Spiffy indoor-outdoor venue for steak & seafood boasts a yacht-club vibe with Nantucket Sound views. Based on 534 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2 Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: (508) 627-7001
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12 PM–12 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Friday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 12 PM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Samantha Knight
A great spot! We came for a snack between lunch and dinner. The drinks were AMAZING especially La Rose De Paris – absolutely the best cocktail I’ve ever had. The oysters were so good we got two orders! The octopus was great as well. Our waiters recommendations for appetizers and were great. He knew what he was talking about. We sat outside right on the dock. I would highly recommend!
… more
Joseph Adelantar
Perfect lunch spot for the whole family! This was our first time in Martha’s Vineyard and The Atlantic Restaurant was a great star. We sat outside with the tables and stools. The freshness of the dishes especially the lobster, crab cake, and fish was wonderful. The grilled octopus was prepared with attention to flavors. The fries was a hit with daughter. And you have to end it with desserts, the Atlantic cookies and milk shake is a must. We liked it so much we came here twice! Friendly staff too’
… more
Anwaar Masoud
My husband and I used to love this place. We’ve been here several times and even brought family and friends to dine. We’ve been wanting to come back so we decided to eat here today. Let me just say – the food and the service were awful.
… more
Slava B
Amazing! Great food and service! Delicious!!! I had lamb shawarma which was perfect! We also ordered large $200 appetizer set (get it! Worth every penny) party of 7 we had half the menu and everything was great!! Definition recommend this place!!
… more
Jeff Fairbairn
My wife and I had a very nice dinner here, with a partial view of the marina. Don’t worry if you see a long line outside, because what appears to be a modestly sized restaurant from the street is in fact a ~200-seat colossus. Service was attentive, drinks were good, food was good (though it came out suspiciously quickly) and the portion sizes were generous (most people won’t want starters or sides if they are ordering a main). The bill was higher than I would expect to pay for something similar in Boston, but we are on an island and the view from our table was worth the price. 3.5 stars.
… more
LaNail Plummer
On July 3rd around 7/7:30pm, a group (5) of friends and I (all Black people and professionals) went to the Atlantic restaurant in Edgerstown, MA.
… more
Sergio Esteireiro
Overpriced for the quality of service and food was way below standards… NO CHEF should had allowed a plate get to the customer this way… at least a real chef wouldn’t.
… more
John Lake
We had a party of 10 including an 18 month old. They accommodated us no problem. The server recommended several dishes so we ordered a few and our server carved it French style at the table side. He made us a surf and turf with bone in rib eye and king crab. It was spectacular. Great edgartown experience.
… more
Kerry
The fried artichokes were INCREDIBLE. The salmon was perfectly cooked and the accompanying raviolo was delightful.
… more
Richard Levins
A tale of two experiences. First, the good: the food. The chef is absolutely not afraid of flavor, and I found myself being taken on an absolute TRIP to flavor town. The food here, aside from the portions being comically large, is outstanding, flavorful, and fresh.
… more
… View more