Anley’s Restaurant (Formerly Pizza Plus) Menu – Old Lyme, CT

Type : Restaurant

Location : Old Lyme, CT

Based on 84 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price

Anley's Restaurant (Formerly Pizza Plus) 06371

Address:
284 Shore Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371

Phone: (860) 434-3282

Website:

Menu

Specialty Pizza
Mozzarella Pizza $8.95
Chicken Pizza $12.95
Appetizers
Garlic Bread $3.50
Garlic Bread With Cheese $5.50
Club Sandwiches
Ham Sandwich $12.25
BLT Sandwich $12.25
Pita Bread Sandwiches
Chicken Pita Sandwich $9.95
Tuna Pita Sandwich $9.95
Gyros
Lamb Gyro
Strips of lamb with onions, tomatoes & cucumber sauce with french fries.
$11.99
Chicken Gyro
Strips of chicken with onions, tomatoes & cucumber sauce with french fries.
$11.99

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Tiphany Brandi
Had a wonderful meal with the family and got a great deal. We had ordered a large pie with wings and a 2 liter of soda, all for under $30! The owner, Caitlin, is very attentive and kept checking in on us throughout our meal and ensured we had everything we needed. The menu has lots of options, so there is something for everyone. Overall, the service and the food were great! Everything came out in a timely manner and was hot and fresh. Will definitely be back!

… more

Olivia Pitney
I have a really big feeling they just cook up a frozen pizza and put it in a pizza box. Quality of the pizza is just gross. The wings are also like refried frozen wings. Yuck!! Definitely not going here again. I knew I shoulda just got teddys, just wanted to try something new 🙁

… more

Mary McAndrew
We ordered a large pizza and a calzone the other night for pick-up. Anley’s called us right back to let us know they were out of ricotta for the calzone, we said no problem, next time. But, much to our surprise and delight, when we went to pick up our pizza, they had our calzone, ricotta and all, ready for us. The above and beyond customer service was much appreciated! And the calzone was delicious – it topped my list of all time greats. Bravo!

… more

Jacqui G
Food was great !!! But service was what made it memorable they forgot to give us the calzone we ordered and we didn’t notice until we got home and they were nice enough to deliver it to us !! Nothing like amazing food and customer service!!!

… more

G A
I’ve had better pizza from digiorno. Anyone in these reviews who thinks the pizza here is good likely believes sound view is the best part of Old Lyme.

… more

Konstantinos Kourdis
Stopped in for a quick pick up. Pizza was awesome. Dough was fresh, toppings were prime quality, just the right amount of cheese. Much better than the other places I have eaten at around here.

… more

Lindsay E Mullen
Love the food, especially the gyros. The staff is wicked friendly and always treat me like I’m part of their family. Highly recommend their pizza .

… more

Mike Hungerford
Wings might possibly the best I’ve had around here. The pizza was great and staff is chill. Next time in old Lyme this place will be my go-to!!

… more

K
Service was great

… more

George Roderick
Very delicious food, highly recommend totally worth the drive. Will definitely be coming back again to eat again.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions