Benchwarmer’s Tavern and Grill Menu – Mt Sinai, NY

Type : Bar & grill

Location : Mt Sinai, NY

Comfy sports-centric spot with homestyle seafood & steak dishes, plus drink specials & shuffleboard. Based on 260 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Benchwarmer's Tavern and Grill 11766

Address:
23 NY-25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766

Phone: (631) 509-4077

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 12–11 PM
Wednesday 12–11 PM
Thursday 12–11 PM
Friday 12 PM–12 AM
Saturday 12 PM–1 AM
Sunday 12–11 PM
Monday 12–11 PM

Menu

Panini’s
Grilled Chicken Panini
Grilled chicken marinated in our house marinade topped with melted mozzarella, spinach and red roasted peppers.		 $17.50
Grilled Vegetables Panini
Grilled mushrooms, sauteed onions, spinach, and tomatoes topped with mozzarella cheese and topped and balsamic vinaigrette dressing.		 $15.50
Appetizers
Mini Tacos
Crunchy hard shell tacos served with salsa, sour cream, and cheddar cheese dipping sauce		 $13.50
Shrimp Cocktail
Served chilled with a side of cocktail sauce and a lemon		 $16.50
Maryland Jumbo Lump Crabcakes
Served with roasted pepper aioli sauce		 $15.50
Chicken Fingers
Fried chicken tenders served with a side of honey mustard		 $14.50
Potato Skins
Potato skins stuffed with melted cheeses and bacon served with a side of sour cream		 $12.50
Wings
Jumbo or Boneless. Your choice of mild, medium, hot, teriyaki, or garlic parmesan, BBQ, or honey BBQ.		 $15.50
Quesadilla
A melted cheddar cheese blend in a flour tortilla and served with salsa and sour cream. Add chicken or steak for an additional charge.		 $12.50
Pretzel Sticks
Soft Bavarian pretzel twists baked with butter, topped with salt, and served with cheddar cheese dipping sauce		 $13.50
Spinach And Artichoke Dip
Chopped spinach and artichoke hearts in a warm creamy garlic parmesan dip served with tortilla chips		 $12.50
Calamari
Fresh floured or buffalo style calamari fried and served with a side of marinara sauce and lemon		 $16.50
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded mozzarella cheese served with a side of marinara sauce		 $13.50
Benchwarmers Sampler
Wings, mozzarella sticks, mini tacos, and potato skins		 $18.50
Marinated Steak Tidbits
Tender cuts of sirloin in our house marinade grilled to your liking served with garlic bread and horseradish cream sauce		 $19.55
Smothered Nachos
Tortilla chips topped with melted cheddar cheese, chili, olives, jalapenos, tomatoes, and lettuce served with salsa and sour cream		 $17.50
Soups and Salads
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, and croutons drizzled with Caesar dressing		 $12.95
Greek Salad
Iceberg lettuce topped with feta cheese, kalamata olives, capers, roasted red peppers, red onions, and tomatoes served with red wine vinaigrette dressing		 $16.95
Cranberry Salad
Iceberg lettuce topped with dried cranberries, red onions, walnuts, tomatoes, and cucumbers served with your choice of dressing		 $16.95
Garden Salad
Large garden salad with lettuces, tomatoes, carrots, onions, and croutons. Served with your choice of dressing		 $12.95
French Onion Soup
Bowl of our French Onion Soup topped with Swiss and mozzarella cheeses		 $7.75
Bruschetta Chicken Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with golden fried chicken, diced tomatoes, red onions, fresh mozzarella cheese, olive oil, and drizzled with balsamic glaze		 $17.50
Chili
Bowl of our fresh chili		 $7.75
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with crispy buffalo chicken, tomatoes, red onions, and chopped bacon served with your choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing		 $17.50
Chicken Noodle Soup
Bowl of our homemade chicken noodle soup		 $7.00
Sides of Sauce
Blue Cheese
2oz size of Blue Cheese		 $1.95
Honey Mustard
2oz side of Honey Mustard		 $1.95
Ranch
2oz side		 $1.95
Maple Mayo
2 oz side		 $1.95
Sour Cream
2oz side		 $1.95
Salsa
2oz side		 $1.95
Caesar Dressing
2oz side		 $1.95
Horseradish Sauce
2oz side		 $1.95
Balsamic Dressing
2oz side		 $1.95
Thousand Island
2oz side		 $1.95
BBQ Sauce
2oz side		 $1.95
Signature BW Sauce
2oz side		 $1.95
Marinara
2oz side		 $1.95
Buffalo Wing Sauce Hot
2 oz side		 $1.95
Buffalo Wing Sauce Mild
2 oz side		 $1.95
Burgers
Marinated Burger
A charbroiled burger marinated in our house recipe and grilled to your liking.		 $16.95
Cajun Burger
Lightly Cajun burger topped with crispy fried onion straws and drizzled with buffalo sauce.		 $16.95
Patty Melt
Burger smothered with melted swiss cheese and sautéed onion served on toasted marble rye bread.		 $16.95
Turkey Burger
8 ounces of freshly ground turkey grilled to perfection.		 $15.95
Plain Burger
Freshly ground beef grilled and served to your liking.		 $15.95
Cheese Burger
Burger served with your choice of melted american, swiss, mozzarella or cheddar cheese.		 $16.95
Boca Burger
Chopped vegetables made into a delicious burger substitute.		 $14.95
Sandwiches and Wraps
Reuben
Your choice of thin sliced corned beef or turkey topped with sauerkraut, swiss cheese and Russian dressing on grilled thick rye bread.		 $16.95
French Dip
Warmed Boar’s Head roast beef served on a toasted bun with melted mozzarella and served with a side of au jus for dipping.		 $17.95
Honey BBQ Chicken And Cheddar
Crunchy chicken tossed in our signature BBQ sauce served on a toasted hero with melted cheddar cheese.		 $16.95
Avocado Chicken Wrap
Grilled sliced chicken wrapped with crispy bacon,tomato, onion and avocado.		 $16.95
Steak Hero
Tender sliced steak topped with mozzarella cheese and crispy fried onions served on a toasted garlic hero.		 $17.95
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy buffalo chicken mixed with lettuce, tomato and bleu cheese dressing.		 $16.95
Blackened Chicken Fajita Wrap
Blackened chicken wrapped up with sauteed peppers and onions, jack cheese, and avocado.		 $16.95
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled sliced chicken mixed with romaine lettuce, croutons, pecorino-romano cheese and caesar dressing.		 $14.95
Baskets
Chicken Fingers Basket
(4) Chicken fingers served over a basket of French fries with a side of honey mustard.		 $17.95
Fish And Chips
Beer battered cod fillets cooked until golden brown with a side of french fries and tartar sauce.		 $16.95
Sweet Potato Waffle Fries Basket
Served with a side of homemade maple sauce.		 $11.95
Waffle Fries Basket $11.95
Onion Rings Basket $11.95
French Fries Basket $11.95
Tater Tot Basket $11.95
Kids Menu
Pasta
With butter or marinara sauce.		 $14.00
Grilled Cheese
Served with fries		 $14.00
Hot Dog
Served with fries.		 $14.00
Chicken Fingers
Served with fries.		 $14.00
Kids Burger
Served with fries.		 $14.00
Mac & Cheese
As a meal.		 $14.00
Dessert Menu
Chocolate Chip Brownie
Warm fudge brownie drizzled with chocolate syrup, whipped cream, and your choice of vanilla or chocolate ice cream		 $5.50
Tartufo
Vanilla and chocolate ice cream in a chocolate shell with a cherry and walnut center		 $5.50
Chocolate Ice Cream $3.25
Vanilla Ice Cream $3.25
Cheesecake
Creamy New York style cheesecake topped with whipped cream and raspberry drizzle		 $6.50
Beverages
Orange Juice $3.25
Apple Juice $3.25
Tomato Juice $3.25
Coffee $3.25
Iced Tea $3.25
Milk $3.25
Soda
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer, Seltzer, Ginger Ale, Lemonade, Iced Tea		 $3.25

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Anthony Vertucci
The food here is always top notch. It’s a small local restaurant bar with great food and drink and a fun atmosphere and a friendly, attentive staff in the restaurant or at the bar. They have live music on Fridays and Karaoke on Saturdays. You can’t go wrong for a fun night out or a great lunch or dinner with the family! I’ve never been disappointed.

… more

holly murtha
Dinner was good!!! French onion was good and the pastrami was the best I’ve had in a long time!

… more

Debbie
Fun place with lots of tv”s that have LOTS of good stuff on them to watch. Quickdraw is extroadinatily fun there too – can’t exactly say why. Probably because of the customers — must of whom were playing at the bar and laughing out up.

… more

June Mccarthy
Waitress is very nice and polite food is absolutely delicious I order french onion soup with no cheese and eggplant parmesan with a little cheese on it with your entree you can get pasta or french fries onion rings I didn’t want that she gave me a salad instead I would definitely recommend this place.

… more

Raymond Neff
The food is great and the people are very friendly and helpful. Great place to go and have dinner.

… more

v a
The staff were nice and friendly,and the food and drinks were good

… more

J I
Review is for the food alone. Tried the wings, mini tacos, and a burger. Wings- def won’t order them again they were extremely fatty and oily not enough actual meat. Mini tacos were like something you’d buy frozen at the grocery store. Really not good at all. Burger was ok nothing special. The regular fries were dry and flavorless, but the waffle fries were much better. The bartenders were attentive and looked like everyone there was having a good time. So ultimately wouldn’t get food there again, but just beer

… more

Anthony Auto
Food is great and the atmosphere is lively and fun. Great place to stop in and catch a game or play shuffleboard or sing a song on karaoke night! Always a great time!

… more

Greg Ruhe
I dare say the food was perfect here, something I never do!!!! I got a Ruben sandwich with tater tots on the side, both were perfectly made!!!! Wait staff is super friendly and helpful. I will definitely come back here when I’m back in the area

… more

J Grier
Overall thought is ws a nice evening until they added an additional $10 to my bill after left a respectable $12 cash tip on a $42 check. So in essence they gave themselves a 50% tip. I called to straighten it out only to be told by Ashley that someone would call me back. They never did, so sad to lose a bunch of money over an extra $10. All I can say is please pay attention to your bill when dinning or having drinks.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch