Based on 76 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
7531 S Virginia Dare Trail, Nags Head, NC 27959
Phone: (252) 715-1227
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Angelica Denham
Let me start this review with saying that I LOVE pizza. By far my favorite food and go to comfort food. When we go on vacation we like to find new pizza places to try. We have several that we have found over the years that we go back to. Benny Tesoros here at Nags Head will DEFINITELY be a place we return to when in the Outer Banks! The pizza was delicious! My favorite part is the crust, it was crispy but not overcooked. Just absolutely perfect! The sauce was also top notch! We only tried the pepperoni pizza with marinara and garlic dipping sauce on the side. I have to rate it a 10/10. There’s nothing I would change about the pizza. Everyone was so nice! The manager, I regret that I didn’t ask his name was super helpful and made sure we had everything we needed. He even recommended we try the cookie spot next door. We are happy to find that they have a location in Raleigh, NC which is closer to us when we come visit NC. Can’t wait to come back!
… more
Tammie Milliman
This was the biggest pizza I’ve ever seen!! It was delicious…we loved the crust it was really soft and the cheese and sauce was really good…the best pepperoni pizza I’ve had by far!! My husband put his hand on the box so everyone could see just how huge it truly was…was definitely worth the money and we will be back for more for sure
… more
Jaden Kendall
Great value for your money and by far the biggest slice I’ve ever seen. We came in on their grand opening weekend and were blown away. Welcoming atmosphere with a great location on the water and outside seating as well. Right next to a brewery too! The pizza has a perfect crunch on the bottom while maintaining that New York flop. Loved the Garlic Mushroom slice.
… more
Wayne Ramprashad
This pizza was huge. It’s the only size. I should have asked to have it double sliced. Make sure you have something to store the leftovers in. It won’t fit in the fridge or oven. The pizza was good hot and cold a few hours later. The serving staff was nice and friendly.
… more
Nancy Burns
Great pizza! Thin crust with a nice chew. The owner was super nice. Will be back. The pizza is HUGE! You can order by the slice as well.
… more
Richard O’keefe
Great pizza at the beach. Giant size piece and beautiful view. Grew up on Jersey Pizza and this is a hidden gem. We’ll be back!
… more
Brian Buller
Awesome pizzeria on the Outer Banks! HUGE slices, great views, affordable price!!
… more
Angie Brady-Daniels
Fun concept of really large pizza slices and pizzas. That made fun conversations with guests picking up orders and eating in. Loved the waterfront location right beside a local brewery with great beer. Was not overwhelmed by the pizza as it took a long time to get our order and the product was just ok. We added extra seasoning to our slices to make them tastier.
… more
Tony Moldovanyi
Have I had better pizza? Yes. But Benny’s IS really good and you can’t beat the atmosphere. And the size of a whole pizza is ridiculous.
… more
Kim DeBoisbriand
I gave a 4 for service because I called in for my pizza and they told me it would take 40 minutes. I showed up about five minutes early and when I got there they had not even started the pizza. So I had to wait outside with three children under the age of eight waiting for another 40 minutes. The staff was pleasant. The pizza was great and I would definitely go back in order again hoping I don’t have to wait.
… more
… View more