Based on 305 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4943 NY-281, Cortland, NY 13045
Phone: (607) 299-4727
Website: http://www.aroundpizza.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–8 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Patrick Williams
It’s thin pizza, it’s very good thin pizza. Some of the reviews here are absurd. Not saying that they couldn’t have happened but I’d bet it was a rare misstep on their part. I’ve never had greasy pizza there. To one review, of course if they close at 8 they aren’t going to take a delivery order at 7:39. The dough is always amazing and it doesn’t taste like cardboard as one review said. Maybe it has been a little soggy for some, that can be expected with such thin crust. Add extra cheese and toppings, you are more likely to get it soggy. I guess it came out of the oven a couple minutes too soon, it happens. Overall, you can’t get better pizza in Cortland. Some have said it was salty…. not hardly. Thin pizza should have a hint of salt. That would be *my* only complaint, I have to add salt to mine. You rock Joe, keep banging them out. I know a certain new C-State freshman who will be ordering regularly. We’ve made stops in Cortland just to get a couple slices. I keep telling you… make poutine, it’ll sell like crazy. Get some steak fries, brown gravy and melt cheese curds on top. Lava fries are also a hit. Shoestring fries, hot sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese…. You’ll have all the Long Island kids at your door.
… more
John Smith
Well I ordered a pizza and 20 wings lastnight and I wanted half cheese and the other half pepperoni came to 50 plus a 2 dollar tip for the delivery guy. Well the delivery guy gave me someone else’s pizza I called a round pizza to tell them there’s been a mix up and the guy was like let me call the driver to see what happened and he said he’d call me back. Never called back. So now im mad and ill never ever order from these guys again plus the pizza was soggy and just gross. Cheaper to make My own
… more
Tara Welsh
We were traveling through the area and decided to stop based on the amazing reviews. My first thought…this has to be a different place but the name and front picture matched. To start off it was filthy. The floor and the rug at the counter were covered in dirt and the “decorations” could use a dusting. We ordered anyway. I told the counter person we were eating in and paid. I then went to find the bathroom. The hallway was blocked by a trash can and two crossed brooms. I said to the guy slinging dough that I need to use the bathroom. At first he tells the kid making boxes to move the stuff, then changes his mind and says the bathroom doesn’t work. I tell him I just want to wash my hands before I eat. He says they have no water. A seating area with no bathroom? A restaurant with no water? Seriously? We get our slices and look for napkins. My husband finds none and asks the counter person for some. She says they’re out. He asks for paper towels, she says they’re out of those too and offers us counter rags to wipe our hands and faces. For goodness sake, there is a grocery store across the street, take a $5 and go buy a pack of napkins! The pizza was ok, not nearly as good as I had hoped. We went to the grocery store to use the bathroom before continuing on our road trip. Really a terrible experience.
… more
ChosenOne OnlyOne
Best pizza in town and I’ve lived here my whole life. Only discovered them last month when my co-worker gave me his cold leftovers bc he was full and it was still the best pizza in town. You do get alot more meat from the boneless wings but whatever still cheap. Free delivery lets you tip a Lincoln to the driver
… more
Miranda Jacobs
We got two pizza but this is the buffalo chicken pizza is a nasty soggy mess! Hardly edible with what tastes like canned chicken. The other pepperoni and ground sausage was really good and the wings!
… more
Colby Reagan
Ordered 16 pizzas and they were all stellar! Much appreciation to Joe and staff for accommodating so many pies! But honestly, the best slices in town! Huge fan of the bbq chicken!
… more
Amber Jervis
We are staying at Hope Lake Lodge (at Greek Peak) and decided to stay in our first night after a day of traveling. When comparing reviews from the other three restaurants that deliver here A Round Pizza was a no-brainer. We ordered two medium pizzas and two Greek salads. As you can see from the pictures, they are very generous with toppings and their portions (both pizza and salad) are quite large! They didn’t have Greek dressing which I thought was odd, but I ended up using their Caesar which actually went well with my salad. There were huge chunks of feta and lettuce that had not been broken down which was more of a nuisance than anything. However, they used black olives over kalamata which technically isn’t a Greek salad. Also, the crust was a little dry. However, A Round Pizza was a pleasant treat after a long day and we would certainly order again the next time we stay at this resort. Oh, and for anyone staying here the minimum order for delivery is $50. When you compare prices at the resort restaurants this minimum is nothing and well worth it!
… more
Stephen Yang
Have you ever had A Round Pizza?
… more
kecia holmes
Pizza had a nice crunch to the crust!! Loved it and great prices!
… more
Linda B
Everything was great! We had a medium garlic basil tomato pizza and 2 orders of 10 wings with 2 different sauces for delivery (free in Cortland). Everything was hot when it arrived. The wings were all crispy but not dried out and the sauces were on point. The pizza was cooked properly, a NY style thin crust, very flavorful. The delivery guy was super nice. Easy to place the order and the person taking the order was also nice. I’m only here on vacation, so very happy to find this. My parents will definitely order from here in the future.
… more
… View more