Wood-fired pizzas & breads earn raves at this stylish American spot offering gluten-free options. Based on 375 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
106 Seneca St, Geneva, NY 14456
Phone: (315) 789-4070
Website: https://www.halseysgeneva.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 5–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
| Sunday | 5–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kerry Hanley
I don’t know how places like this stay open. The food is very expensive ($30-$45 entrees) and just ok. The portions are reasonable, but not huge, and the service was abysmal. It took us almost two hours to have dinner because our waitress was so busy with another table of 12 that we had to go looking for her when we wanted to order dessert. The only good thing was the “complimentary” bread and oil – extremely yummy, but we couldn’t get enough because our waitress was so lousy. She even left empty water jugs and dishes on our table that we had to ask her to refill and clear. For the amount we paid for dinner, we should have had outstanding food and excellent service. This place is very disappointing, and we won’t be back.
… more
Brad Watson
Everything we had was great but the pork shank took the cake. Noah was an awesome server too, very professional.
… more
Teley Quarshie
They were out of a lot of items. I ordered the halseys salad that comes with goat cheese- it came out with blue cheese and when I brought it to my servers attention she said it was feta cheese. I asked for a “complicated” soda (ginger ale Shirley temple with a splash of pineapple & lime wedge) and it wasn’t done correctly- which is frustrating because if I ordered a dirty martini straight up bone dry ice on the side with blue cheese stuffed olives it would have been correct. Why did I order a soda that way- because there was no Mocktail menu to order from. The burnt ends presentation could have been better- no garnish just a bowl of meat. The crab cakes were dry and lacked flavor. The French fries were undercooked. I highly regret not just getting a pepperoni pizza. the food was underwhelming, the service could have been better. I couldn’t wait to finish and leave- highly disappointed in all aspects of the meal. The complimentary bread and oil was the best part! Warm, fluffy and lots of flavor. My daughter enjoyed her steak and my husband enjoyed his burger said it was a bit messy but if ever in Geneva again I won’t be returning to Halseys. The hostess was the BEST part she had great energy and was very kind and helpful. I really liked her and appreciate her going above and beyond I hope she gets tipped out.
… more
Ka Ren
Their pizzas are awesome good. It didn’t over burn the crust at all. The crust feel so soft. There is so many special pizzas on the menu. Their truffle tots are amazing too.
… more
Emrys Davis
Was busy, and we didn’t have a reservation so we sat at the bar. I got a dozen oysters, braised pork shank and a whiskey flight. My wife got a pizza (don’t remember which) and the meatballs. Everything was amazing! Probably top 5 meatballs I have ever had.
… more
Grounded Geneva
Had a wonderful meal for my daughter’s 16th birthday. The vegetarian lasagna is her favorite!
… more
Charlene Steffel
Halsey’s was truly a great experience. It had great food, a great atmosphere and great service. We got a pizza, the lobster bisque and a salad. The soup was huge and I’d definitely recommend sharing it since it’s so rich, as is characteristic of lobster bisque. It has great flavor, although if you’re expecting a lobster bisque with lobster chunks this won’t have that. The bread and dipping oil was delicious and the oil has several little sections of things: crushed red pepper, garlic and Parmesan. Both of our salads (the Caesar and the Halsey’s salad) were amazing. The Halsey’s was so flavorful with the feta, mandarin oranges and dressing adding a great combo of flavors. The pizza was very good out of their wood fire grill. We also had their Margarita, which was absolutely delicious with all fresh flavors and none of that “mix” taste. If you’re in the area I’d definitely recommend making a stop here. They have a good selection of food for an array of budgets: from pizzas and salads to full dinner entrees (that also looked phenomenal even though we got the lighter meals).
… more
Roman
Nice restaurant in Geneva. Good selection of local and National wines. The duck wings were tasty and the rest of the menu was as good.
… more
Steve McLaughlin
Got into Geneva on a dark February night and we were so lucky to stumble on to Halsey’s! My wife and i sat at the cozy bar and had a great bottle of wine and some delicious small plates. Bartender/server/manager was friendly, professional and knowledgeable about local wines. Highly recommend.
… more
Leonard
Gorgeous building and the food was outstanding. Service was excellent. Will return each time we visit Geneva. May be our new favorite place in town.
… more
… View more