Elm Street Bakery Menu – East Aurora, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : East Aurora, NY

Elm Street Bakery began from a desire to create a community gathering place where neighbors could break bread over fresh, seasonal food sourced from local farmers in a warm and welcoming environment.

Follow us on Instagram @elmstreetbakery for updates on upcoming events and seasonal menu items to enjoy.

We look forward to having you dine with us soon!

Seasonal American cuisine is served in this airy, rustic-chic cafe/bakery with a brick oven. Based on 938 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Elm Street Bakery 14052

Address:
72 Elm St, East Aurora, NY 14052

Phone: (716) 652-4720

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 8 AM–5 PM
Thursday 8 AM–5 PM
Friday 8 AM–5 PM
Saturday 8 AM–5 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday Closed

Menu

BREAKFAST (ONLINE)
Avocado Toast
Marinated avocado, feta, cilantro, lemon vinaigrette, everything bagel seasoning on our sourdough		 $13.00
ESB Breakfast Sandwich
farm egg, bacon, cheddar cheese, arugula with lemon vinaigrette, sriracha aioli, on our sourdough		 $9.00
ESB Veggie Breakfast Sandwich
farm egg, cheddar cheese, red pepper, mushroom, arugula with lemon vinaigrette, sriracha aioli on our sourdough		 $8.50
Everything Smoked Salmon Bialy
smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, thinly sliced red onion, green goddess dressing, fresh and pickled dill.		 $13.00
Sesame Smoked Salmon Bialy
smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, thinly sliced red onion, green goddess dressing, fresh and pickled dill.		 $13.00
Garlic Asiago Smoked Salmon Bialy
smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, thinly sliced red onion, green goddess dressing, fresh and pickled dill.		 $13.00
Bialy With Cream Cheese $3.75
Bialy $3.50
Peach French Toast
bread pudding, strawberry compote, lemon thyme whipped butter		 $13.00
The Morty
mortadella, provolone, caramelized onions, dijonnaise, over easy egg, arugula, on a soft roll		 $10.00
Egg Sammy
2 Ordinary Farms fried eggs, cheddar cheese, tomato basil aioli, on a soft bun		 $9.00
Farmers Hash
potato, red onion, collard greens, summer squash, green beans, kohlrabi, over easy egg, sourdough toast		 $13.00
BREAKFAST (SATURDAY)
ESB Breakfast Sandwich
farm egg, bacon, cheddar cheese, arugula with lemon vinaigrette, sriracha aioli, on our sourdough		 $9.00
ESB Veggie Breakfast Sandwich
farm egg, cheddar cheese, red pepper, mushroom, arugula with lemon vinaigrette, sriracha aioli on our sourdough		 $8.50
Sesame Smoked Salmon Bialy
smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, thinly sliced red onion, green goddess dressing, fresh and pickled dill.		 $12.00
Everything Smoked Salmon Bialy
smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, thinly sliced red onion, green goddess dressing, fresh and pickled dill.		 $12.00
Garlic Asiago Smoked Salmon Bialy
smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, thinly sliced red onion, green goddess dressing, fresh and pickled dill.		 $12.00
Bialy With Cream Cheese $3.75
Avocado Toast
Marinated avocado, feta, cilantro, lemon vinaigrette, everything bagel seasoning on our sourdough		 $12.75
Bialy $3.00
Strawberry French Toast
bread pudding, strawberry compote, lemon whipped butter		 $13.00
The Morty
mortadella, provolone, dijonnaise, over easy egg, arugula, on a soft roll		 $10.00
Farmers Hash
potato, red onion, rainbow chard, zucchini, kohlrabi, over easy egg, sourdough toast		 $13.00
Egg Sammy
2 Ordinary Farms fried eggs, cheddar cheese, tomato basil aioli, on a soft bun		 $9.00
SANDWICHES (ONLINE)
Jambon Beurre
a traditional French sandwich-smoked ham, salted butter, on baguette		 $10.00
