Thin-crust pie specialist serving wings, pasta & calzones in a snug, basic locale with deck dining. Based on 789 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
650 Park Ave, Orange Park, FL 32073
Phone: (904) 269-1007
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
shannon birchell
The pizza is very good. Taste like authentic New York. Definitely visit this place. I knocked off a start because inside is dated.
… more
Mary E.
Stopped in today for dinner. WHY did they change the pizza dough! The previous one was PERFECT! Also, the owners need to invest money BACK into the restaurant to make it look cleaner and nicer! Definitely not the same pizza they used to sell.
… more
Christina Schmidt
Their bruschetta was the best- it is always good there.
… more
Rebecca Spenelli
Pizza was on point. Garlic knots were not very good in our opinion. Knocked off 1 star due to lack of info on hours. Hours posted said they were open until 9pm. We were from out of town wanting a sit down dinner with family. We arrived before 8pm. There were guests seated and eating in the dinning area be we were informed by staff they were no longer seating in the dinning area. We were there over an hour before the closing time per their posted hours, hours online, and hours on there menu. We then had to figure out drinks, plates, cups, siverware etc to take back to where we were staying. Had correct hours been posted we could have changed our dinning plans or been better prepared for takeout.
… more
Maivanan Maivanan
My visit to this restaurant left a positive impression on me. The generous portions, delicious sauce, cleanliness, and efficient food preparation all contributed to a satisfying dining experience. I would definitely consider returning in the future.
… more
Caroline Faust
Love Aaron’s, NY style pizza big foldable pieces! The lunch special is such a good deal, small side salad, 2 slices, and a drink for less than $10! Great small business in the Oramge Park area!
… more
John Johnaldson
Lovely small pizza place with excellent food, a cash payment discount, and always fantastic service.
… more
Joseph Sanford
The food here was very good, with a great combination of moisture and crispiness in the crust. The price is just a bit expensive for what you’re getting. Somehow my pizza, just enough for one person, was well over $13. Even with toppings that’s a pricey pizza. But very friendly workers, good food, and quick cooking!
… more
Sarah McIntyre
My friend my mom and I went here for lunch and it was good and everything but they got upset because they had to make me a new white pizza because I didn’t know it had tomatos on it and I can’t have tomatos and it was just a bad experience for me but they made me a new white pizza and it tasted great but the service we go was horrible the waitress was rude because I guess I asked them to remake the pizza and my soda I got tasted watered down but I didn’t want to say anything otherwise everything else was great but it felt like they treated us differently and I don’t appreciate it!
… more
Tracie Forster
I came to town on business. Wanted a good Italian dinner. Ordered the Baked Ziti, tasted freezer burnt. Cold in the middle. When I opened it, it looked like a cheese log. Bread was soggy. The only thing good about the whole meal was the salad. I would definitely not recommend this place. Lesson learned.
… more
… View more