Based on 169 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2660 PA-115, Effort, PA 18330
Phone: (570) 730-4343
Website: https://www.facebook.com/bennyspizza2/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Thegs
Definitely a 5/5 small pizzeria. It takes a bit for the food to come out, since it’s all made to order, but absolutely worth it. I’m a small guy though, and their personal pizza was bigger than I could personally eat. But! That’s leftovers 😉
… more
Tyler Glavocich
Some of the best pizza in the area! Very cheesy, saucy, and crispy!
… more
Marek Tchorzewski
I ordered tomato with garlic as toppings on my pizza. It was the best pizza I ever had. I gave some to a friend and he said same thing 10 out of 10. Best pizza in Poconos.
… more
Rebecca Coolong
I was promised New York pizza and they made a great one!
… more
Maureen Jendrzejewski
I am not a pizza lover, don’t hate, I’m Italian and grew up on sauce and am particular about where I eat it. Benny’s has excellently mastered their sauce. Excellent!
… more
Manda Gifford
You can taste the homemade love. The pizza dough is fresh and the pizzas are made to order. The wings are ok… coming from Texas, they need more rub options. It was Friday evening and it was packed! Need a larger waiting area for to go orders so dining in folks don’t feel crowded. Will be going back for sure!
… more
Lisa S
The food was good but they didn’t get the cheesesteaks correct. Specifically said no onions due to allergy but they put onions on anyway. The Sweet Chili Calamari was great.
… more
John Peterson
I ordered 2 hot subs, one meatball & one sausage. Both were over salted. The sausage had peppers and onions that I didn’t order..
… more
Angela Perez
This was the first time I have ever eaten at Benny’s 2. If I’m ever in that area again, I would definitely go back. There are 5 local pizzarias near me, and their pizza isn’t even a close second, to the pizza I had at Benny’s. I also had mozzarella sticks. They were perfect. Most times I get mozzarella sticks, they are too overdone, and barely any cheese left on the inside. The sauce also had a much better taste, then my local pizzarias. The owner was very friendly, and showed a great concern that you were happy with your food. Wish I lived closer, cause I would love to try other items on their menu.
… more
Tina Szelestei
Just pulled off the road from a long day of traveling and was looking for a quick real food place and the cheese steaks were old school good not greasy like some places and had lots of flavor
… more
… View more