Based on 439 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
15412 Illinois Rte 59, Plainfield, IL 60544
Phone: (815) 267-6155
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–7 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–8 PM |
| Saturday | 12–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jeanine
What a gem to find. The staff is really helpful and friendly, which speaks volumes in todays industry standards. The garlic knots were recommended to us, and they are SO delicious & sauce tasted homemade. The pizza we chose had mushrooms, onion, green pepper and sausage and it was cooked to perfection. What I liked about the pizza the most is that it wasn’t too heavy. I left the restaurant feeling good, not weighed down and bloated. We will most certainly be back.
… more
Les O’Connor Jr
Very nice and reasonably priced pizza place! Wife/I did a small build-your-own pizza to get our favorite toppings, but they also have several different specialty pizzas that cover a variety of tastes. There is a small selection of beers/wine available, but there’s no bar, so no mixed drinks/cocktails. The restaurant was very clean, the wait staff was exceptionally friendly & attentive, and the owner also introduced himself and engaged in conversation with us, explaining the history of the family restaurant. Enjoyed the pizza and will go back in the near future to try some other menu items. Somewhat of a small space, not a lot of seating, so be careful about the time you choose (weekend evenings may get crowded quickly), but overall, I would definitely recommend it.
… more
Gloria “Gigi” Mendez
We totally enjoyed our food and service. We order the garlic knots. OMG, they were the best garlic knots we ever had! Mac and cheese was cooked perfectly, adding some alfredo sauce and took it to another level. The Butchers pizza was a tad salty, but it was full of flavor and the sauce was great. The cinque formaggio was delicious . Be prepared to spend some $$, but it is worth it. Come and try this place, at least just for the garlic knots!
… more
Michael Murphy
We came for the 1st time. The menu was almost too good to choose one. We went for the Great White. AMAZING. we also had the garlic knots. KILLER GOOD!! The corn was a unique twist and delicious. The staff was amazing. You need to get in here in get their food in your face!!! You will not be disappointed. Already planing the next trip
… more
Stephanie S.
A friend recommended this place to me last year and since then my husband and I have been here about 5 times. The pizza is amazing and we always get the Buffalo wings as an appetizer. The Buffalo wings are super spicy so be aware of that. I do wish you got more than 6 wings for the price but it’s a small business so I’m willing to overlook that.
… more
Amanda Szypulinski
We ordered a pepperoni pizza. The sauce is so good! We also ordered a kids spaghetti and meatballs. It came with one giant meatball. (Wish it came with two!) the meatball tasted really good too. Kids and myself loved it all!
… more
Matthew Peterson
The garlic knots were freaking delicious. The pizza was solid (very garlicky) but good. What really made this restaurant 5-stars was the service.
… more
Vernon Hammond
Probably the BEST overall experiences that I have been to, from the food, service, and atmosphere. Emily, my waitress was amazing and awesome. And the staff was very friendly. I really enjoyed this place ☺️
… more
Nicholas Eaton
The food was good. I enjoyed the pizza. I thought it was a little overpriced. The salad was very fresh with an amazing blue cheese dressing.
… more
Becky Maza
Chef’s Table-Steak Night was a delicious success! Absolutely everything was amazing. Big Pauly’s pizza is my absolute favorite pizza, but this was a fun way to further explore their food. We got a closer look into many of their techniques and cooking gadgets that help them get the mouthwatering depth of flavor in something as ‘simple’ as cheese. Interactive and scrumptious. It was a social event where we were able to put the names to many of the faces we’ve seen on many other nights while grabbing a slice.
… more
… View more