Based on 157 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
746 Main St, Margaretville, NY 12455
Phone: (845) 586-4884
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 12–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Bryan Cabo
I’ll start with the decor inside, on the water, outdoor eating and overall ambience was pretty great. Beautiful place. The server was very attentive and obviously concerned with our experience. She was lovely. (I’ve seen some mixed reviews about service)
… more
He Wi
The service was warm and professional. The outdoor seatings were great, especially for warm summer weather and the view of the river was great. The town was pretty nice. We ordered buffalo wings and soup of the day which was kale/bean soup sprinkled with bacon and cheese. Both were good but I wish the wings were crispier. Price was a bit lower than NYC’s.
… more
Steve Dempsey
Ate here a few times, high end bar with both bar and restaurant seating and a deck outside. Craft beer selection and full on menu of staple dishes like steak as well as appetizers and desserts.
… more
Bryan Chadwick
We had a good experience at the bar, bartender was kind and interested. We had the wings and chicken soup, both very tasty.
… more
Jessica Clopton
Some of the worst service I’ve ever received. Upon arrival we were yelled at by the hostess for booking on OpenTable because apparently they don’t give you the table you request (out vs in). She begrudgingly sat us outside anyway. Hey, OpenTable works for other restaurants so that’s kinda on you, lady. Not our problem. We were then served lukewarm water by the other hostess. After about 15 minutes our server finally took our drink order. She took our whole entire appetizer and dinner order as well since we’d been there so long already. The food came out in a reasonable amount of time. The server placed the crab cakes down and said “bang, bang. Bang, bang” which was confusing at best. The bang bang shrimp finally came along with my watery chili covered in GRATED CHEESE. Weird. And no spoon. I felt bad for the server at that point so I let it go and just ate it with a fork. Underwhelming. Our check took a solid 25 minutes. We finally asked the host for it but she ignored us. So I raised my voice and asked a second time to make sure she heard us. The taller host should really not be in customer service. She was a b**** supreme. The server and shorter host were super nice. It was just ridiculous. Probably won’t go back
… more
Christine Foster
Food was very good, however the staff was noticeably biased towards the regular customers that frequent this establishment. Our wait staff was not very accommodating , yet made menu variations for other people.When asked if they had beets, she said No, however my daughters salad had beets in it! Also took a long time to settle the bill.
… more
eric j
This place is awesome; excellent ambiance, staff, and food.
… more
Susan Eberth
The waitress incorrectly informed us that the chile was mildly spicy but it was the spiciest chili that we ever tasted!
… more
Marilia Riva-Andrade
The vegan option, the chili, was delicious!! Our server also informed us of how the soup of the day could be made vegan too, a cream of asparagus, and it was amazing. The hot cider was perfect, especially on such a cold day!
… more
Benjamin Osborn
Non-existent service. We made a reservation for 7:30. Forty-five minutes later no one had even spoken to us, much less taken a drink or food order. There was not even water at the table. We left. As no other place was open in town at that hour, we purchased food at the adjacent supermarket for our dinner. We will not be returning to Binnekill Tavern.
… more
… View more