The Mad Sicilian Menu – Petaluma, CA

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Petaluma, CA

Based on 58 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

The Mad Sicilian 94954

Address:
203 N McDowell Blvd, Petaluma, CA 94954

Phone: (707) 766-8600

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Friday 3–9 PM
Saturday 12–9 PM
Sunday 12–8 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
 3–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 3–9 PM

Menu

Make Your Own Creation
Napolitana Style Pazza Pizza
The Classic Cheese Pizza can be transformed to your greatest pizza creation. Enjoy it as Cheese pizza or use our amazing Napolitana Style crust, a hand tossed blank canvas ready for your masterpiece. Add toppings as desired. You should know that this may become an addictive habit.		 $14.50
The Sicilian Classic Pizza
Genuine Sicilian pizza just like grandma made. Thick, soft in the middle, and crunchy on the bottom crust topped with mozzarella cheese, our zesty tomato sauce, and green onions. Be creative add a topping or two.		 $23.75
Authentic Chicago Style Pizza
A stuffed deep dish pizza that will transport you back to Chicago. This is an extreme cheese pizza that you can add toppings to transform your pizza into something unforgettable.
*Comes with our Zesty Red pizza sauce. Creamy Pesto is available as pictured for an additional fee.		 $17.75
Specialty Pizza
The Mad Sicilian Pizza
The Americano… Celebrating our freedom month with a new spicy pizza. Our famous Napolitana crust topped with a NEW spicy Garlic Sauce, Mozzarella, Hot Italian Sausage, Ground Hot Link, Roasted Red Peppers, Sun Dried Tomatoes and Fresh Basil.
Just the right amount of heat; however, If your desire is more heat… Mike’s Hot Honey is available!!		 $23.00
The Sicilian Half Classic & Half Pepperoni Pizza
Genuine Sicilian pizza just like grandma made. Thick, soft in the middle, and crunchy on the bottom crust topped with mozzarella cheese, our zesty tomato sauce, and green onions. Be creative add a topping or two.		 $26.75
Club Lucky
An ALL time favorite pizza combination… Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms and Black Olives.
Photo of this uncooked Chicago Style pizza is for a visual of the toppings inside! Deep Dish pizzas may take up to 45 mins to bake depending on size.		 $27.00
Gioco (Gee-O-Co)
Taking a Meatball sub to a new level… This amazing Chicago Style pizza is filled with our delicious Meatballs and in-house Roasted Garlic, topped with our famous Zesty pizza sauce and Ricotta Cheese then topped with Fresh Basil… I want it NOW!! Photo of this uncooked Chicago Style pizza is for a visual of the toppings inside! Deep Dish pizzas may take up to 45 mins to bake depending on size.		 $31.00
Green Door
A vegetarian Feast!! Spinach, Green Onion, Green Olives and Artichoke Hearts covered then topped with our Homemade Creamy Pesto Sauce
Photo of this uncooked Chicago Style pizza is for a visual of the toppings inside! Deep Dish pizzas may take up to 45 mins to bake depending on size.		 $30.00
Lottie’s Pub
Our fun twist on classic Hawaiian flavors… Capicola, Bacon, Pineapple and Green Onions covered then topped with our famous Zesty Pizza Sauce!
​Photo of this uncooked Chicago Style pizza is for a visual of the toppings inside! Deep Dish pizzas may take up to 45 mins to bake depending on size.		 $28.00
Room 21
Some of my favorite topping combos… Italian Sausage, Spinach, Roasted Red Peppers & Pepperoncini covered then topped with our famous Zesty Pizza Sauce
Photo of this uncooked Chicago Style pizza is for a visual of the toppings inside! Deep Dish pizzas may take up to 45 mins to bake depending on size.		 $29.00
Twin Anchors
For the Traditionalist: Chicago’s favorite Combo… Double Italian Sausage & Cheese, covered then topped with our famous Zesty Pizza Sauce.
Photo of this uncooked Chicago Style pizza is for a visual of the toppings inside! Deep Dish pizzas may take up to 45 mins to bake depending on size.		 $23.00
The 226 Club
Craving a lil’ bit of heat?… Capicola, Pepperoni, Hot Italian Sausage & Jalapeno covered then topped with our famous Zesty Pizza Sauce!
Photo of this uncooked Chicago Style pizza is for a visual of the toppings inside! Deep Dish pizzas may take up to 45 mins to bake depending on size.		 $29.00
Crazy Greek Pizza
The Crazy Greek… “my wife made me do it”!
Our famous Napolitana crust topped with our own homemade Creamy Sundried Tomato Pesto, Chef George’s Authentic homemade Gyro meat, Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onions and Green Onions then finished with dollops of Chef George’s homemade Tzatziki, a dusting of Cayenne Pepper and freshly chopped Italian Parsley! Are you drooling yet!? Yep… Gryo + Pizza = Gyroizza!! Your going to CRAVE IT!!

Be sure to get an extra side of Tzatziki!!

 $34.00
5 Cheese Extravaganza
The Mad Sicilian twisted an all time favorite… A Classic Cheese Pizza. There is nothing classic about this cheesy cheese pizza… Our Famous Napolitana Crust topped with 5 delicious Cheeses just perfect for the Cheese Lover in all of us!! **STRACCIATELLA, MOZZARELLA, PROVOLONE, PARMESAN, ASIAGO		 $33.00
Our Mad Pizzas
Mount Etna Pizza
Our amazing Napolitana Style, hand tossed crust topped with Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Linguica, Hot Italian Sausage, Bacon, and Jalapenos. Just enough heat to wake up your taste buds. If you need a bit more heat… Order the Hot Honey Dip. It’ll really spice things up.		 $30.00
Taormina Pizza
Our amazing Napolitana Style, hand tossed crust topped with Spinach, Italian Sausage, Pepperoncini, Roasted Red Peppers, Bacon and Feta. My personal favorite combo!		 $30.00
Ragusa Pizza
Our amazing Napolitana Style, hand tossed crust topped with Genoa Salami, Canadian bacon, Pepperoni, Linguica, Italian Sausage and Bacon. Yes, it’s ALL meat… for those that don’t like veggies.		 $31.00
Catania Pizza
Our amazing Napolitana Style, hand tossed crust topped with Spinach, Mushrooms, Roasted red Peppers, Black Olives, Arugula and Balsamic Glaze. Definitely not your ordinary vegetarian pizza…		 $33.00
Palermo Pizza
Our amazing Napolitana Style, hand tossed crust topped with Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Red onions and Black Olives. There’s nothing like a classic combo! An All-time fave.		 $30.00
Hawaiian Pizza
Our amazing Napolitana Style, hand tossed crust topped with Canadian Bacon, Pineapple and Green Onions. Sweet and Savory…think outside the box and add a lil’ something unexpected.		 $21.00
Syracuse Pizza
Want something without red sauce? This delicious pizza is Creamy Pesto adding a unique flavor to an amazing pizza. Our amazing Napolitana Style, hand tossed crust topped with Pesto Sauce, Italian Sausage, Fresh Mozzarella, Artichoke Hearts, Green Onions, and Cherry Tomatoes.		 $30.00
The Soprano Pizza
THE SOPRANOS! A Mad Sicilian pizza so popular we added it our menu! Your taste buds will thank you!
Our Napolitana Pizza topped with our very own Mad Sicilian Sauce, Fresh Spinach, Fresh Fennel (slivered and marinated), Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Chicken and Fresh Zest.

*No substitutions.

 $26.52
Margherita Pizza
Our amazing Napolitana Style, hand tossed crust topped with Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Tomatoes and Fresh Basil. A lite, refreshing change from the more classic pizzas. Sometime less is MORE!		 $22.00
Mount Vulcano
The Mad Sicilian twist on an all time favorite… The Hawaiian. We added just a bit of spice to this usually sweet pizza. Our Napolitana Crust topped with Pepperoni, Capicola, Pineapple, Green Onions and Jalapeño. Just enough of the spice and sweet to satisfy your cravings!
If you need a bit more heat… Order the Hot Honey Dip. It’ll really spice things up.		 $26.00
Luciano
**LUCIANO** a True Sicilian Artisan Pizza!
This delicious pizza on our Famous Napolitana Crust is lightly brushed with our very flavorful Zesty Pizza Sauce, Fresh Arugula, a dash of Mozzarella, Capicola then finished with our Mad Sicilian Magic! Simply Devine!		 $26.00
The Betty
The Bodacious BETTY!! A favorite combination of the Original American Sweetheart! Our famous Napolitana crust topped with a Vodka Cream Sauce, Spinach, Mozzarella, Sausage, Ricotta, Roasted Garlic, Cherry Tomatoes then finished with Sriracha!
Eat and Enjoy like the Stars!		 $29.00
Terrasini
An ALL time Classic on our Famous Napolitana Crust. A true crowd pleaser!! Double Pepperoni and Hot Italian Sausage.		 $23.00
Specials
2 Large Cheese Pizza, 2 Bottles Of Soda Special $45.00
Favorite Appetizers
Mama’s Italian Meatballs
Tender meatball’s simmered in our Basil Marinara Sauce. A perfect compliment to your pizza.		 $9.75
Parmigiana Garlic Breadsticks
Our Parmigiana Garlic Breadsticks are freshly made per order and accompanied with a side of our famous Zesty Marinara Sauce OR Creamy Ranch. Make sure everyone in your party enjoys these… they may keep the Vampires away. 🙂		 $8.25
Zuppa Del Giorno
Bringing a little warmth to you and your family with a different soup each day. Please call for the flavor of day.
Pictured is Creamy Tomato Basil.
Pair famously with our 5 Cheese Extravaganza Pizza!!		 $5.99
From The Garden
Capone Salad
A refreshing delight, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, bell peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, pepperoncini, Genoa Salami and mozzarella cheese.		 $7.15
Caesar Salad
An Italian classic, romaine lettuce, shredded Parmesan cheese, and our very own homemade croutons.		 $7.15
Danza Salad
Sometimes less is more, Romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, sweet baby bell peppers, English cucumber, green onions, mozzarella and Parmigiana		 $7.15
Zorba Salad
A refreshing Greek Salad! Crisp Romaine Lettuce, Cherry Tomatoes, Bell Peppers, Red Onion, English Cucumber, Kalamata Olives and Feta topped with George’s Homemade Original Greek Salad Dressing. OPA!!		 $7.15
Luigi
Yess… Colossal Lump Crab lightly marinated in a George specialty, on a bed Fresh Romaine Lettuce, English Cucumber, Cherry Tomatoes, Pepperoncini and Kalamata Olives. Topped with George’s House made Lemon Vinaigrette .
Available NOW but only for a limited time! serves one		 $12.00
Mike’s Hot Honey Dip Cup
Mike’s Hot Honey Dip Cup
Honey with a kick! For drizzling on pizza, dipping crust, and more. If you prefer to include ingredients as well, it can be ‘Ingredients: honey, chili’s, vinegar’.		 $1.55
For Your Sweet Tooth
Cannoli
An authentic Sicilian pastry shell filled with cannoli cream dipped in chocolate and almonds, then sprinkled with powdered sugar. Straight from my childhood.		 $4.25
Crème Brulee
Crème Brulee: also known as burnt cream or Trinity cream is a decadent dessert consisting of a rich, velvety custard base topped with a layer of hardened caramelized sugar to add the desired crunch and the perfect amount of sweetness. It’s normally served slightly chilled; the heat from the caramelizing process tends to warm the top of the custard, while leaving the center cool. I know you want to dive into this tin of deliciousness I head first. Limited quantities per day, so order fast!! They won’t last!! 🙂		 $4.25
Sicilian Lemon Tartlet
Straight from the Lemon Tree in our backyard. The lemon curd a perfect balance of sweet and tart filling a flaky pie crust topped with a thin slice of candied lemon. A prefect dessert.		 $4.25
Chocolate Mousse
Divinely smooth and velvety chocolate mousse with just the right amount of sweetness.		 $4.25
S’mores Chocolate Cream Tart
S’mores Chocolate Cream Tart….New at The Mad Sicilian!
Bringing you memories of summertime campfires in The Mad Sicilian way…
Homemade Chocolate Cream fills this tart, topped with Graham Crackers and flame kissed Marshmallows!!		 $4.25
Dips
Ranch Dressing $1.55
Caesar Dressing $1.55
Tzatziki Dressing
An Authentic Greek Recipe Cucumber, Garlic, Yogurt Dip. You’ll think you are in Greece! It’s a favorite condiment at my house.		 $3.25
Pasta Dishes
Gnocchi Marinara
My children’s favorite. These delicious little Potato Dumplings are a staple in any Italian family. Lathered in our Famous Zesty Marinara Sauce these are Pure Yumminess!		 $10.95
Gnocchi Meatballs Marinara
My children’s favorite. These delicious little Potato Dumplings are a staple in any Italian family. Lathered in our Famous Zesty Marinara Sauce then topped with Mama’s Meatballs; these are Pure Yumminess!		 $13.95
Gnocchi Pesto
O.M.G.!! Gnocchi smothered in our homemade Creamy Pesto then topped with a bit of Mozzarella. Yum!		 $13.95
Tortellini Marinara
Who doesn’t LOVE Tortellini!? Pasta filled yumminess smothered in our homemade marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese and fresh basil.		 $10.95
Tortellini Meatballs Marinara
Who doesn’t LOVE Tortellini!? Pasta filled yumminess smothered in our homemade marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese and fresh basil. Add Meatballs to make it even BETTER!!		 $13.95
Tortellini Pesto
Who doesn’t LOVE Tortellini!? Pasta filled yumminess smothered in Homemade Creamy Pesto Sauce. Taking this classic to the next level!!		 $13.95
Polenta Marinara
Polenta made just like Grandma’s topped with our homemade Zesty Marinara Sauce.		 $8.95
Polenta Meatballs Marinara
Polenta made just like Grandma’s topped with our homemade Zesty Marinara Sauce with Momma’s Meatballs.		 $11.95
Polenta Pesto $11.50
Beverages
Soda $1.75

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Timothy Hudson
Great Pizza. Ordered the Deep-dish Chicago with Sausage. Incredibly fresh local ingredients. Full of flavor and worth the stop. The staff is friendly and dedicated to making the best pizza I have ever had. This is more than pizza but a culinary master piece! We should have taken pictures before devouring our first piece.

… more

NO NAME
The past two orders I’ve had have been great I absolutely loved the Luciano It was so flavorful and you can just tell that the marinara sauce is in housemade and it’s so delicious. The cannolis are so delicious I really like that they aren’t too sweet and the walnuts and dark chocolate really compliment the filling. The creme brulee is so divine I was craving it for days and I had to order it again I’m so pleased with my orders. I’m so excited to try more in the future

… more

Brittney Worley
Me and my husband were out at Dillion beach, and on our way home (we live in the valley) we wanted some pizza so I googled pizza…and here we ended up! This place was delicious, the crust had so much flavor which blew us away. The sauce wasn’t too salty, lots of flavor and same for the meat! We got meatballs on the house, and we ordered their breadsticks. The owner made the ordering experience personable and checked on us multiple times, that was so refreshing and left s lasting impression on us. I would drive over an hour just to go eat there again, that’s for sure!

… more

Bowman McNear
By far the best pizza in Petaluma, both regular crust and deep dish. I was amazed to find a place that can cook deep dish pizza identical to my favorite pizzeria in Chicago. Also, the monthly special pizzas are a great way to try unusual toppings you’ve never had before

… more

Akshat Kumar
A decent pizza place, we visited here on a Sunday evening and the place wasn’t busy at all. We ordered the Syracuse pizza and the size was good, apt for a medium pizza. The roasted garlic and red pepper toppings were great too.

… more

Sunny Fowles
We decided to eat here after we saw a few highly rated yelp reviews and oh my they didn’t disappoint! All my cheesey dreams came true! The tomatoes sauce on top was perfectly balanced! Don’t forget to add roasted garlic! The hunky Sicilian man herd my cry when I realized I could have added some to my pizza and added it anyway definitely a must! Do yourself a favor and eat here for dinner

… more

Cede DeFalco
I ordered the mad Sicilian for dinner. A half and half Sicilian pizza, bread sticks and the rhubarb cannolis. I actually ordered the tiramisu but they were out of stock so they called to let me know and asked what I would prefer to replace with. Very quick with only a 30 minute wait for delivery. Pizza was fluffy and crunchy. Sauce was good. I felt it was missing a little zest or that little oomph. But none the less it was good! I will be ordering again!

… more

Cynthia Valenzuela
My first visit and I will return. The tomato sauce tastes like fresh tomatoes. Ask for fresh roasted garlic on your pizza. And the cannoli is wonderful! Not gritty or too sweet and grated chocolate not mini chips. Owner and wife are so kind and friendly. A neighborhood Gem!

… more

Travis Rife
These folks know what they’re doing, and it’s clear that it’s done with a lot of love. We got a custom made Chicago style, and that pie was damn near 4 inches thick of luscious cheese and wonderfully crispy garlic brushed crust. Their cannoli are filled to order and make for a fantastic end of meal light desert. We plan on going back and trying their in-house made pasta soon.

… more

Ati K.
Call in and get the Mad Greek. You won’t regret it! Their deep dish is quite good as well and we also like their Sicilian style. The variety is great for families. One of our favorite places to eat in town!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch