Based on 36 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
230 US-209, Port Jervis, NY 12771
Phone: (845) 672-0808
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Shannon DiBernard
I’ve had such a hard time around here finding a pizzeria that makes a good thin crust. Everywhere else around here makes very thick, doughy crust. This place though? PERFECT THIN CRUST! Exactly what I love and think makes a great pizza! It was also really tasty but the white pizza could definitely use more garlic! Otherwise fantastic and definitely my new pizza place.
… more
Shaun Good
Ordered wraps for lunch. They were very good. The French fries were crispy obviously fried in fresh oil. The food was done in exactly the amount of time I was told. Definitely will be returning soon.
… more
Scotty
Well the food started off on a good note, however the quality has fallen slightly. Perhaps if the owner/management would put some outside lights on, passer byes would not wonder if Bella Notte is open or closed. Very dark exterior sends a bad message ?
… more
dizzydaw
Dunno what happened, they were the best pizza I’ve had in Orange County when they opened and I ordered weekly. Once they changed owners or management whatever they did messed it up. Staff was always so nice and welcoming then after the change there was a woman behind counter that was so rude when I was always polite, I got pizzas that weren’t even cut and the taste was wayyy off. Unfortunately they lost their touch and that rudeness was the final straw for me, I refuse to go back. They were a game changer it sucks they changed.
… more
James Falce
Very good pizza. We order from here about once every week. Moved up here from Brooklyn. Happy to have good pizza close to our new home.
… more
Delwin Reyes
Food did not have any flavor had to sprinkle some love on it at home in order to eat it. You can tell the fried chicken tenders and shrimp was from the freezer, meat was slightly gooey . They have items on the menu that they did not make any more. They forgot an order of fries . The cashier/ waitress was sitting on the lap of her boy friend when I walked in. Boy friend had to look in my car to confirm that I was indeed missing an order of fries had to pull out the menu to show them how certain meals comes with fries or veggies. I was over charged. Also the owner never even greeted me he just kept staring at me . You would think sharing my story how I just moved up this way and was looking for a good pizzeria and spent $80 that he would at least greet me .1st and last time I will be getting from this place . To top it all off I woke up to my wife at midnight throwing up and having to use the bathroom at the same time food poisoned her. This is no exaggeration all of this is true . Hopefully they do better.
… more
Sarah Calabrese
I have no idea how this place went so down hill. They used to be the best pizza place in the area, now they take an hour and half to deliver not even five minutes away, but they hang up on you when you call to find your food, then charge you for a veal parmigiana dinner, which is what was ordered, and give you the sub. Then tell you they’ll call you back when they have time. Will never be eating here ever again.
… more
Kelly Gannuscio
My husband and I stopped there a few weeks ago for a slice. We both enjoyed it. We used them again for a family gathering. Put in a very large order in the morning for afternoon delivery. They were there on time and the food was hot and delicious. I would recommend them to everyone.
… more
Scott
The food use to be good and delicious however the present chef doesn’t know how to cook Fra Diablo. The pasta was tasteless and the seafood was sparse. Very disappointing. Please bring the old chef back and give him a raise
… more
John Spagnolo
I got a meatball Parm hero. It was good. Loads of cheese. Ordered from here a few weeks ago too and the pizza was very good. The wings as well.
… more
… View more