ESBLT
heirloom tomatoes, bacon, romaine, roasted garlic + chive aioli, on toasted sourdough		 $16.00
Caprese
fresh mozzarella, confit tomatoes, red onion, pistachio pesto, arugula, saba, on baguette		 $12.00
Peach Tartine
Cornerstone Orchard peaches, baked ricotta, crispy prosciutto, balsamic reduction, mint, on sourdough		 $15.00
Chicken Schwarma
chicken, feta, spinach, cucumber, red onion, tomato, tahini vinaigrette, tzatziki, on pita		 $18.00
Sweet Corn Tartine
roasted corn + jalapeño cream, pickled radish, serrano peppers, cotija cheese, cilantro, sweet paprika on sourdough		 $15.00
KITCHEN (ONLINE)
Classic Pizza
tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, pepperoni.		 $12.00
Cheese Pizza
tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmesan		 $10.00
Margherita Pizza
tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil		 $10.00
Angry Jay
spicy tomato sauce, banana peppers, Calabrian chili peppers, red onion, fresh and shredded mozzarella, parmesan		 $13.00
Spicy White Pizza
roasted banana peppers, confit tomatoes, red onion, ricotta cream, oregano		 $13.00
Vegan Pizza Base (Tomato Sauce, Nutritional Yeast) ***PLEASE SELECT TOPPINGS!
tomato sauce, nutritional yeast. toppings are a la carte.		 $10.00
Mushroom Pizza
oyster + shiitake mushrooms, roasted garlic cream, mozzarella, parmesan, truffle oil, scallions		 $13.00
Sicilian White Pizza
garlic oil, roasted garlic, mozzarella, grana padano, Root Down Farm heirloom tomatoes, red onion, basil, oregano, crushed red chili flakes		 $13.00
Sweet Corn + ‘Nduja Pizza
garlic cream, roasted corn + sweet peppers, ‘nduja, mozzarella, cheddar cheese, pickled red onions, chili honey		 $13.00
Summer Beet Salad
red beet puree, roasted golden beets, shaved white beets, beet greens, Root Down Farm mixed greens, pistachios, pickled red onion, oranges, tarragon balsamic vinaigrette		 $15.00
Caesar Salad
romaine, parmesan, sourdough croutons, lemon, caesar dressing		 $15.00
House Salad
mixed greens, heirloom cherry tomatoes, pickled red onions, lemon & dill vinaigrette		 $7.00
Greek Grain Bowl
mixed greens, farro, crispy chick peas, heirloom cherry tomatoes, red onion, sweet peppers, pickled banana peppers, feta, green goddess dressing		 $16.00
Peach Panzanella
mixed greens, peaches, heirloom cherry tomatoes, sourdough, basil, cucumber, red onion, lemon basil vinaigrette		 $16.00
Summer Minestrone
roasted local corn, cannellini beans, tomatoes, spinach, garlic, oregano, basil
(DF/GF/VEGAN)		 $8.50
Southern Bean Soup
black eyed peas, collard greens, braised pork, bacon, sweet potato
(DF/GF)		 $8.50
Mediterranean Mezze Plate
wood-fired pita, housemate hummus, greek olives, pickled and raw seasonal vegetables		 $17.00
Wood Fired Roasted Eggplant
Root Down Farm baby eggplant, roasted red pepper harissa, sweet pickled cherry peppers, herbed whipped feta		 $16.00
BREAD & PASTRY (WEDNESDAY)
Banana Bread $4.50
Blueberry Muffin $4.50
Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.00
Coffee Cake $4.50
Cowgirl Cookie $3.00
Cranberry Orange Scone $4.75
Molasses Ginger Cookie $3.00
Peanut Butter Cookie (GF) $3.00
Banana Bread Loaf $18.50
Bakery Box
6 of our classic, beloved staples. includes an assortment of scones, muffins, quick breads and other specialties. substitutions may be made based on availability of product.		 $26.25
Morning Glory Muffin GF $4.50
Brookie $3.00
Lemon Lavender Bread $4.50
Raspberry Orange + Pistachio Muffin $4.50
3-Seed Sourdough $8.00
Baguette $4.75
EA Sourdough $7.75
French Batard $6.50
Sesame Batard $6.50
Country White $7.50
Vollkornbrot Rye $8.25
BREAD & PASTRY (THURSDAY)
Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.00
Cowgirl Cookie $3.00
Brookie Cookie $3.00
Molasses Ginger Cookie $3.00
Peanut Butter Cookie (GF) $3.00
