Based on 173 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
Address:
972 W Hwy 11E, New Market, TN 37820
Phone: (865) 262-9775
Website: https://www.anthonys.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Aubrie W
Had a less than pleasant run with their “customer service” after my order was made wrong. I’ll update my review again if they fix it.
… more
Arley Amundson
Dine in closes early when business is slow. The garden salad was fresh. The garlic bread knots were a little hard to chew. They don’t use olive oil. The pasta garlic and oil was very bland and pasta under cooked. Could not taste any garlic flavor. Basically pasta soaking in oil. But, the Lasagna was very good and nice and hot. Pleasant dining area and clean.
… more
Deana Musser
Last review was great but this was my pizza 2/19 last week we could t eat it
… more
Jonnie Witt
Well the food is delicious, I have to give them that, and it was clean, but we were the only ones in the place, no one else called to order, or came in to eat or pick up any food the whole time we were there. We would guess it is due to the poor attitude of the waitress that is working there. She said her parents own the place, so we can only assume that she works there out of obligation, as her personality of a toad definitely would not get her employment anywhere else. Sad, because the food is very good, but pleasant personable wait staff means alot when you are choosing to go eat at a restaurant, and this young lady was not even close. Maybe they should hire outside the family to represent their business! It is also very expensive for a little Mom & Pop local business.
… more
Dawn Breen
I ordered 3 of the 3 Topping $10 pizzas today and I must say they were some of the best pizzas I’ve had from there. The crust was just perfect! And the garlic knots were just as good as the 1st time!
… more
Jen V
The food is great here! Absolutely delicious! I would recommend signing up for their text messages because they will send you great deals. (They also deliver.) I’ve ordered the cheese, Hawaiian, a Meat Lover’s, and Philly Cheesesteak (not on the menu but they made one for us) pizzas. No complaints here!
… more
Alex “Raye” Hughes
I absolutely adore this place. The staff are very nice and the food is AMAZING! I usually order my subs, pasta, and pizza from here all the time. The building is always kept clean and almost feels like a second home when you sit down and eat. I walked in one day and I noticed that they had run out of a particular item that a person had ordered, well, they told him that they had ran out and offered him a substitute and a little something extra for the wait time. I don’t know about you, but that is friendly customer service if I have ever seen any. Cant wait to eat there this Friday, haha.
… more
robin pfeffer
We used to get takeout often but the quality at this location has dropped. While some of the prices are reasonable it became moot when week after week the pizza bottoms were burnt. We did talk to the owners and they did try and fix the problem. But the next order the same thing happened again. After several weeks we finally gave up and stopped getting them from this location. We were ordering twice a week. The Morristown restaurant is much better and we have never had a problem there. Sadly we can only get it about twice a month now because of distance.
… more
thomas rickert
Best take out pizza deals in Jefferson City TN. Just sign up for texts on their weekly deals . Very good pizza at a great price. The only disappointment is they always ask if I want to put a tip on my card if I’m picking up my own pizza why should I tip oh well small quirky thing. Pizza keeps me coming back.
… more
John Howerton
Pizza was great. Wish we had time to go back and try the deep dish. it looked good, and the lasagna. Very friendly waitress, always available and checked on us often. Good eats
… more
… View more