Spacious pizzeria provides slices & pies (including a stuffed version) plus signature garlic knots. Based on 767 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1103 Key Plaza, Key West, FL 33040
Phone: (305) 293-9576
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jack Carello
Big John’s Pizzeria Is Great! Their pizza is good. The interior is decorated beautifully with the lights, and all the great Italian decorations. There’s indoor and outdoor seating. Without doubt I recommend Big John’s Pizzeria. Have a great day!
… more
Lazaro Carrillo
This place has a nice atmosphere and good customer service but on the other hand, there is the food including drinks the day we went there. Pizza was nice but a bit burned, cheese had no flavor and fountain drinks were bad, no flavor at all, just like drinking water.
… more
J B
Pizza was just above average. The wings were way overcooked with no seasons except the hot sauce. Food came out fast and fresh but just didn’t get the hype on this restaurant.
… more
Sheneeza Misir
Amazing pizzeria! Wings, pizza, and garlic knots were so good. I heard the garlic knots are a popular item here and I can see why!
… more
A Muncie Experience
One of the best mom and pop pizzerias in the Florida Keys! Everything was delicious! The all-the-way pizza couldn’t have been better. Loaded with toppings on a New York style crust. The salad was perfect as an appetizer along with their famous garlic knots! Plenty of garlic butter and parmesan cheese on crispy outside yet doughy inside bread bites. The spaghetti was great with a huge portion and more garlic knots! All you can drink fountain pop as well! The staff was very friendly and polite when we ordered and took very good care of us. They also serve and sell a variety of wines and desserts! Located in Key Plaza, a must try pizza joint in the New Town of Key West. Very pleased and will definitely be back next time!
… more
Nicole
Photos should speak for themselves. For 25+ years of experience, this place knows what they’re doing. Best place for good food & a good time. Next time you’re in key west & want GOOD new york style italian food, eat at BIG JOHN’S!!
… more
Tracy Gray
In Key West and found this little jewel. We were here for 5 days & we ate here 3 times. Pizza crust was amazing. Pasta was good, ( could have used more sauce) and the sandwiches were huge & delicious. Arrived fast & hot!!!
… more
Ileana Garcia
This place has become a rip off. They charged me $20 for a small pizza and then argued that it was not a small pizza. And the ladies that work there especially the one that answers the phone is super rude. Argued with about my pizza.. zero customer service. I’m extremely disappointed and will never order from there again.
… more
Michael Logan
As a Conch Local that’s traveled and eaten lots of good Italian.. Omg what a surprise, this was so good! I’m stuffed and so happy I tried this place out! Exceeded my expectations and so glad we have a place this good for Italian for the people! Omg once again seriously I’m taking everyone here when they visit! Eggplant Parm with Garlic knots was omg so good I’m going back again tomorrow for the same thing.
… more
shawn lasher
This is the best pizza I have tried in all of the keys. You can tell that the ingredients are fresh and very good quality. It’s very cliche to say the best New York style pizza but honestly the crust is some of the best I have ever eaten. Thank you BIG JOHN!
… more
… View more