Cranberry Orange Scone $4.75
Blueberry Muffin $4.50
Banana Bread $4.50
Coffee Cake $4.25
Lemon Lavender Slice $4.50
Morning Glory Muffin $4.50
Raspberry Orange + Pistachio Muffin $4.50
Baguette $4.75
EA Sourdough $7.75
French Batard $6.50
Grain-Up $8.00
Sesame Batard $6.50
Honey Wheat $7.50
BREAD & PASTRY (FRIDAY)
Banana Bread $4.50
Blueberry Muffin $4.50
Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.00
Coffee Cake $4.50
Cowgirl Cookie $3.00
Cran Orange Scone $4.75
Molasses Ginger Cookie $3.00
Peanut Butter Cookie (GF) $3.00
Bakery Box
6 of our classic, beloved staples. includes an assortment of scones, muffins, quick breads and other specialties. substitutions may be made based on availability of product.		 $26.25
Brookie Cookie $3.00
Lemon Lavender Loaf Slice $4.50
Morning Glory Muffin (GF) $4.50
Raspberry Orange + Pistachio Muffin $4.50
Baguette $4.75
Caraway Rye $8.00
EA Sourdough $7.75
French Batard $6.50
Sesame Batard $6.50
Sunflower Levain $8.00
Country White $7.50
Sesame Semolina $8.25
BREAD & PASTRY (SATURDAY)
3-Seed Sourdough $8.00
Baguette $5.00
Caraway Rye $8.00
EA Sourdough $7.75
French Batard $6.50
Honey Wheat $7.50
Sesame Batard $6.50
Cinnamon Raisin $8.25
Potato Bread $7.50
Banana Bread $4.50
Blueberry Muffin $4.50
Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.00
Coconut Macaroon (GF) $4.00
Coffee Cake $4.50
Cowgirl Cookie $3.00
Cranberry Orange Scone $4.75
Molasses Ginger Cookie $3.00
Peanut Butter Cookie (GF) $3.00
Cinnamon Bun $5.25
Bakery Box
6 of our classic, beloved staples. includes an assortment of scones, muffins, quick breads and other specialties. substitutions may be made based on availability of product.		 $26.25
Butter Block Chocolate Croissant $5.00
Butter Block Croissant $4.50
Lemon Lavender Loaf Bread Slice $4.50
Morning Glory Muffin (GF) $4.50
Raspberry Orange & Pistachio Muffin $4.50
MARKET (ONLINE)
Barrel & Brine Ferments $8.00
Calabrian Chilis $8.00
Caper Cream Cheese $6.50
Cornichon $5.25
Dijon Mustard $6.50
Elderberry Syrup $21.00
ESB Fermented Hot Sauce
House fermented, jalapeño, salt, apple cider vinegar		 $10.50
ESB Hummus
featured on our beloved mezze plate, now available for you to enjoy at home. ingredients: chick peas, tahini, cumin, lemon, garlic		 $6.50
ESB Kimchi
House fermented, Napa cabbage, leeks, daikon radish, garlic chive, kohlrabi, asian pear, fish sauce, rice flour, chili, salt		 $10.50
ESB Olives
perfect paired with our hand curated selection of cheeses.
ingredients: mixed olives, thyme, rosemary, oregano, garlic, lemon zest, crushed red pepper, olive oil		 $6.50
ESB Sauerkraut $9.50
Fire Cider
made with all organic ginger, garlic, jalapenos, onion, rosemary, lemon verbena, lemons, oranges, hibiscus, raw apple cider vinegar and local raw honey		 $14.75
Hawthorne Valley Sauerkraut $8.50
Ordinary Farm (LRG) Eggs
local, organic, free range chicken eggs from Ordinary Farm. (one dozen)		 $7.50
Pizza Dough $3.25
Pizza Kit (Cheese)
includes dough ball, pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese		 $12.75
Pizza Kit (Pepperoni)
includes dough ball, pizza sauce, mozzarella and pepperoni		 $15.75
Pizza Sauce
tomato, garlic onions, salt		 $4.25
Veggie Cream Cheese $6.50
Bagged Coffee (12 Oz) $17.00
Crostini $6.00
ESB Granola $11.50
Biscotti $6.50
Marcona Almonds $10.00
Smitas Spices $6.25
EA Advertiser $2.25
Maldon Flake Salt $10.50
Syracuse Salt 1.5 Oz $8.50
Krista’s Hot Sauce $6.50
Krista’s Jerk Sauce $7.50
Dragonfly Jam $9.00
Raw Honey $9.95
Maple Syrup
Glosser Farm local maple syrup		 $7.00
Paprika $6.50
Croutons $6.50
LRG Coffee $3.25
SM Coffee $2.75
Hot Tea $3.25
Cold Brew $4.25
Iced Tea $3.25
Saratoga Water $3.25
Natalies Orange Juice $4.25
Johnnie Ryan Soda $2.75
Spindrift $3.00
Red Jacket Juice $3.75

