Athena’s Menu – Cuyahoga Falls, OH

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Cuyahoga Falls, OH

Specialty pies, pasta dishes, gyros & hot wings are served at this longtime, casual outpost. Based on 273 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $

✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Athena's 44223

Address:
4037 State Rd, Cuyahoga Falls, OH 44223

Phone: (330) 929-2940

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 12–10 PM
Sunday 12–8 PM
Monday Closed
Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM

Menu

*NEW* Plant Based Menu
The Vegan Deluxe Pizza
Our red pizza sauce topped with Plant Based Italian Sausage Crumbles, Fresh Mushrooms, Green Peppers and Onions – then finished with Plant Based Vegan Cheese* from Miyoko’s Creamery. (*Vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen)		 $15.95
Vegan Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Vegan Buffalo Ranch sauce, plant based chicken tenders, Miyoko’s cashew based vegan mozzarella*. *Nut Allergen – cashew based.		 $15.95
Vegan Veggie Pizza
House made red sauce, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, banana peppers, black olives and tomatoes – topped with Miyoko’s vegan mozzarella*. *Nut allergen – cashew based		 $15.95
Vegan BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ sauce, Plant Based Chicken Tenders and Diced Onions. Topped with Miyoko’s Pizza Mozzarella AND Miyoko’s Smoked Mozzarella. Smoky, Sweet & Savory – IT’S SO GOOD! *Try it with Jalapenos if you like it spicy! Just put a note in the special instructions to add Jalapenos 🙂		 $15.95
10″ Small – Create Your Own Plant Based Pizza
Red Sauce. 6 Slices Choose your favorite toppings and your pizza will be finished with delicious plant based vegan cheese* from Miyoko’s Creamery. (*Vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen*)		 $10.95
12″ Large – Create Your Own Plant Based Pizza
Red Sauce. 8 Slices Choose your favorite toppings and your pizza will be finished with delicious plant based vegan cheese* from Miyoko’s Creamery. (*Vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen*)		 $14.25
16″ X Large – Create Your Own Plant Based Pizza
Red Sauce. 10 Slices Choose your favorite toppings and your pizza will be finished with delicious plant based vegan cheese* from Miyoko’s Creamery. (*Vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen*)		 $20.95
Family Size 1/2 Sheet – Create Your Own Plant Based Pizza
Red Sauce. Half Sheet – 16 square pieces Choose your favorite toppings and your pizza will be finished with delicious plant based vegan cheese* from Miyoko’s Creamery. (*Vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen*)		 $24.95
Plant Based 8″ Chicken Parm Sub
Crispy plant based Chicken Tenders on a garlic ‘buttered’ roll, topped with our house made red sauce, Miyoko’s mozzarella cheese and oven baked to perfection. Finished with vegan parmesan cheese. (**Miyoko’s vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen.)		 $9.95
Plant Based 8” Vegan Veggie Sub
Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Banana Peppers, Black Olives and Tomato, topped with Miyoko’s mozzarella – oven baked to perfection and finished with Italian dressing. (**Miyoko’s vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen.)		 $8.95
Plant Based 8” Buffalo Chicken Sub
Plant based chicken tenders, tossed in Buffalo sauce, topped with Miyoko’s cheese and oven baked to perfection. Dressed with vegan Ranch, lettuce & tomato. (**Miyoko’s vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen.)		 $9.95
Plant Based Fresh Garlic Cheesy Bread
Our fresh pizza dough, generously brushed with plant based garlic ‘butter’ and topped with delicious plant-based cheese** from Miyoko’s Creamery, cut into dippable pieces and served with a side of our tomato pizza sauce. (**Miyoko’s vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen.)		 $9.95
Vegan Belgian Chocolate “Cheesecake” By Eli’s Chicago Cheesecakes
From Eli’s: Certified Vegan, Plant-based, Cholesterol Free, Made With Tofu. Our Vegan, Dairy-Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake Cuties are made with semi-sweet Belgian chocolate and baked on a layer of old-fashioned cocoa cake, this rich chocolate cheesecake is finished with a dusting of imported cocoa. Using non-GMO tofu from Chicago’s Phoenix Bean makes this dessert cholesterol free!		 $3.95
Vegan Raspberry Lemon “Cheesecake” By Eli’s Chicago Cheesecakes
From Eli’s: Yes, it’s an oxymoron, but we’ve created a dessert so rich and creamy, we couldn’t resist calling it cheesecake! Made with organic GMO-free tofu from Chicago’s Phoenix Bean, this refreshing lemon “cheesecake” is baked on a layer of lemon cake, finished with housemade raspberry puree and a dusting of raspberry powder.		 $3.95
Pizza
Small 10″ – 6 Slices $8.95
Large 12″ – 8 Slices $11.25
X Large 16″ – 10 Slices $16.95
Family Size (Half Sheet – 16 Square Pieces)
Half sheet – square cut into 16 pieces.		 $19.95
Specialty Pizzas
Deluxe Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, and onions.		 $12.95
Greek Pizza
White garlic sauce, feta cheese, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, and Greek Kalamata olives.		 $12.95
The Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, pineapple, cheese, and bacon.		 $12.95
Hot & Spicy Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Generous chunks of chicken tenders, our special hot sauce, and cheese.		 $12.95
BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ sauce, Chicken Tenders, Diced Onions and Bacon. Smoky, Sweet & Savory – IT’S SO GOOD! *Try it with Jalapenos if you like it spicy! Just put a note in the special instructions to add Jalapenos 🙂		 $12.95
Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, green peppers, banana peppers, black olives, and cheese.		 $12.95
Pierogi Pizza
Creamy white sauce, grilled onions and green peppers, potato pierogies brushed with garlic butter, and topped with cheese.		 $12.95
Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
Sirloin Steak, onions, green peppers, cheese, and ranch sauce.		 $12.95
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, salami, and bacon.		 $12.95
The Bucket List Pizza
DOUBLE pepperoni, DOUBLE sausage, DOUBLE bacon.		 $14.95
Fried Chicken
4 Piece Dinner
The 4 Piece Dinner includes jojos, cole slaw and a roll.		 $11.95
8 Piece Chicken & Jojos
Chicken & Jojos		 $20.95
12 Piece Chicken & Jojos
Chicken & Jojos		 $26.95
16 Piece Chicken & Jojos
Chicken & Jojos		 $34.95
20 Piece Chicken & Jojos
Chicken & Jojos		 $42.95
Jumbo Wings
6 Wings $8.95
12 Wings $17.50
Oven Baked Subs
Italian Sub Half 8″
Ham, salami, pepperoni, banana peppers, onions, cheese, tomato, and lettuce – dressed with mayo and Italian dressing.		 $8.95
Italian Sub Whole 16″
Ham, salami, pepperoni, banana peppers, onions, cheese, tomato, and lettuce – dressed with mayo and Italian dressing.		 $15.95
Philly Steak Sub Half 8″
Sirloin Steak, Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and cheese – dressed with mayo.		 $9.95
Philly Steak Sub Whole 16″
Sirloin Steak, Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and cheese – dressed with mayo.		 $17.95
Nashville Hot Chicken Sub Half 8”
Tenders tossed in Nashville Hot sauce, topped with cheese, dressed with pickles and coleslaw.		 $9.95
Nashville Hot Chicken Sub Whole 16”
Tenders tossed in Nashville Hot sauce, topped with pickles and coleslaw.		 $17.95
Buffalo Chicken Sub Half 8″
Crispy fried chicken tenders, tossed in buffalo sauce, topped with cheese – dressed with lettuce, tomato and ranch.		 $9.95
Buffalo Chicken Sub Whole 16″
Crispy fried chicken tenders, tossed in buffalo sauce, topped with cheese – dressed with lettuce, tomato and ranch.		 $17.95
Chicken Parm Sub Half 8″
Crispy fried chicken tenders on a buttery garlic roll, topped with our pizza sauce and cheese.		 $9.95
Chicken Parm Sub Whole 16″
Crispy fried chicken tenders on a buttery garlic roll, topped with our pizza sauce and cheese.		 $17.95
Chicken Tender Sub Half 8″
Crispy fried chicken tenders and cheese, dressed with lettuce, tomato and mayo.		 $9.95
Chicken Tender Sub Whole 16″
Crispy fried chicken tenders and cheese, dressed with lettuce, tomato and mayo.		 $17.95
Veggie Sub Half 8″
Green peppers, banana peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, tomato, cheese – dressed with Italian dressing.		 $7.95
Veggie Sub Whole 16″
Green peppers, banana peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, tomato, cheese – dressed with Italian dressing.		 $14.95
Gyros
Regular Gyro
Seasoned Gyro Meat, House Made Tzatziki Sauce, Tomato & Onion on a soft pita.		 $7.50
Jumbo Gyro
A full half pound Gyro! Seasoned Gyro meat, House Made Tzatziki Sauce, Tomato & Onion on a Soft Pita.		 $8.95
Salads
Garden Salad
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, onions, cheese.		 $8.95
Antipasta Salad
Lettuce, pepperoni, salami, ham, black olives, tomato, and cheese.		 $10.95
Greek Salad
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, Greek Kalamata olives, green peppers, onions, and feta cheese. Try it with our house made Greek dressing.		 $10.95
Gyro Salad
Lettuce, gyro meat, tomato, onion, cucumber, feta cheese. Try it with our house made tzatziki dressing.		 $10.95
Side Salad
Side salad with lettuce, cucumber and tomato.		 $4.95
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Tender Dinner
Five tenders, fries, cole slaw and roll – served with one side of your choice of sauce.		 $13.95
Chicken Tenders
5 Tenders only. No sides. Served with your choice of sauce.		 $10.95
Sides
New* Sauerkaut Balls
An Akron tradition! One dozen , served with a side of honey mustard dipping sauce.		 $5.75
Onion Rings $6.95
Mozzarella Sticks (5) $6.25
Breaded Mushrooms $6.25
Jalapeño Poppers (6)
Cheddar or cream cheese.		 $6.25
Fresh Cut French Fries $4.25
Box Of Fries $10.95
Jo Jo’s (6) $4.25
Box Of Jo Jo’s (30) $12.95
Fresh Garlic Cheesy Bread
Our fresh pizza dough, topped with garlic butter and mozzarella, provolone and parmesan cheese, cut into dippable pieces and served with a side of pizza sauce.		 $8.50
Plant Based Fresh Garlic Cheesy Bread
Our fresh pizza dough, generously brushed with plant based garlic ‘butter’ and topped with delicious plant-based cheese** from Miyoko’s Creamery, cut into dippable pieces and served with a side of our tomato pizza sauce. (**Miyoko’s vegan cheese is cashew based – nut allergen.)		 $9.95
Garlic Roll
Hoagie Roll, garlic buttered and oven toasted to perfection		 $3.95
Garlic Roll With Cheese
Hoagie Bun, garlic buttered and topped with cheese, oven baked to perfection.		 $4.95
Side Salad
Side salad with lettuce, cucumber and tomato.		 $4.95
Cole Slaw $1.95
Additional Dressing $1.00
Additional Sauce $1.00
Dessert
Chocolate Chip Brownie $3.95
New York Style Cheesecake $3.25
Toffee Crunch Cheesecake
NY Style Cheesecake, Drizzled with Caramel Sauce and Topped With Heath Candy Bar Crumbles.		 $4.25
Chocolate Cookie Cheesecake
NY Style Cheesecake, Drizzled with Chocolate Sauce and Topped with Oreo Cookie Crumbles.		 $4.25
Baklava
Delicious Authentic Baklava- layers of flaky phyllo pastry filled with sweet honeyed walnuts.		 $4.25
Vegan Belgian Chocolate “Cheesecake” By Eli’s Chicago Cheesecakes
From Eli’s: Certified Vegan, Plant-based, Cholesterol Free, Made With Tofu Our Vegan, Dairy-Free Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake Cuties are made with semi-sweet Belgian chocolate and baked on a layer of old-fashioned cocoa cake, this rich chocolate cheesecake is finished with a dusting of imported cocoa. Using non-GMO tofu from Chicago’s Phoenix Bean makes this dessert cholesterol free!		 $3.95
Vegan Raspberry Lemon “Cheesecake” By Eli’s Chicago Cheesecakes
From Eli’s: Yes, it’s an oxymoron, but we’ve created a dessert so rich and creamy, we couldn’t resist calling it cheesecake! Made with organic GMO-free tofu from Chicago’s Phoenix Bean, this refreshing lemon “cheesecake” is baked on a layer of lemon cake, finished with housemade raspberry puree and a dusting of raspberry powder.		 $3.95
Drinks
Coke – 20 Ounce Bottle $2.50
Diet Coke – 20 Ounce Bottle $2.50
Coke Zero – 20 Ounce Bottle $2.50
Sprite – 20 Ounce Bottle $2.50
Bottled Water – 20 Ounce Bottle $2.25
Fanta Pineapple – 20 Ounce Bottle $2.50
Gold Peak Tea – Sweet Tea $2.50
Gold Peak Tea – Unsweetened $2.50
Powerade – Mountain Berry Blast – 20 Oz Bottle $2.50
MONSTER ENERGY $3.75
MONSTER ENERGY – ZERO SUGAR $3.75
Vitamin Water – Power C Dragonfruit – 20 Oz Bottle $2.50
Vitamin Water – Zero Sugar XXX – 20 Oz Bottle $2.50
Vitamin Water – XXX – 20 Oz Bottle $2.50
Vitamin Water Energy Tropical Citrus – 20 Oz Bottle $2.50
Vitamin Water – Squeezed (Zero Sugar) – 20 Oz Bottle $2.50
Body Armor -Blackout Berry $3.00
Body Armor – Fruit Punch $3.00
Body Armor – Strawberry Banana $3.00
Body Armor – Orange Mango $3.00
Body Armor Lyte – Peach Mango $3.00
Body Armor Lyte – Blueberry Pomegranate $3.00
2 LITER – COKE $3.50
2 LITER – SPRITE $3.50
2 LITER – DIET COKE $3.50
2 LITER – CHERRY COKE $3.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

