All Star Pizza – a local pizza restaurant serves Penfield and East Rochester NY. Voted as best pizza, sauce, and crust in Penfield our pizzeria has been committed to delicious food, quality ingredients, and convenient delivery. Select from our pizza menus and order online for delivery.
We offer Penfield’s best New York Style Pizza along with chicken wings, subs, salads.
Our full menu is available for delivery to your home or business 7 days a week. We also offer catering and can accommodate any size party from 10 people or more. Call us today and have an All Star dining experience!
Visit our website for more details.
Based on 222 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No takeout
Address:
1628 Penfield Rd, Rochester, NY 14625
Phone: (585) 385-2244
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: allstar-pizza.com
Reviews
Punky Starwood
This lil shop is awesome is small, but the staff is friendly. My pizza was awesome. I love white pizza and this one was amazing. I love that they add ricotta. Mouth watering and heavenly! I’ll be back for more 10/10
… more
Grace Lynch
This is a little hole-in-the-wall place for good NY style thin crust pizza. I went in for a slice – had a well-flavored vegetarian piece that was nicely done.
… more
Marc Hoffman
This pizza is fantastic. It’s just the right amount of thickness, great sauce and cheese, and proper toppings. I will definitely be getting it again!
… more
Jeremy Lloyd
First time trying a slice @ All Star Pizza and it was fantastic! You can tell that they use high quality ingredients across the board. The cheese was super good and all proportions were perfectly even. I will be back to try the wings and get a whole pizza and I can’t wait! Service was also excellent.
… more
Matt Johnson
Good pizza, decent prices. Price board was out of date, but that’s how you know its good pizza.
… more
Jake Mazza
Great place for a slice, good prices and the employees are friendly. The bad reviews are from people who don’t understand that NY pizza is a completely different style then the doughy garbage we get here in upstate NY.
… more
Laura Ribble
First time trying, and I think I’ve found my new favorite pizza place. So so good
… more
Nick
Always good food. Like most places hit some rough patches through the pandemic but bounced right back to their original excellent quality!
… more
Vector Delamorphis
PLEASE READ!!!! Ordered a delivery and they gave me wrong pizza, so I called and asked for my original one, and they got . So this what they brought me an hour later. Half cooked watery pizza just slopped together only little cheese. What kind of pizza shop is this
… more
James Mula
Great pizza. Our favorite in the area. Coming from Long Island this has been the best so far. Our driver tonight was awesome, super friendly. I hope he gets some kudos. I tried to call but it’s clearly busy because of Canal Days, but to my dude. You were awesome. Love this place.
… more
… View more
