Based on 14 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 5.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
221 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701
Phone: (917) 346-5122
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Diana Verity
NYC’s loss is Long Island’s gain! My husband and I were customers when Angelo’s was located in Little Italy and after all they went through when I saw Angelo’s was opening in Amityville I couldn’t wait to go! Once again Angelo’s was amazing!!! Tina (the owner) was as amazing as I remember her and made sure our dining experience was above anything we could image! We ordered the rice balls (not pictured) and it felt like home!!! The food was just as good if even better than the original, the service was fantastic, and the restaurant is beautiful! If you didn’t know the tiramisu is homemade now you know and you need to order it for dessert! We can’t wait to go back!
… more
Michael Correa
I have been going to Angelo’s in Little Italy since I am 10 years old, My Father was a 2x a week regular, Friday nights with his crew & Sundays with the Family. We lived out in Long Island but cruised in as if nothing because it was worth the trip. Now that Tina has brought Angelo’s to Amityville we are Blessed and whomever is reading this will be as well. My favorite is an appetizer that I first had at 10years old and never went there without ordering it, I have tried at many other restaurants and NONE have matched it, *Speidin Alla Romana* It’s Fresh mozzarella in a Caper anchovies sauce- Do not let anchovies throw you off as they are what give it the flavor that is needed, very little is used and they 100% disintegrate into pure goodness and you will never know they existed except for me saying so, Amityville made it just like they did in Little Italy which made me Very happy, to be honest it was 95% the same, all that was different was to much sauce & there was no capers in it. There should be just enough sauce that your upset you drenched your bread in the little that was left and want more. I hated leaving any of it to waste but there was to much, we had 3 orders and 1 of the orders had enough sauce for all 3.. Still was amazing, I will be back next week for more & the next etc etc. Thank you for coming to the Island, I will be bringing many Friends & Family to enjoy what I have for over 40 years.
… more
Frank Marcovecchio
Beautiful place with nice atmosphere. Our food was delicious and a nice wine selection as well.
… more
Stephen Ciccone
Some of the best Italian food on Long Island. Highly recommend
… more
Kerry Wilkie
What a welcomed addition to Amityville! Amazing service, incredible food and a hands on owner who is constantly making sure her restaurant guests all taken care of and feel at home. We had the mussels appetizer, with a broth worth dipping, the swordfish, which was huge and delicious as well as the orecchette with broccoli rabe and sausage. All surpassed out expectations. Plenty of staff, All attentive and sweet. Will definitely return! Welcome to the neighborhood ❤️
… more
Jacki Kronemberg
Beautiful place, Amazing food, amazing saff the service was great, had a great time there !!!!
… more
Tammi Wolfe
One of the best Italian meals I’ve had in quite some time! Everything from the atmosphere, to the menu layout, to the food and staff were top notch. We can’t wait to go back and try everything on the menu. Some menu highlights for us were the Spiedini di mozzarella, the Chicken Marsala (seriously one of the best versions I’ve ever had), Shrimp Fra Diavolo (sauce was perfection) & the Tiramisu (airy and delicious)! Very nice wine list as well. Can’t recommend Angelo’s enough…. Run don’t walk there!!
… more
Debra Brown
Absolutely wonderful. Staff were fantastic. A new favorite!
… more
Peter Herzog
Excellent meal – can’t wait to go back!!
… more
Patti Brown
Delicious dinner beautiful interior great service!
… more
… View more