Based on 470 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
69 Brookside Ave, Chester, NY 10918
Phone: (845) 469-8505
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 5 AM–3 PM |
| Wednesday | 5 AM–3 PM |
| Thursday | 5 AM–3 PM |
| Friday | 5 AM–3 PM |
| Saturday | 5 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | 6 AM–2 PM |
| Monday | 5 AM–3 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rose Ann Rosenfeld
What happened to you Bagel Girls, Today I was craving a pastrami on rye. I always got it from Bagel Girls because they are the best. Until today. First of all I called to order for pick up and they answer the phone with just hello. Then I was informed that they do not take phone in orders. I went to the store, and ordered a pastrami sandwich on rye and was amazed that it cost $20. With a soda. When I got home to eat, pastrami looked dry and I was disappointed. I expected the usual juicy delicious fatty pastrami usually hot. This pastrami tasted like processed meat. I am very disappointed and I hope you guys get your act together soon. Bring back the old Bagel Girls.
… more
Caroline
Don’t go to a chain when this is nearby, this place is so good, quality ingredients at a good price. It’s like a little local market deli and more—cozy seating and THE BAGELS are huge and fresh. Toni is a rockstar and helped me put together a really fast catering meal that made my crew so happy!
… more
Nicholas Levin
Food is awesome and the staff is excellent. Actually trying to order food to go is a little tough since there isn’t a lot of space to stand. It’s always busy when I come, so people are always standing on top of each other waiting for their food. Not really the fault of the owners though- the store is only so big.
… more
Concerned Citizen
You can’t place orders over the phone. Why do they even answer the phone? The guy at the front is rude. The bagels are not good Anyway. Go to c n d’s in warwick If you want a real bagel. almost forgot to mention, If you want a breakfast sandwich it’s eight dollars. The prices don’t match the quality here. honestly without the guy at the front, The food might taste better. Because he leaves you Disgusted.
… more
Peter Olsen
OMG! Completely rude and disrespectful! Especially the guy at the counter! Prices are doubled the cost than what you would pay elsewhere! Corn beef Ruben sandwich $20 plus change! Bagel Boys sells it $10 plus change! Like what the heck! I settled for a $6:00 sad bacon egg and cheese sandwich. Wanted I drink with it and a Monster Mean Bean coffee drink was $6.00 they go for almost half that price everywhere else. I voice my opinion and very politely said that’s expensive that’s more than double the cost and he ranted in rage at me, laughing at me with someone else and telling me than don’t come in here to buy it how do you like that! Completely rude, he’s a jerk!
… more
Katie Gerlach
Great bagel spot! Very popular so it’s busy inside, but they’re quick and friendly. So many good options for breakfast and lunch. Plus snacks and candy. My everything bagel was soft and crunchy, so good!
… more
Katie Gerlach
Great bagel spot with so many options! The service was fast and friendly even during peak business hours and I loved seeing a rude customer being delt with swiftly. I can’t wait to try some of their pastries specialty candy
… more
ethan Mayers
Solid bagels. They have the usual assortment from rainbow to flagels, cream cheese and egg sandwiches. We also got rainbow cookies (so so good). Super easy access off the highway (this was about halfway between long Island and the Poconos so it makes for a convenient food stop).
… more
Victor Robinson
Not the worst but my order was forgotten and i waited a long time. No dairy free cream cheese. No hummus. They used dirty hands to make my peanut butter bagel and got cream cheese all over it. Not great.
… more
Tom Serra
A literal rip-off, check the prices and receipts because the guy at the register is changing the prices as he rings you up. When I said something he threw out the receipt and printed me a credit card slip that was even higher.
… more
… View more