B.J. Wentker’s, in Burlington, WI, is the premier restaurant serving Lake Geneva, Powers Lake, Waterford, Elkhorn, Slades Corners and surrounding areas since 1908. We specialize in fine dining and private parties. For your next meal, visit B.J. Wentker’s in Burlington.
Old-timey American standby with a warm ambiance serving steak & seafood dishes & specialty martinis. Based on 218 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
230 Milwaukee Ave, Burlington, WI 53105
Phone: (262) 758-6112
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Erin Murdock
Just stopped in for cocktails in the afternoon. Amazing wood work all over the restaurant. Shannon was a pleasure to speak with, her service was top notch. We look forward to making reservations and coming back with friends for dinner one evening. They also have a wine club which I think my mom will absolutely enjoy! Highly suggest you stop in and check it out yourself. Drinks are cold, cant wait to come back and try the food!
… more
Chris Bowen
A group of 9 of us had reservations at 5:30pm on a recent Friday evening. What happened next was beyond belief. The short version is they were out of ginger ale, vegetables, mussels, a wine list, and a few other things I can’t remember. Despite there being only one or two other people in the place, 6 of us didn’t get out food for 2.5 hours. The other 3, who ordered perch, didn’t get their food for another 30 minutes later. And they got walleye, which they tried to tell us was perch. Even harder to comprehend than the 3 hour wait for food was the fact that 8 or 9 of us didn’t receive what we ordered- mashed instead of baked potato, mashed potato instead of wild rice, walleye instead of perch, scallops on pasta instead of rice, butter instead of cheese dipping sauce for a pretzel (which arrived burned black), a steak well done instead of medium, and on and on. Perhaps some of this could have been explained had they been extremely busy but there were only a few people in the place the entire time!
… more
Diana Anderson
Shannon the bartender was entertaining and very hospitable. She makes a great old fashion and smokes them too!! Our dinner was delicious. The menu has lots of gluten free options and they are willing to substitute food to make everything gluten free.
… more
Verdi selita
This neat and cozy place make you feel at home! We had a great dinner , the burger and the fried cod were delicious, but the dessert makes it a nice final dinner touch! Plus the manager and their waitress are nice! Nice drinks as well! Also, we saw this beautiful piano and we were told that on Saturday or some Fridays there may be a live pianist! Come and don’t miss this neat place! P.S .now they will be open for lunch!
… more
Grace Lemieux
I have mix feeling about this restaurant. The building has a nice history but it seems like the current owner is struggling to maintaining it. We also learned that the current staff has been on strike. Therefore, the reserve and part time staff were helping out. The chef and owner were in the kitchen. We stayed and had dinner The fried perch was good but we suspect they weren’t lake perch based on their large sizes. They could have been walleye fish. The scallops were cooked perfectly but they didn’t have any taste. The cream sauce on top was cold. Given the circumstances, we came to this restaurant when they are having a bad day?
… more
Jayme Zidar
Been here recently a couple of times. Everything is very good. Great wine and drink selections. Gluten-free options are available.
… more
Timothy Reed
Shannon, the manager/bartender was so nice. We had some cheese curds and bacon wrapped water chestnuts, a couple of drinks. Enjoyed the decor. Old bar metal ceiling and unique barstools. We are going back for prime rib today.
… more
Jeff Ostovich
Had 2 large perch that was excellent along with a bake potato ,colesaw and a piece of bread. Started off with soup.
… more
Chad Heiligenthal
Exceptional food! And very friendly hardworking staff! I can’t say enough about the fish fry, the homemade potato pancakes are AMAZING! Don’t wait to long to try it!
… more
Dawn Klodd
Waited a bit for a table (only 3 other tables of 2 we’re occupied), orders drinks, no Coors light and the tap beer they suggested was out. 3 of maybe 8 appetizers were not available, and they were out of potato pancakes. Baked cod was over cooked and over peppered! Baked potato’s were undercooked.
… more
… View more