Based on 137 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
210 Marble Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570
Phone: (914) 741-2828
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J McQ
Been getting takeout from here for years and it’s fantastic everytime. I always get the sausage and broccoli rabe pizza and it’s probably my favorite pizza I’ve ever had. The crust is amazing, the sausage is delicious and plentiful and I love the broccoli rabe, tender and big chunks of garlic. Both pictures are from my car because I usually eat half (or all) of the pizza before I leave the parking lot and then get a chicken parm wedge to take home to eat later.
… more
Anthony Martinez
My friends and I are from Long Island and we were in the area for a hike and we had no expectations coming here to eat. The hospitality was amazing, and the staff make you feel at home and are extremely friendly, the pizza is unreal— the dough is freshly made and light and airy. (Haven’t had anything like it before). The cannolis were probably one of the best I’ve had ever. The filling was light and fluffy, and the shell was soft and crunchy. This place is the real deal, and we will definitely be making another trip back here just for this! 🙂
… more
Michael S
This place absolutely sucks. The woman on the phone was obnoxiously rude when ordering. They pizza was cold. Then when I called to mention that they dismissed me as if I was being dramatic. Will never go here again. Go to sals across the street or Dino’s down the block both are way better.
… more
Daniela M
I love Pizza. I love New York pizza.. I LOVE THIS NEW YORK PIZZA. It’s amazing 🙂 go enjoy please and thanks. Highly recommend the Margherita and this one on the photo was their day special: sun dried tomatoes, pesto, basil. Incredible.
… more
Lily Winder
Happy to find a top notch pizza place in the area and after trying it for the first time, more than happy to drive 20 minutes to pick it up. The sausage and broccoli rabe is excellent.
… more
Claudio Woolley
The 1 word i can call this place..Jackpot!! I was looking for a place to take my son and since he is an avid pizza lover, and with the name of Arthur Ave, we had to try. It just so happens the owner, Brian Peroni, was born and raised in the Bronx! As soon as we walked in, we were greeted like family. Brian, Mario and Carmine have welcoming smiles and they all contribute in running the business. Since we were 4, he hurridly place 2 tables together so we can get comfortable. The pizzas come in personal sizes, good enough for 1 to 2 people. Brian prepared our pizzas, with skill and the oven he has bakes the pizzas in record time. The crust is crunchy and the pepperoni and cheese were generous. With his oven, the wait time can be 2 to 4 minutes. Very fast!!!
… more
Star Scheff
Was so excited to try this business, especially after reading the reviews. One question, who wrote them? Highly disappointed! My husband & I have been touring pizza places throughout the Hudson Valley. Originally from the Bronx, we have been seeking a BX rated pizza , with no success so far. First of all this place offers only one size….personal. In this case this was perhaps a plus. Bottom of pie was over charred. Either the char overpowered the flavor of the pie, or the pie had little flavor. Very thin crust, which was nice. However it wasn’t crispy. Actually had a sad cardboard texture. Barely any sauce, & scant cheese. I ordered mine with eggplant. One star for eggplant. Unfortunately only 3 small pieces of eggplant per slice. For what you get, it’s overpriced. I attempted to eat a 2nd slice, but my jaws were tired from chewing. And so the journey continues. Going to attempt pizzerias with lower ratings, maybe we’ll have better luck. Hey, it’s all about personal taste, or lack of taste for that matter.
… more
Cosmo Giannetti
Best pizza I’ve had in westchester by a long shot. A young man made me a pizza margherita and it must be up there as one of the absolute best pies I have ever had. You can really tell it was made with such love and care, and the service was great having them bring the pie straight to you in the apron… Reminded me of the good ol days, before the hipsters started taking over pleasantville trying to make everything instagram-chic. This is the real deal!!! Will be returning thank you so much.
… more
Alex Marburger
Very good pizza. Will definitely stop in again. Perfect for takeout. Also spotted Juniors cheesecake in the fridge for takeout!
… more
Paul Grundy
Very good Neapolitan style pizza the pizza is crispy Nicely charred and tasty. The Pizzaolo had thirty years of experience a master. The ingredients are the real Neapolitan deal and everything perfectly in balance. Arthur Ave a real Neapolitan in Westchester.
… more
… View more