Local family-owned pizzeria with a record store vibe. Serving some of the area’s best pizza, breadsticks, pasta, salad, and calzone.
Known for the huge 24 Big Benito, which is a great centerpiece for your next catering event.
Some of the other classic eats include our oven baked subs, chicken wings, and delicious desserts.
Regional pizzeria chain offering flavored crusts & options ranging from thin-crust to deep-dish. Based on 115 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
25760 Pontiac Trail, South Lyon, MI 48178
Phone: (248) 446-7000
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brian Masserman
I was hired to take a few photos of their menu items recently. I also had the opportunity to try some of their dishes. Greg and Rachel are the NEW owners since November 2020. They are a very nice and dedicated couple and drive all the way out from Dearborn daily to serve the South Lyon community.
… more
Patricia Welsh
I am sorry to have to report this because I’ve had several wonderful dishes from Benito’s. But I just had GrubHub deliver a calzone that was horrible. The bottom of the box it came in was SOAKED with grease. when I took my first bite not only did grease drip out of it, it literally ran out. I couldn’t eat another bite. I ended up throwing it all the way.
… more
Val Cronin
Pizza slices were not cut all the way through, all the cheese and toppings slid right off when I tried to grab the slices. This happened because the pizza was still far too hot when they sliced it, so the cheese melted back together. The workers were nice and their establishment is comfortable and it tasted fine I just wish it was sliced better and when it had cooled a bit more.
… more
Rae M. G.
Seriously, the BEST Pizza in TOWN!!! My daughter is a picky eater and she approved by giving me two thumbs up! When I called, I told the lady I need a Medium round pizza with light ham (like I said, my kiddo is picky) Benitos listened and delivered a delicious pizza. I ordered the BLT and my goodness that was so good! Thank you, Benitos & thank you for greeting me when I came in. I’ll definitely be back!
… more
Scott Carlson
Tried to order a pizza over the phone from my go to pizza place(100+ time 96 we’re good). This time a young man(he/she/they/them) answered struggled so hard over the phone to take my order which was not complicated. I gave up. Complete incompetence. I won’t be back. If you can’t take a order for a large half blt and half bacon pizza you. You can’t make it or cook it correctly. Sad to say Benito’s is if my favorite list. And I got hung up on because it was too hard for him. Very disappointed
… more
Anna
This is one of the best pizza’s I have had in my life. Their sauce has seasoning and flavor. the mozzarella cheese was cooked perfectly on the pizza. I got their personal size pizza and it’s great. Here is a photo for reference.
… more
Khrysmari Albanese
Excellent customer service, great food… highly recommend it! You should come open one in Toronto, Canada!!!
… more
Sare Greenwood
Their pizza has some great potential but the last few times I got it, the bread was still doughy. Not a very good taste and we ended up tossing the last half. The lunch pizza is a good deal but it wasn’t fresh (and a little doughy.. So I got old doughy pizza ) I had to toss the other slice. I’d love for this place to succeed because when it’s good, it’s real good. I don’t think my wallet can handle the coin toss anymore.
… more
Stacey j
South Lyon, do yourself a favor and try this pizza! Top notch ingredients and the service is great!
… more
Steve Smith
Not very good. Found out they get their dough shipped twice a week from their commissary ‘frozen’ not fresh. This makes more sense now because the dough is chewey.
… more
… View more