Based on 227 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
1409 Lincolnway, Valparaiso, IN 46383
Phone: (219) 286-6293
Website: http://www.amicigrill.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jim Whitaker
Overall experience was amazing . The ambience of the location is nice and clean . The staff is super nice and friendly. The menu has great options with fair prices . Gyro fries are amazing the sauces they come with are great . Garlic knots are an A+ and fried provolone is tasty . Pizza has an amazing sauce but the crust will blow your mind! I love the crunch ! My new favorite pizza spot ! We will return !
… more
Gospelfunkadelic 7
I will drive from Hobart to here. I will also be telling everyone I know about this place.
… more
Paul Loslo
Had dinner tonight. Pizza was outstanding and service was excellent. Highly recommended!
… more
Kama Aquino
Wowww!
… more
Wanda Vawter
Great service. Food very good and prepared fresh. Four of us dined. Two ordered calzones…they were huge! One had meatball sub..beautifully prepared and very cheesy! Fries were the low point. They were so-so
… more
Alice Creed
Absolutely amazing service and food both times I’ve been there. The prices are on-par with the quality. The waitresses are as prompt as they can be for the little staff they have (so be NICE and patient please!). The marinara dipping sauce is house-made and probably the best you’ll get within 300 miles. I’ve tried their pizzas which are up to my [high] standards. The garlic knots, fries, and fried cheese are amazing starters (I prefer the garlic knots). I also got a calzone this time, which if you’re wondering, can feed a whole family of 10. It’s basically a large pizza crust stuffed with your choice of toppings, folded over and crimped, and baked.
… more
Carmen’s Critiques
Beautiful restaurant that is bigger than it looks! Something for everyone whether you are dining in or taking it to go! Their spaghetti was amazing! If you are there to watch a game, just know the TV programs kept buffering so this would be an ideal place for social interactions and a great date night location!
… more
Christine Gora
C lean, pretty spot across from the university. Meatball sandwich had good flavor, soft tasty bun.
… more
MUNNY MAIIA
Where do I begin. When I first discovered this place I was originally looking for BBQ. Then the website caught my eye. I knew the food was going to be good once I saw “Baked Feta”. Soon I realized the story behind the food when I seen tiramisu on the menu. Greek and Italian inspired. I ordered the gyro fries, and boy was it good. The meat was seared to perfection, the fries were homemade and fresh cut, the Greek dressing was the perfect zest added to the dish, feta tasted fresh, and the tzatziki sauce was the breath of fresh air to top it off. For desert the tiramisu hit the spot. I taste homemade and so good. Ever since my first trip I have been back almost every Saturday. Absolutely delicious dishes , big proportions, and great prices.
… more
Tina W
Yummy food and quick service!
… more
… View more