Warm, family-friendly eatery serving American-inspired local seafood plates alongside wine & beer. Based on 347 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
9 Traders Cove, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
Phone: (631) 509-4848
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: nantucketsportjefferson.com
Reviews
Olivia
Charming restaurant with naval decor right by the Port Jeff harbor. Has a patio and big bay windows in one dining area, bar in another. We went on a rainy Saturday with modest traffic.
… more
Annie Pham
Super adorable little spot in Port Jeff. The food is great, pricing isn’t bad and you get plenty of food. The service is slow but I think they want you to slow down and enjoy life. The drinks are also very yummy. We tried the French toast bites which I highly recommend and the eggs any style plate with parm truffle fries instead of home fries. I will say they do not skimp on the ingredients the parm truffle fries were delicious even for brunch. For drinks we tried bellini’s, espresso martini and mango jalapeño margaritas all were made amazingly. Would definitely go here and again and we did recommend it to anyone we knew. We even ran into a friend dining here with family. We were all from out of town visiting for a wedding.
… more
Vin Geraci
The staff at this restaurant understand what outstanding customer service means. They are very accommodating; our server, Sierra, is an asset for Nantuckets and she is absolutely great at her job. This restaurant has quickly become one of our favorite places to dine in our neighborhood, and we have dozens of options. The chef always has something perfectly prepared no matter what we order from the menu. We loved the delicious, fresh halibut as well as the blackened swordfish. Everything about or dining experience always seems to be perfect at Nantuckets thanks to their hard-working staff. Worth the visit to Port Jefferson NY.
… more
James Wood
We went for Sunday brunch, and I have to say the food was pretty good. We got the steak and eggs, and the shrimp and lobster hash and eggs. They also have a lot of options for cocktails and wine. Overall everything didn’t look terrible and it was up-to-date. The reason I gave this place a three star rating is because the room was so loud we could not even have a conversation with each other.
… more
Ke Hu (Kevin)
The food is ok but pricy. We ordered salmon, duck, mussel and salad. In general good quality is good and better than regular restaurants. However when we come it is a bit busy and service is a bit chaotic. Our orders are mistaken but clarified afterwards. The price is on the high end though. They have a deck so may be a good choice for summer happy hours.
… more
George
First time at this establishment. Food was very good; nice presentation and good quality. However, service was wanting. Polite, but inattentive waiter. Had to wait too long for his very occasional check-ins. Had to go find someone myself to ask for sweetener. Never offered to refresh drinks. No bread served to fill the wait time. Took almost 30 minutes for the appetizer to be served and it was almost immediately followed by the main dish. Considering the time of day we were there (3pm-ish) and the fact that there were only three more tables active at the time, we didn’t feel we were attended to as good as we should have been for the “upscale” restaurant it was aiming to be.
… more
Ryan O
Excellent outdoor dining experience! The staff was very friendly and attentive. We had martinis and the crab cake (Hands down the best I’ve had!) while sitting on the patio. Highly recommended!
… more
august west
Decided to try again . 2nd visit and just underwhelming. Bartender is nice but he’s doing double duty taking table orders , which takes him away from the customers at the bar and additional sales for the restaurant-no doubt he works very hard but I cut my visit short for this very reason.this is a management issue. Management decides to have one less server and give the bartender tables so they can make tips but Bar customers do not get the service they pay for, especially single diners at the bar .
… more
J V
Our food was tasty. Service was lacking. We were there early too. Dining room is very nice and they have a nice patio.
… more
Mary
everything at brunch was delicious & perfectly cooked. they raised prices recently but the portions are generous, which I appreciate (some restaurants both raise prices & reduce portions which isn’t cool). you will leave full & very satisfied.
… more
… View more