Based on 89 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
462 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: (845) 791-7200
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nancy
This place has the best service & thin crust pizza. The delivery people are very nice and friendly he food is very hot when it’s delivered .
… more
ALBERT BIANCHINO
Excellent excellent pizza it tastes very very good and authentic like they made it back in the 80s I haven’t tasted Pizza like that since I was a kid and I’m going to be 47 tomorrow March 25th that’s like 30 years I have pizza that good
… more
Jay C
First time ordering, the person who answered the phone was very rude, deceptive, and misleading about pricing, deals and taxes. At the moment, I do not not recommend, the service really “rubbed me the wrong way” I will be speaking with the owner, unless that was the owner on the phone, In that case, I will never order from there agaian…
… more
Fatima Davidson
I like the employees there, the atmosphere is calming. When wanting pizza, this is the First place I think of.
… more
Harsh Kelawala
New management has messed up everything their buffalo chicken pizza is now worst in the area and also prices are higher now NEVER TRY THEIR BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA.(This is my old review when there was a old managment they have really good Buffalo chicken pizza and they deliver on the time.) They don’t know how much buffalo sauce and cheese to put in.
… more
Barbara Harrison
DELIVERY! They always say they will be a wait of 45min or longer. But I find they are much quicker. Prices are decent. Garlic knots are tasty.
… more
LatinaBeauty Jc
*One of the worst tasting pizza I’ve ever had, staff seem friendly tho,
… more
C S
First pizzeria choice was closed, so I searched for a another one and I am so glad I found Broadway Pizza, because I am completely sold. Crust is thin and delicious, honest price, place owned by a family. We Ordered mozzarella with fresh garlic, mushroom and tomatoes and I wish I had ordered a large one instead! I don’t normally post reviews but they deserve every star above!
… more
Sha Fay
Extra greasy pizza and not that good and when you order through DoorDash it takes forever to get your food. Ordered tonight and at the hour and a half mark I finally contacted DoorDash for a credit. Every other restaurant delivers fast through DoorDash
… more
Xan Star
First time trying it since the switched owner have to say it’s not good anymore. The crust was thin and non existent and the sauce bitter. What was once one of my favorite pizza places is now not. To tell you the cold honest truth the pizza is making my stomach, I miss the way it tasted before I could finish a pizza by myself back then but the pizza now I cant even eat more then a slice.
… more
… View more