Located in historic Findley Lake, NY, Alexander’s was founded in 2017 right on the water. With a combination of locals and people traveling on vacation, we’ve strived to feature high-quality food as well as local craft beer that live up to the views the lake provides. Whether your first trip or your 30th, we want Alexander’s to feel like home.
With our head chef having wheat allergies, we know how important it is to have options for those of you with similar allergies. We offer a gluten-free bun for all of our sandwiches, GF mac for our three Mac ‘n Cheese styles, GF stir fry sauce, and a cauliflower crust pizza.
Small town vibe, big town taste!
Based on 651 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
10417 Main St, Findley Lake, NY 14736
Phone: (716) 233-4000
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday |
11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: alexandersotl.com
Reviews
Ivy Velazquez
It was really nice and the place was beautiful. The only negative thing was that the food took an hour and 10 minutes to be served. There were only two other people so it seemed to be a bit long but the food was great and the desert was amazing. So just go and be prepared to wait for a while
… more
Andrew Eaglen
Stopped in and had the Mac and cheese (regular) and the pretzel appetizer.
… more
Michelle Shepler
Great lakeside restaurant. Food was delicious and the service was good. I had a salmon dinner with rice and the salmon was done perfectly. They take reservations and were able to accommodate our party of 10 the same day we called. Great water themed drinks too.
… more
Ashlyn Hazlett
Great place! The food was great, as well as the drinks! We got these fishbowl mixed drinks that were awesome. Would love to go there again if I visit the area
… more
Barry LaCastro
The BBQ Pulled Pork Mac n Cheese was Delicious!
… more
Donna Young
Great food. Great service. Great atmosphere. Molly, Mimi, Liz, Jade and Melissa are great. Everyone else are as well. Highly recommend!
… more
Laura Peters
Service was good as usual, sandwiches were also good. Sweet potato fries were burnt. I give this place a 1 due to the amount of flies we had to bat away while we were trying to eat a meal. Also, pricing has gotten a bit out of hand in a small town such as Findley Lake.
… more
Jake Jones
With a big group of 13 on a Saturday evening, we were able to get seated on the patio to relax and eat a great meal, overlooking the lake. Our server, Melissa, did an excellent job with us and the many kids we had in our party. Food was quick and delicious!!! I highly recommend this place!
… more
Carmela H
We drove 1 hour 20 minutes to check this place out and we were not disappointed! The pulled pork Mac n cheese alone was worth the drive! Pizza was really good something for everyone on the menu good portions, friendly staff, nice outdoor seating with a view of Findley Lake. We plan to revisit this restaurant in the future and try some of there other food.
… more
Mark/Maureen Makarowski
Fresh food, friendly service and fast delivery. Mimi took totally good care of us! Sat outside enjoying the cool breeze and view of the lake.
… more
… View more