rebelVegans
Phenomenal Vegan pizza. And gluten-free option available. 10/10 taste, toppings, dough. Will come back when we are around. Thanks so much for being progressive, and offering Vegan and Gluten-free options. Loved the cake too.

… more

Eric Jordan
Athena’s is our new go-to pizza place. They have the best crust! Yummy toppings and super friendly service.

… more

Crystal Shirey
Hot, delicious food! First time ordering we got fried chicken which is on par with the best Italian chicken I’ve had. Pizza was good, jojos amazing, fresh cut fries are my favorite. And my boys loved the Nashville hot sub. 5 out of 5 highly recommended!!

… more

Cat Tolbert
First time trying! Got the dinner deal- Large one topping pizza, 8 piece chicken and jojos for only around $26. What a steal! It was also delicious and made for great leftovers. We will be back to try more from the menu. Chris the manager is awesome too and this will be a staple now.

… more

Liz Wilkinson
Athena’s Pizza is under new ownership over the past year or so and the owners, Jason and Allie take great pride in the food they send out! The restaurant is meticulously clean and the workers also seem to take great pride in sending out great food to their customers. The chicken is so fresh and delicious and cooked to perfection when we get it. They have so many vegetarian/vegan entrees that are new to their menu and are excellent! Our daughter loves the vegan barbecue chicken pizza. And the rest of the family enjoys the pierogy pizza and even just plain cheese pizza is amazing Check out this local pizza shop. You certainly won’t leave hungry or disappointed.

… more

Amy Simpson
Fresh food and high quality ingredients!! Athena’s is the best locally owned pizza shop. Juicy fried chicken, crispy and well baked pizzas. Wait till you try the salads! The homemade greek dressing is better than any you’ve tried before. Get a little bit of everything, you will not be disappointed! The new owner really has turned the place around. This place is right on the way to Blossom, so stop in and grab a some grub before the show.

… more

Nate Sikora
Just moved to the area less than a year ago, and was looking for a good pizza place. My coworkers highly discouraged me from ordering pizza from Athena’s, but I wanted to give it a try and I am really glad I did. Little did they know Athena’s had changed ownership. Workers were friendly, pizza shop was clean and the food was hot and delicious!

… more

Leroy Hucks
My Out of Town “Sault St-Marie” Family came in for a Weekend Visit, and Ordered here. There was one “Special Menu Item” that was requested. And Allie (hopefully spelled correctly), obliged❗️ So Much Love & Hospitality! So Much Appreciation Felt, & Given! Thank You for showing Grace & Willingness, Allie. . ‼️EVERYTHING WAS DELICIOUS‼️

… more

Rick Fournier
Their pizza is simply the best in NE Ohio, that’s after a lot of searching. I then worked through the rest of their menu and everything is top shelf. Tastes like homemade, if you were living with a top chef. Great food, price point and service.

… more

Craig Kerensky
First time here. Delicious. Even the gluten free pizza and vegan cheese was great, which is not easy. Pizzas are a little undersized so order extra but that’s a very minor complaint. Probably the best pizza in town.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch