Longtime Italian restaurant, opened in 1926, serving pizza, pasta, salads, sandwiches & fried fare. Based on 495 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2607 N University St, Peoria, IL 61604
Phone: (309) 688-8200
Website: https://agatuccis.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 5–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
andrew cofield
I’ve been away from central Illinois for a while. The pan pizza from the old Leonardo’s at Gondola is great, and just how I remembered… But the incredible pizza at Agatucci’s is that cracker thin square cut bar pizza I cherished as a kid growing up here. Thin, crispy, packed with flavor and a bar/dining room packed with nostalgia that represents the very best in a locally family owned pizza pub. It’s perfect. Really perfect.
… more
George Hernandez
Good pizza , great hospitality and atmosphere, opened at 5 pm,but accomated every one pretty fast ,will visit again soon
… more
Melissa Hicks
Family business about 100 years in Peoria.
… more
Jen Benningfield
A true staple of Peoria. Service is always friendly and fast. Fried chicken is a favorite of many. Pizza is one of a kind. Prefer their special with sausage mushrooms onion and gp. Drinks are reasonable ( recommend pitchers for soda or beer, have wine crafts too ). Need reso for larger groups.
… more
Jake Zobrist
If you know you know. This place doesn’t need reviews but I feel I owe it a written acknowledgment. Here it goes: Best pizza ever hands downs. I will literally fight you over it. Try and find a better sausage pizza. It’s a spiritual experience to polish off a large by yourself. I use the tiger sauce as after shave just so I can smell like the pizza. I had my 16th and 21st bdays here along with my wedding rehearsal dinner. If I could live in the bank by the ovens I would. Sadly I don’t live near it anymore but it is my first stop when I come to town. If your aren’t convinced then it’s not for you. More pizza for me.
… more
Tony Powell
This is the closest thing to Chicago pizza you’ll get here. Similar to home run inn, not frozen the real one. It’s kinda shoulder to shoulder and take out isn’t normal, you pick up your pie and take it to the bar to pay. Lmao. Bit it’s good.
… more
Joe Thompson
This Peoria staple is iconic. Tony and his staff do a great job. The pizza is the best along with their secret recipe “tiger” sauce.
… more
Mary Kuchefski
Horrible experience on 4/23. Hour & a half wait for food. They ran out of sausage, so had to change pizza order. My spaghetti with meat sauce tasted burned, so had to send that back. One person in our group ordered fried chicken, but was told that the fryer oil was bad, so he had to get something else. Ridiculous. I felt sorry for the wait staff, they were so overwhelmed.
… more
Gypsy Russ
Friendly staff but the food was awful. The pizza looked good, but I ordered spaghetti, and the sauce was old tasting. I had a fettuccine Alfredo in mind, but they don’t have it on the menu. It was pretty gross
… more
Jacquelyn Lee
I Ordered a small pizza from here, granted I Ordered a small but I didn’t realize this small. I should’ve just cooked my frozen Jack’s pizza from Walmart that was $3 compared to this $25 pizza. Theres like no pizza sauce an looks like the cheese is dry, like when you make chips an cheese in the microwave. Taste like it’s been sitting pre-made an they just heated it up.
… more
… View more