Agatina’s Restaurant serves up homestyle Italian-American comfort food to the Rochester community in a relaxing, casual atmosphere. Here, our food is always made to order. We take great pride in our reputation for preparing only the finest and freshest ingredients. We are an Authentic Italian Restaurant!
Family-run Italian eatery with a large, kid-friendly menu & weekday deals. Based on 841 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2967 Buffalo Rd, Rochester, NY 14624
Phone: (585) 426-0510
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: agatinas.com
Reviews
Jonathan Canio
Wedding soup and seafood fra Diavola in scampi sauce was the best. My uncle had some bad pesto and it was replaced with another meal without any issues. Excellent service!
… more
Alexander Gamcsik
Had our rehearsal dinner here, and we are very glad we did. Management was patient with us and bent over backwards to make our night special. The food was great, everyone took home a lot of leftovers. My Chicken French was melt-in-mouth good (very thin cutlet and balanced flavor). The cookies and canolis were a great dessert! And the Italian Wedding Soup was amazing! We will be customers of Agatina’s for years to come!
… more
Alicia Bruscella
The food was delicious. I didn’t think it was too salty at all, which is unusual, but that means that they know how to flavor food without salt. Seriously, when you’re eating Italian food that has cheese, there’s no need to add salt. I loved thar they didn’t over salt the food. That is one of my biggest issues when I go out to eat.
… more
Delavan Smith
Very nice Italian restaurant. The shrimp scampi and artichoke French was delicious and my server Courtney was very attentive. Thank you. I will come here again.
… more
Katie Stock
I’m a bit perplexed about how well this place is rated, because it’s very inconsistent with my experience. I have been here several times over a decade and a half (not my choice), and I have never actually had a standout meal. The drinks poorly made, the wine list is overly sweet and one note, and the quality of the food isn’t nearly what it should be. I’ve had much better meals for half the price.
… more
David A
We had a party of 8. Our server was friendly, funny, and very helpful with recommendations. The appetizers and entrees were generous and delicious. I highly recommend Agatinas for anyone interested in good food and good atmosphere.
… more
Tracy Jong
Highly recommended. I went on Mother’s Day. Meal was fabulous. Full menu and amazing specials. Not out of anything despite bei g booked solid. Every seat was booked but the staff was amazing getting to everyone and minimizing the wait on such a busy day. My wait was no more than a busy friday or Saturday. One of the best holiday experiences I have ever had. I usually avoid busy holidays but they really made it wonderful.
… more
Matt Hilbert
Service was slow, but the staff was nice. The chicken was very rubbery in two different dishes, not super impressed. Was expecting better for the price.
… more
Ben Miele
Agatina’s has been our favorite Italian restaurant for years and we try to get here at least once a month. The Alfredo and Fra Diavola sauces are are some of the best I’ve ever had. Recently, they have started serving tripe as a special more often.
… more
Sam Cooper
We were shocked when we got our food. There are so many great reviews for the restaurant, and the place was packed! We thought the food would be to die for…until we got it. Looked like all the ingredients had been thrown together in a hurry. The dish tasted like it’d come right out of a can. My wife’s dish was exactly the same. We had both taken away, and we went home hungry.
… more
… View more