Old-school standby for steak, seafood & Italian entrees, including pasta dishes, plus a full bar. Based on 160 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
218 E Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
Phone: (631) 226-9205
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
| Sunday | 2–8 PM |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Frank Lynch
This place is one of 2 places I have found on Long Island that makes Veal Marsala correctly. They start you off with a bowl of salad and different dressings. Then the bread… oh man. Hot and served with the salad. The staff made me feel like I was having dinner at a family members house. The atmosphere was quiet and seemed to have had my Playlist on shuffle. When you first walk in you walk directly into the bar. They bring you to the back to find 15 to 20 tables. The decor is nautical. Perfect place for a date night during the week. We ate like pigs and had a drink.
… more
Aimée Rubinowitz
Was very sad revisit to an old favorite after many years. Service was awful. Literally took pitcher from a server just to get water for table. Had to track down people to get drinks for table, which were terrible. My “2 lb” lobster rendered maybe 4 oz of meat! Fresh bread & garlic mozzarella bread fantastic, but don’t recommend this place anymore. They seemed overwhelmed during early 6-7 pm dinnertime.
… more
lambie48
I have lived two miles from Alletto’s for 48 years and never ate there. For our 51 anniversary I wanted lobster and they did not disappoint! Everything was perfectly cooked and delicious. It’s going to be a tradition now. Pics are before and after.
… more
Joe Caraccia
This place was picked by a friend who was in the mood for lobster. The service was very good however what was served left a little to be desired. My wife had the Filet Alletto which was bland and tasteless. I had the Brazilian lobster tails which for some unknown reason had a coating of breadcrumbs on them. There wasn’t much “atmosphere” however the wait staff were very nice. If you’re looking for good seafood, I wouldn’t recommend Alletto’s. The price was reasonable but you get what you pay for it. This was a “one and done” for my wife and I.
… more
Peter Castellano
Worst dining experience I have ever had. $468.00 down the drain, my fathers birthday ruined. Please avoid this restaurant. 3 full meals left on the table untouched, we are so disappointed. Avoid and go somewhere else and save your money.
… more
Marie Z
This is old school Italian at its finest! The round loaf of seeded Italian bread told me we were in for a good night! The clams oreganato were so tasty, and the muscles fra diavalo were huge and perfect red sauce for dipping all that great bread! The eggplant parm was perfectly done with a side of al dente spaghetti and the broiled scallops and baked potato were divine!
… more
Laura Cummings
Old style family restaurant where you can linger and linger whether you want to or not. So be prepared to sit back and chill. It’s like having dinner in a private house. 2lb broil Lobster special for $30 cash was cooked perfectly. The 4 shrimp were large and the 4 clams plump and juicy in the pasta dish with additional chopped clams in the sauce. Shrimp scampi tends towarda Oreganata more than scampi. You don’t come here to be wowed but you come here for good old no frills Italian based food.
… more
Mr Vlog
foods great the staff is very nice. Joe and Cathy are great people, and I’ve been going there for over 40 years never had a dirty glass before. I don’t know why people say that
… more
christopher burke
The food was perfect and made great by the chef tom but the rest of the service sucks The server was really rude and wanted me to get out of there
… more
Jennifer Sanchez
Ok so it’s not what I expected. The carpeting and decor are not to my taste. But I was pleasantly surprised by the seafood plate for two (there was alot in there). The food was ok some parts were a bit salty. The service was fine. Im giving it three stars because my daughters (who are both under 10 years) loved the seafood and the linguini. I guess it really depends on what your looking for… This reminded me of a diner not a restaurant.
… more
… View more