Lakefront eatery serving American dishes in woody, inviting surrounds with views & an upstairs deck. Based on 576 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
115 W Lake Rd, Mayville, NY 14757
Phone: (716) 753-3960
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: webbscaptainstable.comopentable.com
Reviews
Lisa Frederick
Nice large restaurant. We sat upstairs outside so we could have a view of Lake Chautauqua. Arrived at 4 pm when they opened on a Friday evening, so there wasn’t a wait. We started by ordering drinks. A Margarita ($12.00) and a Blueberry Remedy ($10.50), both of which were good but very small. Barely 8 oz of liquid by time the ice was added to the glass. The variety of rolls came out warm and were delicious. My husband and I both ordered the Chicken Mediterranean, which was presented very well and was delicious. Lastly, their dinners do not include salads, so we ordered house salads in addition to our dinner for a $13.90 up charge for 2. Our waitress was friendly and good at her job. If we are back in the area, we will probably eat there again for the location.
… more
Jasmine Hanson
From my parents who had dinner there this evening– We came for our 33rd anniversary dinner tonight, thinking we were going to receive 5 star dining based on the prices, however, we were WRONG.
… more
Kaylee Taylor
Brynn made our entire experience at Captains table restaurant one to remember. As a young mutant filled with radioactive oooze, Brynn dabbed some of my Chernobyl goodness off the table when needed. Her demeanor was extremely kind. At one point, I watched the delightful Brynn roundhouse kick to a Tarantula that was trying to steal my baked potato. If it wasn’t for Brynn and her quick to act on high stress-level situations, I may not have gotten to enjoy my baked potato.
… more
Zerø
Me and my family dined in tonight and our experience was enjoyable on a very high bar. The food was prepared perfectly and presented extremely well. The look of the place, the atmosphere, and service were all exceptional and quite appreciated. Personally my first time here and it’s a favorite already.
… more
Sue Moore
Wonderful meal to celebrate our 52nd anniversary after a cruise on the Chautauqua Belle. We dined outside on the upper deck and had a great view of the lake. Our waitress was friendly and very professional. Our meals were Chicken Mediterranean and Scallops. Both were outstanding and we hope to go back again soon!
… more
Heather Lowe
Never got an automatic refill on water. Had to ask each time for each family member. Soup came out with my entree. Greetings staff was wonderful throughout the entire visit. Our waitress was new, spilled a beer on the next table over, and I overheard him say she charged me for it, too. Ugh! Hope when we go back we have a better experience. Place looks amazing.
… more
Casey Wolfe
Sat on the deck- didn’t have the food we got before. Asked about another menu and that’s now considered the “bar” menu and was told we can only get that food inside at the bar. So we asked to move. Got the “bar” menu and ordered. Noticed another couple upstairs also moved inside for the other menu. It doesn’t make sense to not serve the same food everywhere in the restaurant.
… more
Candace Maguire
I had the Filet Oscar and our guests had the Chicken Parmesan . The presentation on both entrees was fabulous. And the food was extremely delicious! We only visit the area once a year, but we will most assuredly return next year. It is a hidden jewel!
… more
Martha Pascarella
My dinner was called th Oscar, I think. It’s totally delicious. I will order this again. I love how they pair the wine with the dinner. Wait staff so friendly. Great experience for all.
… more
Paul Barina
We stumbled about this restaurant when we realized another local spot was seasonally closed. We didn’t realize it but it was a little more formal than anticipated so we sat in the bar area which worked out just fine. The food was tasty and service friendly. It is a little pricey but we felt the food quality was worth it. I would recommend!
… more
… View more