Based on 774 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
4797 York Rd, New Oxford, PA 17350
Phone: (717) 624-8987
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Matt Bitner
It seems like it would be a great place when its a warm day, but we stopped in after the temperature had dropped and were not disappointed. We had the big easy, fish and chips, french onion and chicken tenders. They were all good but the clear winners were the big easy and the French onion. The burger was cooked perfectly and tasted great. The brisket in the French onion was delicious. I really liked the atmosphere as well with the vaulted ceiling.
… more
roger parnell
Great spot off Rt. 30…beautiful indoor with an awesome Bourbon wall with a ton of selections and a very nice outdoor seating area…even volley courts set up outside…great relaxing stop…
… more
Kala Stasiak
Love the renovations and the the food was delicious. They have a great selection of booze as well. Had my favorite tequila (Altos) which most places don’t carry.
… more
Jonathan Dingus
Limited menu outside until 4pm. With that being said, the crab burger and everything else we got off of that menu was delicious!.. there’s always things to do, especially on the weekends! Atmosphere is great, staff was very pleasant!.. definitely will be back!
… more
James Strand
This place is gorgeous, they did some great renovations to it. Unfortunately the only thing consistent about their service is their inconsistency. Long wait, short wait but wrong food, dropped my food on the floor. The staff themselves are very friendly but just always seems like there aren’t enough of them. My last visit I’m pretty sure the lady who took my order was making the food too, as well as tending bar, it was chaotic. I do like the food though, just haven’t had a great experience there yet. I know I know, I keep going back, so that should tell you how good the food is, it’s worth it when I have the time and patience to be inconvenienced. I would eat there more if I knew I wouldn’t be waiting three hours for a table of four to get fed. But when I have the time, I’ll hit them up, but usually only when going with friends who want to go there.
… more
F689 UZRC Heinrich
I had dinner here twice during the week. The first time I had the crab cake tacos and enjoyed them. The prices are very reasonable. Two days ago I had the meatloaf and they were served over mashed potatoes. The meatloaf had a nice taste however there is only one small piece and the potatoes were a bit cold. I would not order them again.
… more
Shawn Poole
The food here held up to the expectations that have been put out about The Bourbon Mill. I got the Crab pretzel and I’d like to say WOW! When they came out with it my jaw dropped because I knew it was going to be big but wow was I amazed at how big it really was. And it tasted just as good as it looked! Definitely recommend the bourbon mill to anyone who wants a laid back place to eat. FYI, the patio is the best place to sit.
… more
Jim Rice
We have been going to this place for years and loved it till now. The dining room was seat your self and only had a few people for a Sat. evening, which was weird. Normally it would be packed. We ordered wings and a sub which took 55 mins. The sub only had a little bit of meat and did not have the toppings that was listed on the menu. They actually gave me a bag of UTZ chips instead of chips on my plate. The wings were dry. Something has diffidently changed with this place. We are so disappointed because we always had a good time there, but not going back.
… more
Ric Ravier
Great Location, good beer selection, big outdoor areas, Dog Friendly Section on the patio behind the pavilion. The prices are very reasonable. The food was a little disappointing, but I would go back and get a Cheesesteak. I saw a few, and they looked amazing. The steak that was on the salad was very low quality tasting. Not sure if it was the prep or what, but the burgers and sandwiches looked delicious.
… more
Paul Peters
It was great finding this place! Food was delicious,plentiful and reasonably priced! Service, staff friendly and helpful. We were quickly seated and server was friendly and quick with drinks and food! Rustic atmosphere which everyone enjoyed!
… more
… View more