BJ’s Market Street Tavern & Oyster Bar Menu – Selinsgrove, PA

Type : Oyster bar restaurant

Location : Selinsgrove, PA

In historic building with a patio, this warm tavern offers BBQ, chops & seafood, plus a full bar. Based on 855 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery

BJ's Market Street Tavern & Oyster Bar 17870

Address:
17 N Market St, Selinsgrove, PA 17870

Phone: (570) 374-9841

Website: https://www.bjsmstreet.com/

Hours

Wednesday 4–10 PM
Thursday 4–10 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11:30 AM–11 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 4–10 PM
Tuesday 4–10 PM

Menu

Desserts
Juniors Original Cheesecake
Skyscraper Fudge Cake
Classic Crème Brulee
Snicker’s Pie
Hot Drinks
The Original Irish Coffee
Toboggan Truffle
Toasted Almond Café
Mexican Monk
Hot Green Tea
Firey Hot Chocolate
Seasonal Cocktails
Apple Cider Margarita
Maple Sour
Salted Carmel Butterscotch White
Plum Prosecco Smash
Others
Irish Point
Standish Shore- Massachusetts
Malpeque
Deep Water Wellfleets- Massachusetts
Rhode Island Top Neck Clams
Clams Casino
Oyster Casino
Oyster Rockefeller
Wine Garlic Clams
Jumbo Gulf Shrimp

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Pamela Hecey
I had such a wonderful experience Tuesday night at BJ’s! We sat on the quaint patio and had amazing service by Haley and everybody else were very nice as well. The food was delicious and came out in a timely manner! I just wish we lived closer! We live in Cleveland and we were going to Knoebels for the day! I highly recommend this place the atmosphere the great little town it’s in the food and the service were all top notch!!

… more

Brandon P
We were in the area and wanted a quick bite to eat but had our dogs with us, so we decided to come here because they had some outdoor seating. As far as service the servers, they were pleasant and seemed accommodative, especially since we were the only people outside. As far as the food, it was tasty and portion sizes seemed plenty. As far as prices, they seemed on par with what this resturant was providing and what we were expecting. If we were in the area we would consider stopping here again.

… more

Erica Schaeffer (theClickery)
We haven’t eaten here for many years. The Jalapeno Burger was delicious. The crab dip was pretty good, but I did not care for the Old Bay Crab Egg Rolls. The description sold us, but it didn’t live up to its name. Lacking in old bay and crab meat and the egg roll itself overpowered the flavor or lack thereof. Service was very efficient and fast.

… more

Larry Weader
Consistently one of the best places in PA. Fresh oysters are fantastic, and I just had a sea bass entree that was one of the 10 best meals of my life! Service is always top shelf also.

… more

Lisa Sanchez
First time there. Wonderful service. Delicious food. Coconut shrimp..amazing

… more

John Mullen
Really good food.. great time we had there.. music was awesome.. service was outstanding. The staff was incredibly helpful..Would definitely recommend having a few meals at this place. The wings were really tasty and the cornbread/cake was really good as well… well we went back for another meal.. a celebratory one.. service was great.. food was great.. did miss the strawberry shortcake that I had before but the snicker pie deal was pretty damn good also

… more

Paul Peters
Good food, great atmosphere fair prices. Cooked to order steak. Good desserts. On street parking can be a challenge! Would venture back here when in the area!

… more

UnderCat Cards
The food was so good!! Their homemade salad dressing was so tasty we bought a container to take home- A++

… more

Jody Ramer
BJ’s has really gone downhill over the past few years. Our last meal, bongo bongo was burnt, house salad dressing was straight oil (waitress did get us new salads and dressing, she was great!), iced tea sweetener was watered down and didn’t sweeten the tea, and the steak salad was supposed to be medium and was well done. You get 1 piece of cornbread/person as long as you order an entrée. So sad compared to what it was like just a few years ago.

… more

Auguste
What a wonderful restaurant! The food at BJ’s Market Street Tavern and Oyster Bar was absolutely perfect and delicious. We had not one complaint about anything. From the atmosphere to the service, from the employees to our meal everything was spot on.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions