Benny’s Brown Bag is a creative sandwich, fine foods and craft beer store located in Peekskill, NY. We have a wide selection of curated foods & snacks, perfect for that unexpected party or picnic. Benny’s uses high-end deli meats & cheeses, fresh chicken & beef and we partner with local bakeries for our array of breads. We strive to make everything in-house to bring a new experience to Peekskill and beyond.
Based on 66 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 5.0 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No dine-in ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1100 Elm St, Peekskill, NY 10566
Phone: (914) 600-8848
Website: http://www.bennysbrownbag.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–4 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–4 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–4 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–4 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–4 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Edwin O’Brien
A+
… more
Vincenzo De Raco
Hit up Benny’s today and the sandwiches were straight fire. Love the old school feel. Great drinks chips and have to try the whole menu
… more
Chana
Service was pretty quick considering the number of staff. It’s got cute decor and neat snack selection. I would be down to return soon and try another sandwich soon!
… more
Jeff Nelson
Everyone is so nice and you can’t go wrong with anything!
… more
Matthew Milliken
“I think this is the best sandwich I’ve ever had in my life”
… more
Bradford Wason
Benny’s brings together fantastic sandwiches, an easygoing atmosphere, and an attentive, kind team. Drinks, chips, sandwich sides, and a well-stocked beer fridge help round out your visit. Be sure to save room for the banana pudding, which has large, fresh chunks of banana, a rich, creamy whipped cream, and a wafer base. The Thai Fried Chicken sandwich has two generous, well-breaded, and cooked pieces of chicken, and is completed with thinly sliced apple, a house-made slaw, and a sweet, tangy sauce, served on a seeded roll. If you’re looking for something lighter and Vegan friendly, both the Sky-High Veggie Stack and the Buffalo Chickpea sandwich are fantastic options. Thick, grilled, marinated tofu on the Veggie stack pairs exceptionally well with pickled cabbage, cucumber, and tomato. Meanwhile, the Buffalo Chickpea is packed high on toasted thick-cut white bread and finished with a bit of arugula and cucumber. Benny’s is a welcome addition to Peekskill, and I look forward to many return trips.
… more
David Meltzer
Delicious, fresh, and generous portions. Their Chimi Chimi Ya Roast Beef is perfection. We Love Benny’s!
… more
Amanda Rantuccio
Absolutely loved Bennys! Highly recommend the Chili Crisp Turkey sandwich – super tasty, perfectly balanced, gorgeous ciabatta bread and not too heavy.
… more
Peekskill Exurbanist
In a town filled with delis and corner stores (not a bad thing!) the new Benny’s really stands out!
… more
Maxine Gray
FINALLY! If you’re sick of overpriced, low quality deli sandwiches that you’re still hungry after eating, this is the place for you. Sandwiches are over $10, but it’s a meal, and they’re mouthwatering.
… more
… View more