America’s Pie is So Much More Than Pizza!
The atmosphere in our restaurant is friendly, welcoming, bright, and clean. America’s Pie’s founder, Matt, takes pride in the quality, freshness, and tastiness of all his food. America’s Pie has lots of seating, Wifi, a very expansive menu and a variety of soft drinks.
We are located on East Gay Street in West Chester, PA, in the Cambridge Square Shopping Center, across from Rita’s Water Ice.
We deliver to West Chester, West Chester University, Exton, Westtown, PA, East Goshen, West Goshen, East Bradford, Green Hill, PA, Cheyney University, Oakbourne, Hershey Mill, PA.
Our dine-in customers come from as far as Paoli, Malvern. Berwyn, Downingtown, PA, Thorndale, and Marshallton, PA.
A pizza menu including a variety of options along with other American fare in a casual environment. Based on 332 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
323 E Gay St Suite B2A, West Chester, PA 19380
Phone: (484) 947-5115
Website:
Social Profile: 
![]()
Hours
| Saturday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brian Nowak
I have been a loyal customer of America’s Pie since they opened their doors in 2010, and I was thrilled to learn that they had reopened after their recent fire. My family and I decided to stop by for dinner, and we were not disappointed.
… more
Riley Patrone
Every time I go here things are delicious. Recently ordered “Vincent the conqueror” sandwich and it is unbelievable. I also got the Olivia salad and it was so good. They gave a huge thing of chicken in a separate box for the salad. Don’t overlook this place!
… more
Ricardo Ramos
Ordered the Satchmo sandwich. Supposed to have siracha on the fried shrimp and there might have a been a few drops. Quality control is out the window at this place anymore.
… more
Danielle Morris
Americas Pie catered my party and the food was amazing! Every single one of my guests raved about the food!! Would highly recommend them and I will definitely use them again!
… more
E Griste
From my initial phone call inquiring about their unique pickle hoagies through my pick-up, America’s Pie was professional, personable and kind. I will definitely be back to try their awesome looking to-go meals and menu options.
… more
M Clark
Every time we order from here we try something different because we know it’s going to be good. Everything is so carefully made, looks amazing when you receive it (even when it’s delivered) and tastes phenomenal. And they aren’t just pizza! I urge you to branch out and try the amazing sandwich combinations and wraps you will not be disappointed. Plus they cater , make bread pudding and debut phenomenal soups on the fly. The latest creation the Thai Curry Shrimp was outstanding. Definitely a place to keep on rotation!! Can’t wait to order again!
… more
Anthony Flynn
Never disappointed in the food, but the customer service lacks at times. They made a mistake and sent us home with half the wrong order, which happens I guess. But offer to make up for it. Instead got to sit around while they remade it, while the food at home got cold. No apology or compensation, just a… don’t worry the order is right now.
… more
Erin Dungee
Everything was edible in the sense that it wasn’t poison, but it was all flavorless. OK CBR pizza had no flavor of ranch or bacon or chicken (or onion we added) despite having the ingredients on the pie – everything was very dry (esp the chicken) and bland. Cheese steak egg rolls were soggy and undercooked – the egg roll wrapper was raw – and also desperate for flavor. The saving grace? Some onion rings that were soggy upon arrival (travel) but perfectly fine once air fried. This is what we get for a ordering a cheat meal, I guess!
… more
Jim “The Cheesesteak Guy” Pappas
America’s Pie, West Chester, PA, The Cheesesteak egg roll was pretty darn good. I went with The Dos Amigos and none of us were overly impressed with our sandwiches. Their name, America’s Pie, indicates pizza is their focus. What I like about pizza places is their toppings are usually very good and this was true here. I got the Philly special which came with a special hot sauce which I found very tasty. The peppers and onions on Dan’s sandwich look nice, big, good and fresh. Nice big menu. Don’t go hungry like we did it. We had to let three people go ahead of us because we were on big menu overload.
… more
Patrick Convery
World-class customer service. Great people who care about their community. Their everyday menu / service is second to none, but their catering is what separates them from the rest by miles.
… more
… View more
