Based on 90 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1745 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY 10547
Phone: (914) 528-8200
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Amelia PHW
The interior is quite dated and could use a bit of TLC. There were almost no slices on a Thursday afternoon and no garlic knots. Staff seemed disinterested and looked like they wanted to leave. The server kept touching and rotating some of the slices with her bare hands. Definitely won’t be returning.
… more
Ralph Niese
I ordered a Mohegan salad that was 13.95 on the menu. My wife picked up
… more
Broconut
This place really does live up to its name. The food is always hand-made with top-notch skill, and they serve exactly the kind of brand drinks that taste great with their menu.
… more
sal bellantoni
Went their at least 7 or 8 times times for slices and didn’t have slices available. Never in my life did i ever come across a pizza place that didn’t offer slices. Wow!…..Now they offer half price slices on Sunday. I guess they decided to sell slices!……..Don’t waste your time on this place and also don’t know how to greet and thank customers.
… more
Carol R.S.
Our company is located a few miles away and have given this business thousands of dollars in catering and lunch orders over the years. They have gotten so bad that I finally had to write a review. We give at least 2 hours notice on any large order (6 pies and a few salads for example) for example, and they are ALWAYS at least 30 mins to half-hour late, leaving our employees sitting in meetings with no food. The last recent time we ordered, we called 2 hours ahead and actually drove over to pick it up in order to avoid the wait for delivery. Um, 2 hour notice…6 pies and a few salads were STILL not ready.
… more
Barry Brown
The food is usually good. This time we ordered 2 meatball parmigiana wedges to go. When we got there in 20 minutes as told the order was not ready. Then it took another 15 minutes. My daughter went to pay and to her surprise it was more than we expected We she got back to the car the food was not even bot. The bread was not fresh. It seamed like day old. There are 15 pizza places between my house and Peekskill on East Main Street I thought we would give Frank another try. Very disappointed
… more
Andrew Moran
Food is bad compared to other places within a 5 minute drive. Also, despite having delivery listed EVERYWHERE, when you ask they refuse to deliver. Massive waste of time, pay your drivers more and get better cooks please.
… more
Bill Goss
I have lived here for almost 15 years and this was actually the first pizzeria that my wife and I came upon and is only down the road from where we eventually bought our home. The first time was definitely the best time. Over the years My Favorite Pizza has declined more and more in all aspects. Now I’ve never witnessed the disrespect to the employees that some others have commented on. I’m talking service, being told 15-20 minutes for a pickup order and then waiting another 20 minutes after arriving and being told that “it’ll be right out” after taking my money (numerous times which is why I stopped patronizing), screwing up delivery and pickup orders, leaving items out and then expecting you, me, to come down and pickup the missing items because “the driver is out on another delivery” (my opinion, the owner or whoever is in charge at that time should be jumping in his car without hesitation to make it right). Then recently I figured that I was in the area and had to pickup a prescription at CVS and didn’t want to drive all over the place to get some dinner for my son and I, because normally I would go to Francesca’s in Shrub Oak, and I bit the bullet and ordered a pie. Needless to say, never again out of the reason of convenience. Pizza was burnt and dry. It was ready when I arrived but even my son could tell that it wasn’t Francesca’s. Sorry My Favorite Pizza, but no more.
… more
Mike Dee
The food is starting to slack here. Delivered a burnt pizza. I would rather had been told and would have waited. They made a chicken wrap wrong and I brought it back…. Made it wrong again.
… more
Heather Koob
Pizza is delicious, however the guy who seemed like owner/manager definitely needs to stop yelling & degrading his employees and treat them with more respect. I felt terrible for them. I was also bothered by the fact that no gloves/sanitation were used when handling my food/others food after the register & phone were used. The delicious pizza redeems them. 3/5
… more
… View more