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Mai Nguyen
Was taken on a surprise breakfast date and this place was super cute! We went on a weekend and it was very busy with people and families constantly coming in and out. Ordered a couple breakfast sandwiches, pastries, and a latte. Wish the sandwiches were warmed up (maybe we just had to ask?), but overall everything tasted really good. Would definitely stop in again to get more pastries and another coffee!

… more

Amal Darwish
First time visiting today and can’t wait to go back! Everything was delicious!! It is very hard to find a nice place that checks off everything! Great coffee, amazing pastries with a delicious breakfast menu!! Have not been for lunch but cannot wait! For everyone that says it’s pricey I don’t think that is very fair to say. The quality of food you’re getting is the reason you are paying that price. Which in my opinion portions are perfect and fulfilling. I have paid more for mediocre coffee and pastries at other places. So excited I found this place and can’t wait to bring my friends for our coffee and lunch dates!!!

… more

Baloney Jones
Really cute spot for food and drinks right off Main Street. We came on a busy Saturday and had to wait in a bit of a line to order and then again to get food but overall was very fast considering. There is plenty of seating and the staff is very friendly. Food was phenomenal, especially obviously the bread in the sandwiches and the other baked goods. The bread had a great crust and just the right amount of firmness to support the contents of the sandwich. Both the Cuban and the Philly were very flavorful and well balanced. It is a bit pricey but worth it for the experience and quality of food. Would highly recommend if you find yourself in East Aurora. 4.8/5 -BJ

… more

Aimee Metzger
My husband and I love coming here for breakfast! I usually get black coffee but here I love the cappuccino. The barista makes the drinks look so inviting and pretty!

… more

Hanna Marcolina
Came in with a group of friends for lunch on a busy Saturday. The staff helped us all find a spot to sit together and accommodated a few other needs. Everything we had was delicious!

… more

Gerson Getulio Machado
Snowing outside.

… more

Dmitriy Brovka
Really cool spot to eat and hangout with friends. The salami sandwich was just okay, kinda disappointed. But steak sandwich and the potato bacon soup were great!

… more

Y B
Steven is the Master of Coffee! The quality coffee, not to say the brewed batches aren’t excellent in their own regard, is what takes the whole experience to the next level. Good baked items with a good cappuccino. I’ll take two, please!

… more

Dave Niedbala
What a cute little bakery this place is. We’ve passed by here before and they were closed so we made note to come back and I’m glad we did. We got a chocolate chip cookie with their apple bread which was very very good. And then we got a Caesar salad which was a bit pricey at $14. And we also got a personal Pizza cheese Which was delicious.

… more

Tayler Coder
The best quality food and vibe in East Aurora. A must stop for wood fired pizza and creative vegeatarian options. We love the outdoor dining options and rotating seasonal fare.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch