Casual mainstay with wood booths serving New York-style, brick-oven pies & familiar Italian dishes. Based on 865 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3385 S US Hwy 17 92 #165, Casselberry, FL 32707
Phone: (407) 767-5220
Website: http://www.papaanthonyspizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Maryann Manicone
Lauren was our waitress. Super friendly. The food is amazing! It is one of the best pizza parlors around wintersprings. The pizza sauce is tasty and just the right amount on the pizza. The crust is crisp as the oil drips down, and mozzarella drips from every bite. The calzone is very delicious. I love the ricotta creamy and perfect. Once you have this pizza it will be your favorite!
… more
jonsay241
First time coming here. Just for a to go order.
… more
Lindsey Banzhoff
Don’t go here! My friend and I went here for pizza and decided on the lunch special of 2 slices of cheese pizza with the side salad for $10.99. The waitress was asked if we could upgrade the pizza and was told we could and the upcharge would be “a dollar or two”. After waiting 27 minutes we got the bill for $35, the bulk of which was for the upgraded items. Using a new computer system which they were not familiar with, took another 20 minutes. Management was very rude and all but acknowledged it was our problem. The place was cluttered with boxes and God only knows what was laying around. Not only was it dirty, it smelled terrible, not like pizza.This place is in a strip mall where I work and I can assure you my experience will be shared with others. I will never go back. Save your money and go somewhere else
… more
allan pearl
Very good pizza. Typical , expected atmosphere. The girl behind the counter should pay a little more attention. Our pizza was done and sat on top of the oven for several minutes until the guy making the pizzas asked what we were waiting for and handed us our pizza
… more
justin Adams
I really can’t complain about the food here. With in a 20 mile radius this place is probably the best I’ve had. My advice to the Cashiers and waitresses though is try to smile more. None of you seem like you are thrilled to be there and that weighs on the customer. The one older woman waitress was complaining about the tip jar always being empty. You really can’t expect everyone who orders take out to tip. I don’t know why that’s a big surprise to some people.
… more
ronald miller
Of All the Anthony’s pizza places I’ve ate at, This one is Always my Favorite! Building is older, so not as updated… But design is More Traditional Italian pizza style than a lot of the newer ones that just look contemporary/industrial. Yes.. looks matters!!! 1/2 of the experience of dining out is the Atmosphere!! And This location Never fails to deliver one of the Best stromboli of Any I have had Anywhere else! Waitresses here are very friendly and punctual and pleasant! Great Restaurant!
… more
Clint Biggers
My wife and I have been coming to this establishment over the last 8 years every Tuesday night with a group of let’s say “jolly” friends. The food is always fabulous and the service is absolutely impeccable. Keep up the good work and we will see you on Tuesday night.
… more
Pam Alexander
First time in the place. I let the person know this at the counter. I order a pizza and ravioli to go and tell the girl I want a slice of pizza and a beer while I wait. I ask if I can go ahead and seat myself she proceeds to tell me no and I can not be seated with my order…. Mind you I tipped 20% at time of order. I sat for a few minutes in the waiting area with my beer and then Asked when I could get my slice of pizza (from a pizza that was already made sitting in the window) bc those were the only slices they had… I started looking around and there are hand written signs that say no seating for take out orders. So since again this is my first time in this establishment I ask if I need to have them take off my in house pizza and beer order with my take out order so I can be seated to eat… no but not one server checked on me or asked if I wanted another drink or glass of water! Horrible customer service!! Never ordering here again! Sad bc the pizza was actually Really good.
… more
Luz Ramos
Ordered Chicken Marsala. The chicken breast meat was thin, chewy, and it tasted like it was old pre made days ago, so spaghetti pasta was over cooked and bland.
… more
Shamir Carrillo
Whether I placed my order wrong over the phone or not I was a customer for over 10 years. I ordered a half pepperoni half hawaiian pizza with garlic knots. I arrive and the wonderful woman with her superb customer service said I ordered a full hawaiian pizza and she wouldn’t change it, take it or leave it. So you are willing to loose not just me as a customer but my whole family and friends in town which are going to add up once i post this on my social media. For a simple fix that what is your true cost of a large pizza maybe $10. You guys are sorry and don’t bother replying to this because this is a dead body under ground. Thanks for your 10 years of service but our ties are cut.
… more
… View more