Old-fashioned, family-operated pizzeria providing pies, subs & salads as well as beer & wine. Based on 778 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
3557 Fayetteville Rd, Lumberton, NC 28358
Phone: (910) 738-2002
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Portia Moore
We just moved to the area and found this place by searching Google for ‘pizza near me’. The pictures are what sold me because we usually order well done – that browned cheese in every shared photo had me curious! I didn’t see a website, so I called to place an order. The pizzas only come in Small or Medium, so we went for medium! So glad we did! The pizza was the perfect crunch on the crust, the pepperoni is under the cheese, the sauce is SO good, and that browned cheese… oh baby! We also ordered the Buffalo wings. Those came with ranch and a bag of chips, which was a pleasant surprise! They were crispy, and everything was hot. We will definitely be back!
… more
Trenia Pevia
Salad was lots of ice berg lettuce with 1 slice of cucumber pic attached… Ordered lasagna special… No longer exist even though on menu board… It was cold.. Most upset. Almost $18 including tea.. Wtw happened?
… more
Ashleigh Shaw
I’ve been going to this place all my life, I turned 40 last month. I hadn’t been since COVID came so my mama, my son and I went for her birthday. It was awful! The spaghetti tasted like burnt chili instead of spaghetti. It had a funky texture, almost gritty. Will not be going back any time soon.
… more
Kayla Singletary
The service and food were amazing. We actually hadn’t been here in a while until tonight the food taste like it use to before covid. The restaurant was very clean. The owner was very nice and appreciative of our business.
… more
Stephen byrd
Ordered a small turkey sub. Used to come with french fries, now they just throw a small bag of chips in there. The sandwich was also sub-par at best with poor quality ingredients. Inside, the place looked like a dump, with half the seating area in the dining room now filled with styrofoam take-out trays. I’ve been patronizing this place since they opened, but they sure have gone down-hill, and I won’t be going back. Thank god for Jersey Mike’s!
… more
Paula Lee
Bravo Pleasant Pizza use to have the best subs and the subs were loaded with ingredients and the small came with fries. Now all you get is bread and you pay extra for fries and it looked like a disaster area. Was very unappealing. I know the price of everything has gone up since covid but we could have went to Texas Steakhouse and ate for what 2 small subs with fries and 2 drinks cost. I definitely will not be going back anytime soon.
… more
Natalie James
We stopped off here after driving 4 hours on the highway. Craving good pizza. This place did not disappoint. Friendly staff and the pizza is to die for! Decor was pretty as well.
… more
Leonardo Cicerone
A hidden Gem …What a fabulous old school restaurant! This place is authentic Italian/Greek.. we got out there the place was closed but Yanni, the owner decided to open up for us. Absolutely fantastic pizza! Super great staff very responsive owner great food! Recommend this to everyone friends & family and all others!
… more
Debra of SENC
We have dined here for many years and still highly recommend this place. They are local and family owned. We have never been disappointed with our meals. They have renovated since we were here last and the place is beautiful on the inside. The food and service was excellent. We ordered spaghetti with meat sauce. It was delicious.
… more
Blake Wolanin
highlight: MOLDY SALAD
… more
… View more