Benny DiCarta’s Menu – Kalamazoo, MI

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Kalamazoo, MI

Based on 301 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Benny DiCarta's 49007

Address:
232 E Michigan Ave, Kalamazoo, MI 49007

Phone: (269) 903-2828

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–10 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–12 AM
Saturday 11 AM–12 AM
Sunday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

Slices & Whole Pies
Cheese Slice $5.75
Pepperoni Slice $6.75
Sliced Italian Sausage Slice $6.75
Garlic Mushroom Slice
Oven baked mushrooms seasoned with salt, pepper, oregano, and a hint of cayenne pepper. Mixed with chopped garlic.
$7.00
28″ Cheese (Whole Pie) $36.00
28″ Pepperoni (Whole Pie) $42.00
28″ Sliced Italian Sausage (Whole Pie) $42.00
1/2 Pepperoni & 1/2 Cheese Whole Pie $39.00
1/2 Italian Sausage & 1/2 Cheese Pizza $39.00
Whole Garlic Mushroom Pie $42.00
1/2 Cheese 1/2 Mushroom Whole Pie
A whole 28″ pizza with one half plain cheese, one half topped with our garlic mushrooms.
$39.00
Chips & Dips
Garlic Dipping Sauce $0.75
Side Of Marinara $0.75
Side Of Ranch $0.75
Original Potato Chips
Great Lakes Potato Chip Co, kettle cooked, skin on.
$2.00
Buffalo Wing Potato Chips $2.00
Barbecue Potato Chips $2.00
Seas Salt & Vinegar Potato Chips $2.00
Cans & Bottles
Bottled Water $1.50
Coke
12 oz.
$1.50
Diet Coke
12 oz.
$1.50
Sprite
12 oz.
$1.50
Dr. Pepper
12 oz.
$1.50
Pepsi
12 oz.
$1.50
Diet Pepsi
12 oz.
$1.50
Coke Zero
12 oz.
$1.50
Diet Dr Pepper
12 oz.
$1.50
Cherry Dr Pepper
12 oz.
$1.50
Vernors
12 oz.
$1.50
Mountain Dew
12 oz.
$1.50
Diet Mountain Dew
12 oz.
$1.50
Arnold Palmer Lite
11.5 oz.
$2.50
Sunny D
11.3 oz.
$1.50
Specialty Drinks
Sprecher Root Beer $3.50
Calypso Original Lemonade
16 oz.
$3.50
Calypso Ocean Blue Lemonade
16 oz.
$3.50
Calypso Strawberry Lemonade $3.50
Espresso Rootbeer
Northwoods Syrup Rootbeer infused with espresso
$3.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

G PV
Stopped in today for the first time and we loved everything about this pizza joint. Previously from Jersey it’s great to find a NY Pizza gem near by. The service was super friendly and helpful and the pizza slices were huge. We can’t wait to go back soon!

… more

Kevin Dorcy
Update: I stopped in again to give them another chance. Definitely met my pizza expectations. Crust was perfect, thin, with a little char under the carriage. Cheese mix was really nice, and the pep was so good.

… more

Caleb Rights
Great pizza huge box and 7 selections they cook it right there in front of you!

… more

Michael Austin
Read a few reviews and figured I would stop in for a quick slice before grabbing dinner later. The “Slice” was $6 even. I had no idea I would be getting not only the biggest slice I have ever had but also one of the best damn pizzas I have ever had. Sauce was on point, crust was nice and crispy. No flop at all on this baby

… more

Asia Barajas
Please do not be fools like us and ignore the fact that they only serve 28 inch pizzas. Therefore, those are the slice sizes you will be getting. We ordered 4 slices (not a smart move. We could have shared 1 lol) which basically added up to the size of your average pizza.

… more

Ashly Goike
Amazing pizza! Thin, crisp slice is very good! Dough has great flavor. 5 blend cheese is so tasty. Highly recommend!

… more

ari
It not the best pizza I have ever had, but it is definitely not the worst. A good option for a quick lunch or if you have a special event and you want to wow your guest. One of the few places around that you can get a pizza by the slice.

… more

Dorothy Kovacs
Enjoyed delicious enormous pizza more than once here while attending Beats on Bates. Listened to the live music from the deck. Easy parking nearby in the ramp on Burdick

… more

Kimber Kaya
I stopped in around 7pm on a Monday night. There was one table finishing up. Very short, simple slice menu that included approximately 5 varieties. Order and pay at the counter and your slice will be ready in about 5 min. There’s a wide variety of canned/bottled soft drinks. My can of Coke cost $1.50, my slice that was HUGE was $6 and some change. A slice of cheese will run you $5.

… more

Madelynne Tice
Huge pizza and it was delicious and the staff was super friendly! Thanks guys! Will definitely be back here again.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions