Based on 109 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
52 Main St, New Paltz, NY 12561
Phone: (845) 255-1999
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12 PM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tony Link
Fire pizza!!!! If you’re looking for that OG Brooklyn style pizza that fills you just right without overdoing it or breaking the wallet and with great conversation, this is the place. Stop in, grab a slice, or 2 and get them taste buds what they deserve….
… more
Ruby Montoya
Great little Spot !! Amazing Pizza !! I wish they had more juice drinks not a soda drinker but I guess I’ll bring my own drink ..lol. but definitely recommend this place to any who’s never tried their pizza !! Delicious
… more
Tavish Laidlaw
Certainly not the best pizza. not awful, but not the best, especially for the price.
… more
Nikki Pison
No. Not best. Not even mediocre. Their “best” plain large pizza was $23 and barely edible. Flat, flavorless chewy thin crust with barely a sprinkling of cheese. Only highlight- about two pieces of basil, but they could not rescue this pie.
… more
Drew Kozlowski
Great pizza, supper thin and crispy. There’s just a special kind of pizza that can have a super thin crust and light cheese and be the most delicious thing ever. It is slightly more expensive than the other pizza shops around but it is totally worth it, because you can tell the ingredients are fresh and not pre bagged/prepared.
… more
Colleen Zayas
The pizza was best I’ve tried so far in area. The bottom was a little too burnt taste from oven but again it was a Sunday and busy. The cheese was food quality with sauce and definitely would go back. Service was fast and efficient.
… more
Nick Duque
really 1 of only 2 good spots for pizza in New Paltz. It’s a little pricier than other places but way higher quality and tastes really good. Pies are very big too. Good meatball/eggplant parms. I’m very picky about pizza sauce, but in my opinion, theirs is perfect. I could eat their sauce straight up with a spoon tbh. My only complaint would be that I ordered a side of meatballs one time and was pretty disappointed at the portion size. Four itty bitty meatballs (I mean tiny) and like 8 toast points lol… Can’t complain about the taste though. They were delicious.
… more
Maryann
Good pizza. But, disappointed to find out their grandma pizza has anchovies in the sauce after looking online. In store there is no signage or warning from their staff that there’s anchovies. My partner confronted the staff about this and they shrugged it off. This is a serious concern and fish allergies are real. Please add signage when there’s fish included in your slices in the case. Not everyone looks at the online menu.
… more
Dakota P
I didn’t think I’d ever eat pizza that reminded me of NYC since being upstate. This pizza sauce & cheese are delicious, the crust is crunchy. Top tier pizza. You’d be silly to go anywhere else, I mean it is called best pizza for a reason!
… more
Mary Fiero
Came here one night to grab a quick bite with my boyfriend before meeting up with some friends. Ordered 4 slices of pizza. The guy at the counter told us if we waited a few more minutes he could give us all new fresh slices. It was super good.
… more
… View more