Based on 382 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
240 S Bear Lake Blvd, Garden City, UT 84028
Phone: (435) 946-3600
Website: https://www.beartrapperrestaurant.com/pizza-co/
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Megan Jones
Unique little place with a gift shop and a pizzeria. Cute outdoor seating.
… more
Ryan Johnson
We wanted to try the “famous” bear lake pizza. It was really good. We did half supreme and half meat lovers. We had 6 adult men and it fed all of us. Would recommend at least once.
… more
Makaria Elixabete
Rude personnel. Dismissive and not customer service oriented. Having a captured audience and being annoyed at people during a certain busy season doesn’t mean you can be dismissive and lame in terms of friendliness with customer service.
… more
Rachelle Mann
Call ahead of time to order, this delicious pizza is in high demand. The crust was like a buttery bread stick. Each pizza flavor was on point. We got pepperoni, cheese, BBQ chicken, chicken bacon ranch pizzas.
… more
Jake Smithson
Biggest pizza I’ve ever ordered. The old ephram was great. Will go again
… more
Jill Lalliss
We love our annual trip to Bear Lake! We always visit Bear Lake Pizza Co. and this trip was one of our best!
… more
Evan Meidell
I need to give credit when credit is due! I placed a call ahead order earlier in the day and didn’t think much about it until time to pick up. As I arrived the windows were dark and the open sign was off and I thought I doomed my family to no dinner. Well, turns out the power was out and they were ‘open’. I went in to see the state of the place and found my order was the last order to make it through the oven before the outage and they made sure it stayed hot for me! The team was awesome in making sure we had everything we needed! We had to conduct a non-traditional payment because of no power but Venmo saved the day! I was able to pay the manager and she confirmed it was squared away! Amazing staff and amazing food! You did great guys and delivered the great pizza I promised the family!
… more
Heather Steck
We were so excited to try out this pizza place! We got there and ordered. We have 2 people in our party with food allergies so we ordered 3 different pizzas to accommodate. They have a gluten free pizza crust option which is nice. After waiting for over an hour for our food and watching 3 other parties who arrived after us get their food first (including a massive party of around 15 people) and then finish we finally got our order. But it was missing an entire pizza and one of the two pizzas that we DID get was missing cheese. It costed us nearly $50 for this. They ended up taking that pizza back into the kitchen and putting cheese on top and melting it but by the time we finally got our order patched together to an acceptable place my kids and I were beyond hangry and we were just done. We were very disappointed in the service we received and probably will take our business elsewhere next time.
… more
Karen Taylor
We love Bear Lake Pizza! Each pizza is made to order. We are thrilled that they also offer a gluten free pizza! The Old Ephraim is huge. Our family of 7 had enough left over for another meal. We have found that on busy summer weekends, it is best to call our order in and it is ready when we arrive. This family owned pizza place is our favorite!
… more
Stephen Gale
We ordered The Old Ephraim, a 38″ pizza. For the size of the pie, it was delivered to the table very quickly. The outdoor seating was perfect for the time off year and for the size of our group. The crust was soft and cooked evenly throughout. Servers were friendly, but scarce for the outdoor area.
… more
… View more