Based on 69 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
7026 Shore Terrace, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Phone: (317) 204-8433
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 2:30–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4:30–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 2:30–9 PM |
| Thursday | 2:30–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 2:30–9 PM |
| Saturday | 2:30–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Scott Roenigk
The pizza dough was fresh. The pizza tasted good. Carry out 20 minutes from ordering. I will not get pizza from the big chain restaurants again.
… more
Sierra
It was okay. The service was nice. It was done by the time I got there, but half my food was over cooked and not good. The pizza was good, but the breadsticks had no flavor (no butter or garlic) and were hard. First time trying this place. Not sure if I will give it a go again.
… more
Jasmine Tinsley
I ordered my pizza over the phone to pick up in store. When I arrived, I noticed a sign for a special, similar to what I ordered, but a larger size pizza for $4 less than my total. I asked the guy working why he didn’t tell me about the special. He said he’s supposed to get me to spend more money. I think it was a joke, and he said he would give me a discount next time, but I won’t be back. I used to order from there pretty regularly. They don’t appear to be a small business that can afford to lose customers to poor customer service, but Magoo’s is nearby and I’ll holler at them next time instead. Also, they changed their crust and it’s just ok. It was better before.
… more
Shannon M
Tried this place for the first time this evening; odered a Supreme. The pizza was about 12 minutes late, but there was only one person working there tonight, so totally understandable! We got home and ate it and o m g. Definitely will be back! Best pizza I have had in a while. You can tell everything is made fresh down to the bread sticks! Bravo Agostino’s!!!
… more
Kristin Burnett
Pizza comes with plenty of toppings, I got a small cheese pizza, added bacon. Another reviewer said they had thin crust, my crust wasn’t thin. It was very tasty. Boneless wings with bbq sauce weren’t anything special, they were just normal tenders. I still enjoyed them, they give big portion sizes. I would recommend this place.
… more
Cleo Brown
Ordered $60 worth of pizza and breadsticks for specific delivery time. No delivery was made. Business called after scheduled time to say they couldn’t process the order…too short staffed. Promised to credit payment made online, but 2 days later no credit or response from business. Buyer beware!
… more
Kipp Shinabarger
We tried Agostinos carry out tonight.
… more
Sharon Fowlkes
When it was family owned the pizza was awesome hot, on time and customer service was great! Now they are barely open never get my order right. I’m so disappointed because the pizza use to taste so authentic now it tastes blah will not waste my money any more
… more
T. Thompson
This pizza was so good they have Beef Pepperoni.
… more
cjordan
My wife and I have gotten sick from Agostino’s Pizza. Bland breadsticks and chicken wings were subpar. We had to toss the rest of the pizza to prevent us from getting more sick. We will not be doing Agostino’s again.
… more
… View more