Benny’s Off the Water Menu – Birdseye, IN

Type : Barbecue restaurant

Location : Birdseye, IN

Based on 282 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Benny's Off the Water 47513

Address:
2976 Dillard Rd, Birdseye, IN 47513

Phone: (812) 685-2095

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–8 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–7 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Paulina Brown
Very good food served by a sweet and funny waitress. I ordered a grilled chicken salad (no tomatoes) with ranch dressing. It was delicious, but the salad was like a shredded topping kind of lettuce if you don’t mind that. The ranch was also kind of chunky (though I may have just gotten the wrong kind and didn’t realize) but it was still good. The fries were the best I’ve had at any restaurant and the All Meat Pizza was my husband’s favorite, he recommends it to anyone who comes here.

… more

Margie Weatherholt
Service was wonderful for the crowd! Pizza was amazing as always! Loaded fries were a great buy, too. Tenderloin, wings, and burgers were good (just not as expected). Middle of the deck seating is a little loud/hard to hear your table.

… more

Brian Hite
Great food and place. Was a holiday weekend so it was busy. Didnt like the root beers at 2.50 a pop, but all else was good.

… more

Stephanie Bryant
BBQ pizza was outstanding, and the BBQ sandwich with slaw was delicious, too! Will definitely be back!

… more

David Lecklitner
Bar food. Everything fried! Not enough staff to quickly serve you, although they worked hard and still managed to take care of the large crowd. My breaded tenderloin was more like a fried pork chop. Delicious, yet a little fatty. My wife was happy with her fish sandwich. The French fries were tasty. Couldn’t eat it all. The iced tea was good. Not fine dining but overall a good meal.

… more

Ted Shepard
We were visiting nearby for the week and this was our closest option for getting something to bring back to our cabin. We ordered a pizza and some smoked wings. The pizza wasn’t the best I’ve ever had, but it wasn’t the worst either, the wings had a kind of slimy texture to them like they weren’t cooked enough. They pretty much have a monopoly in the area because of the lake and all the lodging surrounding them. It kind of had the feel of a fly by night operation, I’m sure some days are better than others when it comes to quality. I had no expectations when ordering, it is what it is.

… more

Jane Runge Darlage
Had heard their pizza was good, but was pleased to find it was superb! Crust was not too thick or thin; edge was just a touch crispy while rest of crust was delightfully chewy. They are generous with the cheese and toppings. Everything was just perfect! They have a nice kids menu and lots of sandwich, appetizer, salad and beer options. A lovely gem in an out-of-the-way locale. Well worth a drive. Serve was excellent, too, even though they were rocking a half hour before closing!

… more

Hannah Pierson
Atmosphere wasn’t bad, so I was expecting good service and good food. However, service was underwhelming. Host staff was rude and waitress was slow and inattentive. Not entirely the waitress’s fault though, considering we were a larger party and she told the host she didn’t want us seated in her section, probably due to having plenty of other tables already. Food was not very good to end up over $20.

… more

Ryan Wineinger
One of our favorite go to places for a Saturday or Sunday afternoon quick bite to eat. Anything smoked on the menu is always a no brainier, but it’s hard to beat the wings. BBQ pulled pork pizza is another favorite that is hard to pass up. The staff are always great and the laid back atmosphere on the deck makes for some relaxing dining!

… more

Jason Evans
We had a large group for lunch on Saturday and the service and food was great! The Hoosier tenderloin was amazing. 100% recommend this restaurant.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions