Brick-oven pizzas, everyday pastas & other Italian comfort food offered in easygoing surrounds. Based on 282 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
170 N Main St, New City, NY 10956
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nash Williams
So I actually went into Agnello’s to buy a metal “Eat” sign they no longer wanted. Which I am enjoying in my kitchen… I was greeted with friendly faces and Diane, one of the owners. She was as cute as can be with an infectious smile telling me about the families history in the restaurant business…. I ended up ordering a large white pizza. I couldn’t pass up the opportunity with this kind of history! It said no sauce and with garlic… that’s me allll day! While it was cooking I asked one of the guys if they had garlic knots. No, nothing like that. A bit disappointing but the pizza was ready quick and I left. It was the perfect temperature when I got home and I started in. The crust was amazing…. the toppings? Just regular. I’m still struggling watching them use sliced cheese instead of shredded…. but it was good, just not like I though it might be. Diane was sweet, but she’s not making the pizzas. If I lived closer I’d try more. Will I drive 20 minutes for more? Probably not. Love the sign tho
… more
Christian
Simply the best pizza in rockland county and honestly better than a lot of the best places in Brooklyn, Jersey or New Haven, too. I’m telling everyone about this pizza. I wanna bathe in it. I wanna be christened in it. This is a pizza that breaks up with you but you say thank you when it does it. This is pizza you travel a long distance for and regret nothing. Run, don’t walk to Agnello’s.
… more
Mill Yanare
Had a house salad to start with dressing on the side. Salad was fresh and hearty. Service was ok should have been better. My first and only time here and my waitress started of good and attentive until towards the end of the meal when it was can I have my mom check time felt like a good 15 20 minutes had gone by at least and my waitress was no where to be found. Finally a waiter came by to see if everything was ok. Thankfully I was able to get the check from him. As I left I seen the waitress sitting at a table with someone. Looked like she was having a meeting with a boss I hope. Pizza was good and flavorful. I went on a night that it wasn’t crowded and had a plenty of parking available in the parking lot.
… more
Jonathan Collins (Images by Jonathan)
I grew up in New City, and haven’t been back to eat in a long time. Happened to be up on business, and we were recommended Angello’s by my lunch partner. Happy to say it was great. Fresh mozzarella and tomato pie, along with a bowl of tortellini or pasta fagioli soup was the lunch special. Can’t beat it! Another friend who was also eating here for the first time said it was great as well. Add a very friendly waitress and it was well worth it. Keep up the good work!
… more
I N
The food is legit. Very Old School Jazz bar/restaurant looking with nice slow old school music. I like that I can taste that it’s homemade. I ordered mozzarella sticks, and boy! They are the real deal. I can actually see the mozzarella is fresh, and the stix are huge. Really good for the price. The breading could use better flavor but it’s still good. Highly recommend. Even the tomato sauce is homemade.
… more
S A
Great pizza restaurant. Friendly, attentive service. The food is pretty good too. Thank you.
… more
Christina Paccione
I’ve dined at this restaurant a number of times. Never ever disappointed in the quality of the food and the service. They really do make you feel like you’re dining with family! Bon Appetite for sure!
… more
Nicholas Alonso
The food is really great, I had chicken parmesan. Only complaint is the tomato sauce is a little on the sweeter side.
… more
Catey & Dan
Went to eat here with a bunch of family members to see if we wanted to cater our daughters birthday party with them. After going back and forth many weeks speaking of the date many times even getting as far as placing the order only to be told when I was asking for the price that they aren’t open that day (a Saturday) and can’t help me..ridiculous. Poor communication. Was planning on spending $400. Will not be recommending.
… more
Danielle Clerkin
Coming from the Bronx, we moved here in 2020 & have ordered from every respectable pizza shop in Rockland & Agnellos is the only one worth coming back to. Every aspect of this pizza is fresh & delicious. I haven’t been in yet for dine in but I am curious to check out their dinner for 2 special if they’re still doing that.
… more
… View more