, dressed greens, grilled lemon (GF)		 $28.75
Grilled Chicken
arugula, tomato, radish, balsamic,parmesan crisp (GF)		 $19.25
14 Oz. New York Strip
rosemary fingerling potatoes, bleu arugula salad, housemade steak sauce (GF)		 $43.45
Shed Fries $7.95
Gouda Fries $8.95
Sweet Potato Fries $7.95
Homefries $4.95
Dressed Greens $6.95
Biscuits & Jam $5.95
Fruit $5.95
Bacon $5.95
Turkey Bacon $6.95
Sausage $4.95
Pure Maple Syrup $5.00
Slaw $3.95
Basmati Rice $5.95
Roasted Mushrooms $5.95
Small Caesar $7.95
Sautéed Spinach $4.95
Brussels $5.95
Dinner Menu – STARTS 4PM
Fried Pickles
buttermilk dressing		 $10.50
Skillet Mac & Cheese
corn, jalapeño, bacon, green onion		 $16.25
Hummus Crudite
basil hummus, buttermilk dressing, garden veggies (GF)		 $16.75
Calamari
fried, herbs, cherry peppers, tomato vinaigrette		 $15.10
Shed Wings
chipotle buffalo, bleu buttermilk		 $15.60
Deviled Eggs
Avocado, roasted jalapeno, pickled onions, tajin		 $12.10
Shed Bowl
Roasted chicken, arugula, radish, sweet potatoes, wild rice,sunflower seeds, mushrooms, goat cheese, spiced honey vinaigrette (GF)		 $18.75
Summer Bowl
strawberries, goat cheese, pickled red onion,arugula, smoked almonds, white balsamic vinaigrette, pink peppercorn honey		 $17.25
Veggie Protein Bowl
tomato herb rice, garbanzo, sprouts, Brussels, sweet potato,mushrooms, sunflower seeds, pickled veggies		 $16.25
Cobb Salad
greens, grilled chicken, avocado, corn, tomato, bacon, egg, buttermilk dressing (GF)		 $18.75
Caesar Salad
Romaine, crouton, parmesan crisp		 $14.75
Omelettes & Frittatas GF
PICK 3: onion, mushroom, sweet potato, spinach, jalapeño, bell peppers, corn, tomato, bacon, turkey bacon, sausage, american, swiss, cheddar, goat cheese, parmesan, cheddar jack, corn, scallions		 $15.89
Shed Burger
American, swiss, lettuce, tomato, onion jam, shed sauce		 $15.95
Steak House Burger
bleu cheese, potato chips, house steak sauce		 $15.95
Smoke Burger
Applewood smoked Bacon, Cheddar, Smokey Tomato Jam		 $15.95
Vege Burger House-Made
Green pea & Potato Patty, pickled Carrot Relish, hot pepper Ketchup		 $14.95
Reuben
corned beef, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, shed sauce		 $16.50
Fish Sandwich
Blackened Market Fish, cucumber slaw, chipotle mayo		 $15.10
Chicken Sandwich
hot honey fried, pickle, buttermilk dressing		 $16.10
Shed Dog
kobe beef, onion jam, shed sauce, pickle crisps, brioche bun		 $14.95
BLT
bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, rustic bread		 $14.95
Short Rib Melt
bbq braised beef short rib, cherry pepper aioli, cheddar, pickled red onion, grilled hoagie		 $16.50
The Shed Lobster Roll
Butter poached main lobster, brioche split top bun, north fork potato chips, coleslaw, pickle, grilled lemon		 $38.50
Chicken & Waffles
Habanero honey		 $18.75
Glazed Salmon
brussels, sweet potato, shallot, sweet mustard glaze (GF)		 $28.40
Farmer’s Breakfast
flat iron steak, 2 eggs any style, homefries, hollandaise, dressed greens (GF)		 $22.95
Grilled Chicken
Arugula, tomato, radish, balsamic, parmesan crisp (GF)		 $19.25
Blackened Sea Bass
beurre blanc, basil oil, dressed greens, grilled lemon (GF)		 $28.75
14 Oz. New York Strip
rosemary fingerling potatoes, bleu arugula salad, house- made steak sauce (GF)		 $43.45
Shed Fries $7.95
Gouda Fries $8.95
Sweet Potato Fries $7.95
Homefries $4.95
Dressed Greens $6.95
Sautéed Spinach $4.95
Slaw $3.95
Basmati Rice $5.95
Roasted Mushrooms $5.95
Small Caesar $7.95
Brussels $5.95

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

JV Young
The parking lot was full, I think we got the last spot, but we walked in and we were seated right away at the best spot in the restaurant.

… more

YKK
We didn’t check out the indoor seating but we liked the outdoor seating area a lot. If its a nice day definitely get a table outside. Food and the service were also great. Our waitress was very nice and attentive. Definitely try the mac and cheese!!!

… more

Najeeb Abdullah
We came here on recommendation from a friend. This is such a nice restaurant! It has a rustic event venue type vibe, like a waterfront restaurant. We ordered the omelette and french toast. The food was very good and very filling. The staff were very friendly. We really enjoyed our time here. This is an excellent weekend brunch spot!!

… more

Sunita Sukhu
Had dinner here a few days ago. There’s plenty of parking in the back. We came in through the door by the parking lot. The bar is really nice. We went to the hostess and were seated right away at a cute booth for 2. Pur waitress came over right away. We had drinks that were really nice and ordered an appetizer. The mac and cheese. It was so yummy!!! For dinner we had a salad and the lobster roll. Again, super yummy. The Shed will definitely become a place we go to often. Looking forward to the next time we go back. Good food and good service!!

… more

Douglas Lloyd
Decided at last minute to go to dinner on a Tuesday evening. We were able to get seated at a quaint table for 2 by the front window. The service was great with all staff welcoming and friendly. Lots of great choices for food which came out hot and delicious.

… more

Jeffrey Mumford
Was great. Party of e seated immediately outside. Took drink order within minutes. Had short ribs melt, lobster roll, brioche french toast. Everyone loved their food. Had to take some of the French toast home…it is a lot to eat. Bill was 112 after tax and tip. Only issue they did not like the watermelon juice, tasted overripe. Waitress replaced 1 with pineapple juice and took the other one off our bill. Also many napkins lipstick staind, but it’s hard to get out. Great experience.

… more

Mackenzie
Wooooow. Typically we stay local (Smithtown) because there are plenty of restaurants here, but I found this place through Bring Fido, an app for dog parents to find places that allow pets. We brought our puppy this evening and sat outside.

… more

Kim Cleary
I always hear about The Shed. A millennial’s paradise! I’m too busy and old for that so the Barbie movie was a great excuse to drop in with my daughter. Let me just say Alexa was our waitress (BTW AMAZING ❤️) but the entire team works together touching all the tables for a smooth service! Drinks, food, and service were top notch and will definitely be back !

… more

Richard Cheek
The food was delicious and service attentive! It’s was a beautiful night to eat outside and right around sunset got chilly. Staff put the heaters on right away! And let me tell you the tea was delicious and fresh brewed! Definitely going to return, don’t know how we didn’t make it here sooner!

… more

Lauren Jacobsen
Food was excellent. Pictured are the chicken and waffles, smoke burger, short rib melt, and fries. Everyone in my party enjoyed the meal. We also had calamari for appetizer, which was delicious! I highly recommend this place!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch