Pizzeria Gemelle Menu – Nantucket, MA

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Nantucket, MA

Welcome to our little neighborhood joint!

Just your run-of-the-mill motley crew of pizza-obsessed guys and gals makin’ some pretty dope Neapolitan-ish pizza pies for our friends!

We have a funky selection of affordable wines, some sweet treats from the South, a handful of salads, and some simple sides that happened along for the ride.

Based on 59 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Pizzeria Gemelle 02554

Address:
2 E Chestnut St, Nantucket, MA 02554

Phone: (508) 901-5958

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
 Closed
Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Specials
Italian BBQ Wings $18.25
Chicken Parm Sandwich $23.95
Italian Panuozzo
Spicy Soppresatta, Mortadella, prosciutto, speck, giardiniera, mozzarella & shredded lettuce.		 $20.55
Square Slice $6.85
Prosciutto Panino
arugula roasted peppers mozzarella prosciutto di Parma on homemade focaccia		 $17.10
Antipasti
Giardiniera
Assortment of vegetables pickled at their peak with vinegar and spices		 $8.00
Marinated Olives
House cured olives marinated with fennel, blood orange zest and house mixed spices.		 $8.00
Taralli
An Italian Cracker/Bread Stick, flavored with Rosemary. Great with a dip or charcuterie board & cheeses. Pack Description 300gr		 $9.15
Insalata
Arthur Ave Salad
Romaine, Ricotta salata, olives, pepperoncini, red onions, prosciutto cotto, red wine vinaigrette.		 $16.00
Arugula Salad
Baby arugula, shaved Parmigiano, lemon vinaigrette.		 $10.30
Pizza
Annabella Pizza
Gemelle Mozzarella, sliced guanciale, black truffles, cracked egg.		 $28.50
Calabrese Pizza
Marinara with red onions and ‘nduja		 $22.80
Capricciosa Pizza
Artichokes, Mushrooms, Olives, Prosciutto Cotto, Gemelle Mozzarella		 $23.95
Carbonara Pizza
Pizza topped with fresh mozzarella, crispy guanciale, pecorino romano, cracked black pepper, and a sunny side up egg.		 $23.95
Diavola Pizza
Spicy salami, taggiasca olives, red chili flakes		 $22.80
Emilia Pizza
Gemelle Mozzarella, tomato sauce, garlic oil, prosciutto.		 $22.80
Funghi E Speck Pizza
Woodfire roasted mushrooms, speck (smoked proscuitto), smoked mozzarella, basil, parmigiano reggiano		 $26.25
Giovanni Pizza
Potatoes, rosemary, parmesan, olive oil, sea salt.		 $19.40
Margherita Pizza
Gemelle Mozzarella, basil and tomato sauce.		 $21.70
Marinara Pizza
tomato sauce, oregano, basil, garlic, olive oil		 $19.40
Meatball Calzone
Meatballs, mozzarella, basil, fontina, and parm		 $27.40
Mortadella Pizza
Mozz, fontina cheese, arugula, shaved parm and mortadella		 $22.80
Nonno Pizza
Marinara pie topped with arugula, sliced prosciutto and fresh robbiola cheese		 $26.25
Quattro Formaggi Pizza
Parmigiano, gemelle Mozzarella, Fontal, Gorgonzola, basil.		 $22.80
Salsiccia E Friarelli Pizza
House pork sausage, Friarelli (an italian broccoli rabe, marinated in olive oil and chili), mozzarella and basil (white pie)		 $22.80
Scampi Pizza
fresh white shrimp, D.O.P. pesto Genovese, parsley, basil & parmigiano *contains nuts*		 $23.95
Spinaci Pizza
spinach, ricotta, fontina, garlic & cave-aged pecorino		 $23.95
Dolci
Nutella Pizza
Gemelle pizza dough topped with Nutella		 $17.10
Tiramisu
Housemade ladyfingers, Nantucket coffee roasters espresso, whipped mascarpone and cocoa powder.		 $12.55
Extras
3 Oz Tomato Sauce $1.75
Chili Flakes $0.30
Holy Oil $1.15
Parm $0.90
Cook at Home
Pizza Dough $4.60
Pizza Kit
Dough for 2 pizzas, tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil & parm		 $22.80
Stuffed Shells
In tomato sauce, stuffed with ricotta, topped with mozzarella and parsley.		 $16.00
Ventuno Meatballs
8 of Ventuno’s pork and beef meatballs in tomato sauce.		 $30.80
Merchandise
Pies Are Always Hot T-Shirt (Pink)
*******If shipping please write address in special instructions. If ordering more then one shirt only click shipping once and click pick up for the other shirts.***********		 $31.95
Pizza Gemelle – Pizza, Natty Wine & More T-Shirt (Brown)
*******If shipping please write address in special instructions. If ordering more then one shirt only click shipping once and click pick up for the other shirts.***********		 $31.95
Ribolla Gialla T-Shirt (White)
*******If shipping please write address in special instructions. If ordering more then one shirt only click shipping once and click pick up for the other shirts.***********		 $31.95
Ventuno T-Shirt (Grey)
*******If shipping please write address in special instructions. If ordering more then one shirt only click shipping once and click pick up for the other shirts.***********		 $31.95
Bevande
Bottled Water $2.85
Club Soda $2.30
Soda $2.30
San Pellegrino Mineral Water $3.45
San Pellegrino
Italian mineral water.
750ml is $7.00		 $8.00
Birra
Bud Light $6.85
Cisco Gripah $6.85
Heineken 0.0 (Non Alcoholic) $6.85
Peroni $6.85
Stella Artois $6.85
Red Wines
’16 Guido Rivella ‘Fausoni’ Barbaresco
Previous winemaker for Angelo Gaja, Rivella makes a wine with a strong personality, mainly evident in its finesse, elegance, and spiciness, highlighted by notes of licorice and chocolate.		 $144.80
’19 Dom. La Taupe ‘AK400’ Gamay
Longer maceration than what is typical of the Loire, yielding a juicy but sinister dark cherry. Partial whole cluster keeps this Gamay structured and complex, with crunchy minerals and an array of dark fruits. The first sip is a mouth full of juice, red, fruity and ripe. (Another French wine, sorry Elio!)		 $45.60
’19 Dom. Leonine ‘Bottle Neck’ Grenache/Syrah
Domaine Leonine is a fierce advocate for organic farming and making living wines, unfiltered and with virtually no intervention in the cellar. Beautifully ripe red fruit, with just a hint of white pepper spice. An all-round good time.		 $45.60
’20 Domaine De La Taupe ‘Bruno Bert’
100% Cot, or Malbec, this wine stems from Loire Valley. 40% whole bunch, short maceration in fibreglass, then aged in old barrels for 12 months. Zero SO2. (NATTY LOVERS COMMENCE). Charcoal, deep black minerals, blackberry and dark chocolate. I love the length here – and the acidity which is perfectly integrated and ever so slightly tart. For a bigger wine it’s still so fresh, with a very lively vibe.		 $38.80
’21 Ampeleia ‘Un Litro’ Toscana Rosso
A blend of Grenache, Carignan and Alicante Bouschet from the Tuscan coast made by female winemaker Elisabetta Foradori. Red-fruited and juicy, this is perfect for pizza night or to just share with friends (we won’t judge you if it’s just for you either).		 $26.25
19′ Clos Fornelli Robe D’Ange, Sciacarelli, Corsica
100% Sciacarellu! From Corsica! Light, strawberry and balsamic. A bit of structure so not a straight up choogler, but an awesome summer sipper.		 $27.40
Whites & Rose
’18 Edi Kante Vitovska, Friuli
I KANT(E) stop drinking this zippy, white Vitovska (thats the varietal) from NE Italy. Think wet river stones in Yellowstone after getting stalked by a mountain lion. Okay but for real, lemon curd, creamy, white flowers (honeysuckle!) oily texture meets almond cake. DO IT.		 $47.90
’18 Punta Crena Matoassu, Liguria
Bright and light with green reflections. This crispy boi is from the Ligurian coast and has tons of fresh salinity and zingy acidity. CHEERFUL & CHUGGABlE!		 $33.10
’19 Alois Lageder Chardonnay
This lean and crisp Chardonnay comes from Trentino-Alto Adige (NE Italy) and is steely, mineral driven and has notes of crisp lemon water and white flowers. Unoaked Chardonnay with a beautiful mouthfeel from a biodynamic producer, this white SLAPS.		 $18.25
’20 Rado Rebula Orange
Orange wine (its not red, its not white, its not even rose, its ORANGE!) made from Rado’s 25-35-year-old Rebula (Ribolla Gialla) vines grown in BRDA’s reputed sandstone/clay marl, or ponka in local dialect. Given three weeks on the skins, this wine is textured yet not immensely tannic.		 $28.50
’21 Burlotto Sauvignon
Okay so sauvi b is sauvi b, but this is BURLOTTO sauvi b so is automatically elevated onto an ethereal and superior level. This wine is crisp, clean and citrusy while being complex but at the same time approachable. Try it I dare you.		 $29.65
Gift Certificates
Gemelle Bucks
Good for one Margherita		 $17.10
Gift Certificate
Redeemable at Gemelle, Ventuno, and Via Mare		 $28.50
Specials
Dozen Wings
Garlic seasoned Wood fired jumbo wings tossed in lemon and parm (sundays only)		 $18.25
Italian Panuozzo
Spicy Soppresatta, Mortadella, prosciutto, speck, giardiniera, mozzarella & shredded lettuce.		 $20.55
Square Slice $6.85
Prosciutto Panino
arugula roasted peppers mozzarella prosciutto di Parma on homemade focaccia		 $17.10
Antipasti
Giardiniera
Assortment of vegetables pickled at their peak with vinegar and spices		 $8.00
Taralli
An Italian Cracker/Bread Stick, flavored with Rosemary. Great with a dip or charcuterie board & cheeses. Pack Description 300gr		 $9.15
Marinated Olives
House cured olives marinated with fennel, blood orange zest and house mixed spices.		 $8.00
Insalata
Arugula Salad
Baby arugula, shaved Parmigiano, lemon vinaigrette.		 $10.30
Arthur Ave Salad
Romaine, Ricotta salata, olives, pepperoncini, red onions, prosciutto cotto, red wine vinaigrette.		 $16.00
Cucumber Salad $11.40
Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Gemelle Mozzarella, basil and tomato sauce.		 $21.70
Emilia Pizza
Gemelle Mozzarella, tomato sauce, garlic oil, prosciutto.		 $22.80
Annabella Pizza
Gemelle Mozzarella, sliced guanciale, black truffles, cracked egg.		 $28.50
Giovanni Pizza
Potatoes, rosemary, parmesan, olive oil, sea salt.		 $19.40
Salsiccia E Friarelli Pizza
House pork sausage, Friarelli (an italian broccoli rabe, marinated in olive oil and chili), mozzarella and basil (white pie)		 $22.80
Quattro Formaggi Pizza
Parmigiano, gemelle Mozzarella, Fontal, Gorgonzola, basil.		 $22.80
Capricciosa Pizza
Artichokes, Mushrooms, Olives, Prosciutto Cotto, Gemelle Mozzarella		 $23.95
Scampi Pizza
fresh white shrimp, D.O.P. pesto Genovese, parsley, basil & parmigiano *contains nuts*		 $23.95
Spinaci Pizza
spinach, ricotta, fontina, garlic & cave-aged pecorino		 $23.95
Marinara Pizza
tomato sauce, oregano, basil, garlic, olive oil		 $19.40
Calabrese Pizza
Marinara with red onions and ‘nduja		 $22.80
Nonno Pizza
Marinara pie topped with arugula, sliced prosciutto and fresh robbiola cheese		 $26.25
Meatball Calzone
Meatballs, mozzarella, basil, fontina, and parm		 $27.40
Mortadella Pizza
Mozz, fontina cheese, arugula, shaved parm and mortadella		 $22.80
Carbonara Pizza
Pizza topped with fresh mozzarella, crispy guanciale, pecorino romano, cracked black pepper, and a sunny side up egg.		 $23.95
Funghi E Speck Pizza
Woodfire roasted mushrooms, speck (smoked proscuitto), smoked mozzarella, basil, parmigiano reggiano		 $26.25
Diavola Pizza
Spicy salami, taggiasca olives, red chili flakes		 $22.80
Spring Asparagus Pizza
citrus herb ricotta, grilled spring onions, asparagus, house mozzarella.		 $23.95
Dolci
Tiramisu
Housemade ladyfingers, Nantucket coffee roasters espresso, whipped mascarpone and cocoa powder.		 $12.55
Nutella Pizza
Gemelle pizza dough topped with Nutella		 $17.10
Extras
3 Oz Tomato Sauce $1.75
Holy Oil $1.15
Chili Flakes $0.30
Parm $0.90
Cook at Home
Pizza Dough $4.60
Pizza Kit
Dough for 2 pizzas, tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil & parm		 $22.80
Stuffed Shells
In tomato sauce, stuffed with ricotta, topped with mozzarella and parsley.		 $16.00
Ventuno Meatballs
8 of Ventuno’s pork and beef meatballs in tomato sauce.		 $30.80
Merchandise
Pizza Gemelle – Pizza, Natty Wine & More T-Shirt (Brown)
*******If shipping please write address in special instructions. If ordering more then one shirt only click shipping once and click pick up for the other shirts.***********		 $31.95
Pies Are Always Hot T-Shirt (Pink)
*******If shipping please write address in special instructions. If ordering more then one shirt only click shipping once and click pick up for the other shirts.***********		 $31.95
Ribolla Gialla T-Shirt (White)
*******If shipping please write address in special instructions. If ordering more then one shirt only click shipping once and click pick up for the other shirts.***********		 $31.95
Ventuno T-Shirt (Grey)
*******If shipping please write address in special instructions. If ordering more then one shirt only click shipping once and click pick up for the other shirts.***********		 $31.95
Gift Certificates
Gemelle Bucks
Good for one Margherita		 $17.10
Gift Certificate
Redeemable at Gemelle, Ventuno, and Via Mare		 $28.50
Bevande
Club Soda $2.30
Soda $2.30
Bottled Water $2.85
San Pellegrino Mineral Water $3.45
Aranciata
Italian sparkling orange soda		 $3.45
Limonata
Italian sparkling lemon soda		 $3.45
San Pellegrino
Italian mineral water.
750ml is $7.00		 $8.00
Birra
Peroni $6.85
Stella Artois $6.85
Bud Light $6.85
Cisco Gripah $6.85
Heineken 0.0 (Non Alcoholic) $6.85
Whites & Rose
’18 Punta Crena Matoassu, Liguria
Bright and light with green reflections. This crispy boi is from the Ligurian coast and has tons of fresh salinity and zingy acidity. CHEERFUL & CHUGGABlE!		 $33.10
’18 Edi Kante Vitovska, Friuli
I KANT(E) stop drinking this zippy, white Vitovska (thats the varietal) from NE Italy. Think wet river stones in Yellowstone after getting stalked by a mountain lion. Okay but for real, lemon curd, creamy, white flowers (honeysuckle!) oily texture meets almond cake. DO IT.		 $47.90
’19 Alois Lageder Chardonnay
This lean and crisp Chardonnay comes from Trentino-Alto Adige (NE Italy) and is steely, mineral driven and has notes of crisp lemon water and white flowers. Unoaked Chardonnay with a beautiful mouthfeel from a biodynamic producer, this white SLAPS.		 $18.25
Red Wines
’19 Dom. Leonine ‘Bottle Neck’ Grenache/Syrah
Domaine Leonine is a fierce advocate for organic farming and making living wines, unfiltered and with virtually no intervention in the cellar. Beautifully ripe red fruit, with just a hint of white pepper spice. An all-round good time.		 $45.60
’19 Dom. La Taupe ‘AK400’ Gamay
Longer maceration than what is typical of the Loire, yielding a juicy but sinister dark cherry. Partial whole cluster keeps this Gamay structured and complex, with crunchy minerals and an array of dark fruits. The first sip is a mouth full of juice, red, fruity and ripe. (Another French wine, sorry Elio!)		 $45.60
’16 Guido Rivella ‘Fausoni’ Barbaresco
Previous winemaker for Angelo Gaja, Rivella makes a wine with a strong personality, mainly evident in its finesse, elegance, and spiciness, highlighted by notes of licorice and chocolate.		 $144.80
’20 Domaine De La Taupe ‘Bruno Bert’
100% Cot, or Malbec, this wine stems from Loire Valley. 40% whole bunch, short maceration in fibreglass, then aged in old barrels for 12 months. Zero SO2. (NATTY LOVERS COMMENCE). Charcoal, deep black minerals, blackberry and dark chocolate. I love the length here – and the acidity which is perfectly integrated and ever so slightly tart. For a bigger wine it’s still so fresh, with a very lively vibe.		 $38.80

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Christopher Henderson-West
Small shop with Great Pizza. Ordered the Diavola. Made right in front of you and takes about 20 minutes from order to finish. Had to stop myself from going two days in row! Would definitely come back.

… more

Helen F
We had the Capricciosa Pizza for lunch. Very fresh ingredients & tasty thin crust. It’s extremely thin, which we like, but too thin for the toppings. Very wet and limp in the middle of pie.

… more

Jen Shiman
Absolutely fantastic pizza. Very Italian-like. Tiny pizzas with 4 pieces each. We got 3 for lunch for a family of 5 and that was perfect. If really hungry-you could eat a whole one yourself. Just got take out, not a lot of space to eat inside.

… more

William Campbell
Added “extra crispy” in the comments, got it soggy, so no dice. Paid $3 for arugula on the pizza. Look at the picture. Also paid $3 for anchovies. Also see picture.

… more

Nikki Montgomery
Delicious pizzas and fast, friendly service!

… more

Lisa
Great pizza made really quickly, plus homemade gelato, cannoli, and a nice Aperol Spritz! Perfect meal. My favorite pizza so far is the Capricciosa, but I can’t wait to go back to try the Emilia and the potato pizza! The margherita is a perfect starting point for exploring this pizza menu. The tomato sauce is just so good. Will definitely be back here again and again and again.

… more

Jonathan McEuen
This is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. If you eat meat, their sausage is so perfect on the potato/rosemary pizza (I also added Gorgonzola). Fresh, delicious, easy to grab and go.

… more

Giorgio Giardina
Delicious pizza, great priced wine, friendly staff, amazing vibes. And they are Ferrari fans. 10/10

… more

Timmy T301
One time the owner made me feel like my pizza didn’t matter. I asked them for no tomatoes. He just looked at me and shook his head.

… more

Lee Milazzo
Great Artisan Pizza, Friendly Staff and a really nice wine selection!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch