Casual strip-mall spot offering NYC-style pies, plus pasta, calzones & other familiar Italian eats. Based on 646 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
7177 Nolensville Rd Suite 6A, Nolensville, TN 37135
Phone: (615) 776-1800
Website: http://amicosnewyorkpizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Eduardo Diaz
Small, cozy little spot. Pretty active inside. Server was prompt and food was quick.
… more
Joe LaFerriere
Took a ride out to Nolensville to try Amico’s New York Pizza, it’s tucked in a plaza just North of the historic district. Jan met me at the door and got me seated, they were pretty busy with the Sunday lunch crowd. When she returned she brought a basket of what I will call their “heart attack rolls” (garlic bread) that soaks in their butter/olive oil “drizzle”. The bread is really good…crispy outside and light as air inside. I ordered a medium cheese pizza (14”) and it came out pretty quick. Would I consider this pizza “NY Style”? Absolutely! The crust is solid, crispy, and folds well without cracking. For me the mozzarella was a little chewy and I did add a splash of parmesan and a sprinkle of red pepper flakes for more flavor…but overall a solid pie. My server Jan was awesome…she took great care of me.
… more
Dyanne Branson
This restaurant is a must try!!! Service was wonderful and the food was delicious.
… more
Amy A
Great local pizza place. Prices are reasonable. Mozzarella cheese sticks were so tasty, along with great red marinara sauce. We also wanted some meatballs, ordered a few sides of them (3) per order. Meatballs had a great flavor to them- definitely recommend. If you’re wondering if they are any good at this restaurant, wonder no more….go ahead and order!!
… more
Jeremy Scott
Recommended by a local, we stopped by to eat in for lunch on a Sunday afternoon. It was quite busy, but we had prompt service and our food came quickly.
… more
fishinpeach
Pizza was really good, not the best, but good. We had a very nice waiter that never checked on us after the pizza was served. Looked like he was the only server on duty. Poor guy trying to keep up. The manager should have sent someone out to help him since there were TEN other employees just standing around in the kitchen. When we finally got our bill, there was a 3.5% “Convenience fee” added to our total. Convenient for who? We eat at a lot of restaurants and nobody else does this. If you’re going to charge a premium price, you have to deliver a premium experience. Amico’s, y’all can do better.
… more
Erik Harris
Being from New York myself, I had high expectations, and was mostly satisfied. The salad was great, the mozzarella wedges were on point, the pizza was great, and the wait staff excellent… so why only 4 stars??? The dough for the pizza and the complimentary garlic bread was on the sweet side, which is what knocked it down a little for my personal tastes (I would have given 4.5 stars if Google allowed half stars). I did enjoy everything, but really would have absolutely loved it more if the breads didn’t have that sweet undertone.
… more
Rob Foglia
The food here is always exceptional! My favorites are the Italian Stromboli, house special pizza, and the Italian sub. My wife loves the baked ziti. This is the best restaurant in Nolensville!
… more
Mandy Johnson
Last night, my partner and I continued our search for a replacement pizza spot close to home since our favorite place closed. Though this spot is not within walking distance like the last by any stretch, it’s closer than downtown Nashville! We agreed that we need to put them in regular rotation because they’re just so good.
… more
Randy Mitchell
Im married to a girl who was born and raised in Brooklyn with family in the Bronx and she has made me very picky about my pizza.
… more
… View more