Strip-mall parlor known for upside-down square pie serves basic Italian fare plus burgers & wraps. Based on 206 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
601-9 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
Phone: (631) 467-4674
Social Profile: 

Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: albertspizzamenu.com
Reviews
Madison Banfi
The best pizza on Long island! I stopped in here one day when i was nearby and i will never go to another place! Such an amazing atmosphere and the people working are all so welcoming and kind, The owner is such a great guy. The food was outstanding. I got a few slices of pizza, a salad for sister and a chicken parmigiana dinner for myself! It was all so tasty. This place has my business i will surely be coming back here soon!! Thank you alberts Pizza
… more
Collateral Beautie
I had a Buffalo slice and it was delicious.
… more
Freeda Freeda
I was just saying to a friend that the best pizza I’ve ever had was 30 yrs ago. I tried Albert’s pizza 2 days ago it was so go that I had to try it today. It was just as good. I strongly recommend trying it. The young lady at the counter is so friendly and welcoming. Customer satisfaction is an understatement.
… more
Dawn Dalto
Absolutely my favorite pizza ever! Grew up on the Albert’s in Copiague and was thrilled that this location was so close to me. The new owners are great! Kept the recipe for upside down pie. And introducing so many new items like the Caprese style pie, Buffalo chicken pie and so much more! Go there and see the new renovation! You won’t be disappointed!
… more
Joseph Kerns
Something CHANGED ! Not sure if all locations are affected. But my family has been going to Albert’s for more than 40 years. And now their signature square pie that made them famous is no more. All it is now is a square piece of dough painted with sauce by a paint brush, hardly any cheese and tastes horrible. It used to be so delicious. I can assure you, I know my pizza and am Sicilian. The pies used to have a thin crispy crust, lots of cheese and plenty of sauce on top. The sauce would drip off the slices as you ate. Best pizza ever. Now it is all gone. Even the crust is different, and not AIRY/CRISPY like it used to be. Now it is soft and chewy. The owner should be ashamed to lower the quality of such a famous food. Despicable !
… more
Pizza Queen
The best pizza and pasta around!!! This place shouldn’t only be known the upside down pie. Entrees are delicious and very well portioned. Not to mention the customer service was amazing. ❤️
… more
Dolores Chinnici
I stopped going here after the first time, awhile ago, because the pizza was not that great, but I understand the new owners took possession recently, and I decided to try it again. Delivery was super fast, and the pizza was absolutely delicious. I will be ordering everything from there. Perfect
… more
Lori
I got a delivery last night of a pie and some garlic knots. The pie was OK. New owners of taking over and it’s been much better than it was previously, but the garlic knots were burnt and inedible. Not really happy about that.
… more
Bianca Perricone
Food was perfect. Extremely family oriented, family owned business. Owner is so kind, friendly & personal. Warm atmosphere & high vibe. I never leave reviews, but they deserve this the way the owner & his sons portray their family business. Much love!
… more
George Koopmann
Not sure what happened when the new owners came in, but wow. Got the $50 deal they had and was very disappointed in the food. Sauce for the pizza was bitter, chicken wings looked like they came off a pigeon and the garlic knots were a little bigger than the size of a quarter and dry as the Sahara.
… more
… View more